Which of these Peppy Villagers should I get? (2.0)

[Flare]

I'm making a new one since the other one had options in which I didn't like anymore.

So... which of these should I get?
I'm thinking on getting rid of Cookie, but idk...I like her at times and sometimes I dont. I would get Rosie but I don't want 2 Cats in my town but I think of not minding 2 of the Same Species at times. I am also interested in the others too.

Rosie and Molly hold some good/mysterious memories which is why I would be interested in getting Rosie once more. Unless I get rid of Kid Cat or something, I'm not sure.

Also, I'm interested in Ankha and Lucky, so I may get Bunnie because of it.

If I choose Chrissy I'll think of getting Francine as well since I wouldn't mind having them both. But that's kinda debatable.

I also really wanted to get Ketchup and Julia since they were announced for a return, I don't mind having Julia in there since she looks more like a Peacock and not too similar to Phoebe. After some thinking, I would'nt mind having Ketchup in town either.

 

[ZaAlPa2006]

You should definitely keep Cookie. Shes like the cutest thing in the world apart from Molly

 

[junebuggy.99]

Chrissy is good❤

 

[Gruntilda]

I would vote for ketchup since she hasn't been in the game for a while. I also really like bunnie when she was in one of my old towns.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

I was struggling to choose between Rosie and Ketchup since I have both of them in my town and I love them, but I chose Ketchup because she's so unique.

 

[5cm/s]

I do love my girl Ruby

 

[Pun of Nentown]

I would normally suggest Felicity, but with her on the poll, I'd say go with Rosie.

 

[Rabirin]

Ruby all the way.

 

[mermaidshelf]

Of the Peppys listed, Rosie is my favorite so I chose her. If you don't want to get her because you don't want two of the same species, then I'd get Ketchup or Chrissy.

 

[Verecund]

I like Rosie the best out of those, she's so cute!

 

[hamster]

i'm stuck between bunnie and ruby, both are in my top 10 and are adorable

 

[Flare]

Bump

 

[Flare]

Err... double post. :0

 

[Lululand]

The only ones I personally care about at all among the ones you've mentioned are Ketchup and Cookie... though consider that Ketchup is amiibo-only so unless you have her card yourself obtaining her isn't going to be the easiest thing. So if I were you I'd just keep Cookie.

 

[Flare]

Bump

 

[Flare]

Bump

 

[Garrett]

Out of the available options, I voted Rosie.

I'd pick Maddie myself though.

 

[Flare]

Bump.
Smh, I wonder why I don't want two of the same species like Rosie and Kid Cat, yet I wouldn't mind Chrissy and Francine?

 

[Flare]

Bump

 

[hestu]

Peppy ducks are probably my favorite villagers, so I would definitely say Ketchup out of these options. Pate is just as cute and wonderful in my mind, but Ketchup is adorable and super sweet and her house is a pizzeria so you really can't go wrong there?? Rosie is cute too, but she's no walking tomato.