Which normal should I keep?

[eggs]

I personally love Nana. But I would keep the villagers you find the most "interesting", and have the closest relationship with (if that makes any sense).

For example, I have three normals: Lily, Nana and Savannah. I love them all, but if I were forced to let one go, I'd let Lily go because I find her dialogue the least interesting out of the three of them. I find she repeats herself a lot, and says the same generic phrases quite a bit, whereas Savannah says different things all the time.

That was kind of ramble-y, but hopefully it helps a bit. xD

that totally makes sense! i think about the same thing.

 

[Raffy]

I personally love Nana. But I would keep the villagers you find the most "interesting", and have the closest relationship with (if that makes any sense).

For example, I have three normals: Lily, Nana and Savannah. I love them all, but if I were forced to let one go, I'd let Lily go because I find her dialogue the least interesting out of the three of them. I find she repeats herself a lot, and says the same generic phrases quite a bit, whereas Savannah says different things all the time.

That was kind of ramble-y, but hopefully it helps a bit. xD

Thanks! If I based my choice on who I have the most connection with, I would be saying goodbye to Maple and Nana as I literally just got them last night.
If I were to choose who were the cutest, I would def go with Molly and Nana.

- - - Post Merge - - -

i looked through the official looking for thread and i found AshleyKrystine with nana as their dreamie. they made a post a little over a week ago saying it.

ty! If Nana decides to ping, I will ask her ^^

but hopefully not

- - - Post Merge - - -

i looked through the official looking for thread and i found AshleyKrystine with nana as their dreamie. they made a post a little over a week ago saying it.

ty! If Nana decides to ping, I will ask her ^^

but hopefully not

 

[FireNinja1]

I'd let go of Nana or Lolly. Personally, I'd pick the former, but the latter is overrated and just doesn't really appeal to me overall. It's totally your decision though, just chipping what I'd do.

 

[Ettienne]

I'd let Nana go. She's cute, but...the others are cuter? ^^;

 

[Shimmer]

I would definitely go with whoever means the least to you and who you don't feel a connection with.

Good luck! Picking villagers is SO HARD. :C

 

[Raffy]

I would definitely go with whoever means the least to you and who you don't feel a connection with.

Good luck! Picking villagers is SO HARD. :C

I KNOW ITS LIKE PICKING FAVORITE CHILDREN! but im way too young to have children

Thank you! My decision will def. be based on who I have the most connection too!

 

[LostWasteland]

I would keep Nana.
I really like her. She's sweet. I know all normals are generally sweet. I find Nana's aesthetics to be more appealing. Ideally, I'd want Caroline, Lily, or Melba, but that's just me.

 

[Millefeui]

I have Nana and I like her a lot, but if I had all of those villagers you have, I'd probably keep Molly. She is so tiny and adorable. That said, ultimately I think you should pick the one you are more attached to or the one you like the design the most.

 

[Greninja]

keep maple

 

[Karminny]

Keep Molly and maple! Theyre adorable

 

[creamyy]

Keep Lolly

 

[spCrossing]

Probably Lolly or Molly.

But the choice is up to you honestly, I'm just giving my dumb opinion.

 

[Hazelnut]

Molly is my n?mero uno, so I'd say keep her.

Of the other three, Maple is really adorable.

 

[Raffy]

Okay!
I think I might be letting go of Maple and Nana.

My reasons ---
Lolly has been with me since the beginning, I can't let her go.

Ever since my friend got ACNL, she let me play on her 3DS and even make a character in her town! So I did some research and looked up some villagers, I found Molly and FELL IN LOVE.
In my Wild World version I had Freckles the duck and I just was really obsessed with ducks. I can't let her go ;-;

When Maple and Nana are ready to leave, they can. I won't stop them.
Thank you to everyone who gave their opinion as it really drove me all different directions.
When I started this thread, I thought for sure I was going to keep Nana but after some time, I decided it's probably a good idea to let her go.


Both Nana and Maple are unoriginal. If anyone wants them, don't be afraid to ask me ^^

 

[Quill]

Molly is by far the cutest, but due to popularity she's also super common, so it depends on whether you value cuteness or orginality.

Personally, I wouldn't keep any of the other three, but that's just me (I'm picky about character design) so ignore that.

 

[J e s s i c a]

I would get rid of Nana and keep Lolly, Molly and Maple. If you want to get rid of another one get rid of Lolly as Molly and Maple are way cuter <3

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay!
I think I might be letting go of Maple and Nana.

My reasons ---
Lolly has been with me since the beginning, I can't let her go.

Ever since my friend got ACNL, she let me play on her 3DS and even make a character in her town! So I did some research and looked up some villagers, I found Molly and FELL IN LOVE.
In my Wild World version I had Freckles the duck and I just was really obsessed with ducks. I can't let her go ;-;

When Maple and Nana are ready to leave, they can. I won't stop them.
Thank you to everyone who gave their opinion as it really drove me all different directions.
When I started this thread, I thought for sure I was going to keep Nana but after some time, I decided it's probably a good idea to let her go.


Both Nana and Maple are unoriginal. If anyone wants them, don't be afraid to ask me ^^

loots like you made up your mind! also I may be interested in Maple ^.^

 

[StrawberryCream]

I think you should keep Maple. I'm not a fan of the monkey villagers, so Nana I personally wouldn't keep, Lolly is cute but a bit generic and Molly is bland.

 

[kawaii_princess]

I've always adored the normal type villagers! Out of the four, I say either keep Lolly or Molly. Both are so adorable and they're pretty popular!

 

[CJODell62]

Keep both Lolly and Maple, is what I'd say. Lolly because she's a very popular villager (Tier One), and Maple because she's completely adorable.

 

[patriceflanders]

Lolly, no doubt about it