Which starter villagers did you keep?

[Bwazey]

It's sad to say. But I only kept one starter. Which was Walker. I almost kept one of my other starters, Rhonda. But in the end, I needed room for Savannah, which is probably my biggest dreamie.

Which begs the question, which starter did you decide to keep? Did you keep them because they were already a dreamie in the first place? Or did they grow on you? I know Walker grew on me.

 

[NicPlays]

I started with Samson, Rodeo, Pinky, Coco and Cyrano. Samson and Coco were my favourites but I though Samson would lower my chances of getting Rod, so he ended up being my second move out :/ I then moved on to liking Pinky and Coco, and I'm making sure they will never ever leave. Sadly I never liked Rodeo or Cyrano. Rodeo took a while to move, he was my sixth move out. Cyrano took FOREVER though. He was my tenth move out, and I had done the two day forward two day backward trick over 65 time before he pinged!!!!

At least my Pinky and Coco are still here

 

[PaperCat]

I still have a few starters in my town. But I only will keep Gabi, as the others (Margie and Friga) don't fit my theme. I like them but I am going for a theme.

 

[Breath Mint]

I started my game in May and let three of my starters go right away. I still have Daisy and Frobert, but I'm not really attached to them like I am with my other villagers. I'll let them go as well at some point, but I might try to get their pictures before I do.

 

[Aria Nook Violet]

I kept Jay, Muffy and Zell. Muffy and Zell grew on me they couldn't possible be dreamies since they were introduced in New leaf XD Muffy has tastes very similar to mine so it was a fast grow. Zell was the first smug type I met and so it was the very first smug villager to grow on me. Jay has a big story on the other hand.
My first animal crossing game was animal crossing wild world on a emulator. Before buying new leaf I wanted to try animal crossing to see if I liked it. In my town Jay was the only male so that spark some curiosity on me since I'm a girl lol. I wanted to be friends with this bird. At first as a jock Jay was pretty demanding he only wanted fossils and I had to give them to him instead of the museum. Then this hard quests to find the right fossil for him made me start to like him. lol I was determined to get him the right fossil. Then as a reward Jay started to treat my character better and they become friends

Then I decided to buy new leaf and guess who was one of the starters! Jay! That's right he was back. He then became my top dreamie. He just say beautiful things to my character. He's special to me and surely grew on me.

 

[disneydorky]

I started with Ozzie, Greta, Kid Cat, Roscoe, and Pompom. I would have probably kept Ozzie, but he left when I took a hiatus this Spring. Roscoe is the only one who remains. I thought about letting him go, and couldn't at the time. I might eventually, but I do like him.

 

[sam8806]

My starters are Jitters Poppy Frank Wendy and Mathilda. Jitters I hated and he moved right away. I want frank to do the same. Mathilda I'm keeping for NicPlays who is cycling for her. Wendy I was gonna let go because shes not a dreamie, but that will be really hard since she's too cute to let go! Poppy is a dreamy so she is staying

 

[candiedapples]

I still have my two bear cubs, Tammy and Chester! They just grew on me and I find them to be really cute!

 

[FelicityShadow]

I kept Melba, though I'm only keeping her until my birthday. We have the same birthday and I want to celebrate it with her. I can't keep her since she doesn't fit the theme im going for, and I want her to move on. Maybe I'll cycle back or check here after 16 villagers if I do decide to bring her back again.

 

[Dunquixote]

I started with Puddles, Punchy, Gaston, Baabara, Blanche, Hamlet, Paula, Gladys, Keaton and Harry (who came from a friend's void); now, I only have Puddles, Punchy and Gaston and I hope they never leave.

 

[Bwazey]

I started with Puddles, Punchy, Gaston, Baabara, Blanche, Hamlet, Paula, Gladys, Keaton and Harry (who came from a friend's void); now, I only have Puddles, Punchy and Gaston and I hope they never leave.

Awesome! But I actually mean starters. Meaning the villagers you have from day one. Which is 5 villagers.

 

[Bjork]

So far, all except Kevin.

I had Dizzy, Lolly, Mint, Hopper, and Kevin.

I'm not sure how much longer Hopper will stay though.

 

[visibleghost]

i think pompom, croque, dora, lucky and gigi were my starters. i still have dora and lucky, but dora is definitely moving because she's in the middle of my planned path. I might switch out lucky for benjamin later, but atm i like him a lot and also his house is in a really nice spot :>

genji and phil moved in just a few days after my town was started, and i think i'm keeping genji forever. i have a lot of smugs and i might get 3 ostriches in my town, so phil might have to go some day. idk tho

 

[ShinyYoshi]

Out of all the starter villagers I had, Joey still remains. Sometimes I think I'll let him move out, but when he actually says he's moving out, I can never bring myself to letting him leave. He's been through everything since the beginning, I think I'll keep him

 

[aericell]

My starters were Bettina, Bruce, Queenie, Filbert and Patty. I lost Patty early in the game from a TT'ing accident and let go of Bruce a while ago (though I'm going to get him back soon). I still have the other three and I have no plans of getting the other 3 out

 

[Maplexcutie]

I started with Bam, Pashmina, Tipper, Tutu, Del, Bertha and Keaton. I still have Keaton, Del, Bertha, Tipper and Tutu, and plan to keep Tipper and Maybe Tutu.

 

[edsett]

Bespin: Groucho, Felicity, Annalisa, Rory, Diana
None kept.

Kamino: Merry, Gruff, Miranda, Lily, Stitches
Kept Stitches. He's my absolute number one favorite villager and has been for quite a few years. His house is in a great spot too. Merry is still around, but only for PWPs.

 

[Vizionari]

I kept Bunnie, Hamlet, and Cranston from my main town. They initially weren't dreamies but I grew to really love them <3

 

[~NinfiaLazuli~]

I don't think I kept any of my actual starting villagers. Blaire was one of them but she moved without warning. I eventually got her back though, so I guess that kinda counts?

 

[TheGreatBrain]

In my Joy town and farmtown, I kept them all. I never have old movers hanging out on my main street. Tangy is the only one I kept in my Critters town. Her house was in a nice location. I'm glad I kept her, because I've grown to really like her. My newest town had three deer as my starters, puddles and Flip. I'm keeping the deer, but the other two can move.