which town would you prefer ?

[patriceflanders]

My daughters and I are wondering which towns of ours would be the most popular (if any) amongst you guys... (the whole package: layout, fruit, villagers, etc)

Paarl (my town):

- fruit: peaches
- villagers: Fang, Whitney, Fauna, Elvis, Beau, Tabby, Marina, Diana, Tangy and Chief
- perfect status
- full main street

Seabell (youngest daughter):

- fruit: cherries
- villagers: Tia, Savannah, Papi, Ozzie, Hugh, Diana, Ruby, Lobo, Yuka and Marshal
- perfect status
- T&T

Tasmania (middle daughter):

- fruit: apples
- villagers: Julian, Coco, Cole, Ankha, Erik, Tangy, Rasher, Kiki and Wolfgang
- perfect status
- T&T

Oishii Ai (eldest daughter):

- fruit: pears
- villagers: Rosie, Julian, Marina, Skye, Tia, Whitney, Wolfgang, Marshal, Francine and Chrissy
- perfect status
- very basic main street




maybe also post below why to prefer one to another

red little person = location mayor's house



THANKS FOR HELPING US OUT HERE !

 

[MightyMunchlax]

I think it's cool all of you have your tree plazas in the bottom middle part of town, and that you and your oldest have almost the same map. (Which btw I really like the map). I guess Oishii Ai would have to be my favorite even though I like your map a bit more, but I like the villagers and the map. I really like Seabell's villagers as well. Cute towns!

 

[whiskerlickins]

I love that your event plazas are below the river! I'd have the same if I had the guts to start over.

 

[patriceflanders]

thanks folks...

more comments ?

 

[menrfrommagmar]

Paarl seems like it's easiest to get from the dock to retail after a successful bug hunt. :3

 

[marierock13]

Seabell, to me, has the nicest combination of villagers. I'm also a sucker for cherries, one of the nicest-looking town fruits.

Looking at the maps, I'd also have to say that Seabell has a well balanced layout, with nothing standing out to me as awkward or misplaced.

That said, if you are wondering for which town to post a dream address (in your signature or otherwise), to be honest, I would be interested in visiting all of them. Any town into which time and effort has been put is interesting to me, and I personally enjoy visiting as many different dreams as I can.

Just my two cents.

 

[patriceflanders]

Seabell, to me, has the nicest combination of villagers. I'm also a sucker for cherries, one of the nicest-looking town fruits.

Looking at the maps, I'd also have to say that Seabell has a well balanced layout, with nothing standing out to me as awkward or misplaced.

That said, if you are wondering for which town to post a dream address (in your signature or otherwise), to be honest, I would be interested in visiting all of them. Any town into which time and effort has been put is interesting to me, and I personally enjoy visiting as many different dreams as I can.

Just my two cents.

yes, Seabell is nice, BUT I have a problem with the fact that, for some reason, I wasn't "allowed' to put the main bridge perfectly aligned with the plaza tree... it bothers me...

- - - Post Merge - - -

the same goes for Oishii Ai

 

[Red Cat]

I like Seabell because the map layout is very similar to my town and it has cherries which are the fruit of my town. It looks like the easiest map to get around and the ponds are out of the way. The only thing I don't like is the police station placement as I like it next to the train station like in my town and the other towns here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

yes, Seabell is nice, BUT I have a problem with the fact that, for some reason, I wasn't "allowed' to put the main bridge perfectly aligned with the plaza tree... it bothers me...

- - - Post Merge - - -

the same goes for Oishii Ai

I have the same problem in my town as I have that exact same bend in the river in the center of the map.

 

[QoQ]

Paarl has the slight edge over Oishii Ai (IMO). I like the idea of 3 cranky's and love all your villagers (Tabbys actually one of my old time favorites). Your dock-bridge path leading to retail actually is the main reason I think its the best and if you swapped Beau for Julian then it would be no contest lol. A few other things I like about Oishii Ai though... (the name sounds fitting with the native fruit and the campsite seems to be in a really nice spot).

 

[Toadette]

All so nice looking! If I HAD to choose one, I would choose Paarl! I love the layout and the beach slope on the bottom!

 

[peachesandicecream]

I really like Tasmania map!

 

[RoseNitemare]

I ended up voting for Tasmania for a few reasons.

1: Apples are my favorite of the fruit, though peach is a close second.

2: I currently have Ankha in my town, and I've had Julian before, so I like the villagers more. Fauna is one of my favorites too though, and Rosie is just precious.

3: The map looks fuller. With the way things are layed out, it looks like a cute busy little town, and I love that. Seabell is the same way. Paarl and Oishii Ai (judging from the map at least) are more spread out and have a bit of open space. There are pros and cons to both layouts, however. In the cluttered towns, it's easier to decorate because you have smaller areas that you have to fill in, but at the same time there's less space for the larger pwp's or for any extravagant layouts. For the more spread out/sparse maps it's the reverse.

Anyway, those are my reasons. They honestly all seem pretty great, and the full main street on Paarl is impressive, but Tasmania ended up being slightly better. For me at least.

 

[Royce]

Paarl it seems cute!

 

[kasane]

Oishii Ai has an intriguing layout. Cool symmetrical southern part of the town lol. Also pretty cool as to how Paarl and Oishii Ai have a similar layout, and likewise for Seabell and Tasmania!
Paarl has the best villagers imo and Seabell has best fruit.

 

[Shiny Spritzee]

Seabell is such a beautiful name for a town. I really like the layout, and it has cherries which are my favourite and one of the best looking fruits. The villagers are sooo cute, especially Lolly, Bunnie and Diana.

But Oishii Ai has the best layout, with the way the 3 bridges are placed it looks so neat on the map. The villagers are some of my very favourites. For this reason I would choose Oishii Ai but they all look so wonderful.

 

[Arcticfox5]

All of these towns seem very great from what I can tell. They all have great villagers and layout. I think I like Tasmania best, but Paarl is a very close second. I like how the villager houses are all spread out over the town and I like to combination of villagers. I like the shape of the river and the placement of the bridges. The only thing that I find is a bummer is the fact that one of the villager houses is blocking one of the bridges, but that is just a minor detail.

Overall, you all have great towns and should be proud of your achievements!

 

[patriceflanders]

for those who want to have a "real" look :

DA's :

PAARL : 6600-4628-2156 (4 "humans" - full houses) / fairy-tale theme / all DLC
SEABELL : 6100-4544-2483 (3 "humans" - 2 full houses) / no theme really (bit modern) / some DLC
TASMANIA : 6600-5552-5401 (3 "humans" - 2 full houses) / modern / some DLC
OSHII AI : 6100-5014-4991 (2 "humans" - full houses) / nature zen theme / little DLC


if you should visit, maybe you can tell us which room of all those, you find prettiest


THANKS AGAIN

- - - Post Merge - - -

Seabell, to me, has the nicest combination of villagers. I'm also a sucker for cherries, one of the nicest-looking town fruits.

Looking at the maps, I'd also have to say that Seabell has a well balanced layout, with nothing standing out to me as awkward or misplaced.

That said, if you are wondering for which town to post a dream address (in your signature or otherwise), to be honest, I would be interested in visiting all of them. Any town into which time and effort has been put is interesting to me, and I personally enjoy visiting as many different dreams as I can.

Just my two cents.

especially for you : see my post above

 

[EvilSide]

My favorite town map is by far Oishii Ai's. That symetry... it's so nice, it looks like butterfly wings with the river. Seabell has some cool villagers too.
I visited all the dream towns. I liked the fact that Paarl is settled during autumn, we only see few towns in this season which I think is a shame. The wide paths were cool too, it looked nice around the town hall and firepit (I really like random bushes surrounded by paths!). My favorite room was Patrice's 2nd floor :>
In Seabell, I loved the exterior of Harry's house, as well as the main room, and Tasmania, my favorite room was Gwijde's basement.
I really enjoyed Oishii Ai's design, I think it's my favorite out of the four. The paths are so pretty, and they fit well with the theme. The right room in Mio's house was my favorite. This town is really relaxing, and the humans characters were so cute too! Gotta keep the DC somewhere.
These where nice towns to visit overall, good job !

 

[patriceflanders]

bump

 

[tokkio]

oohh I find it cool how you and your daughters all play animal crossing all your town maps are very nice btw! I like oishii ai's map best though eheh, but tasmania's beach structure is the best~ I like Paarl's villagers the most, but I also like seabell's native fruit and house placements!