Which Map?

[xiaonu]

Map one has a nice south facing waterfall. plaza and shops nicely in one area.

 

[Acnl_starfall]

2 looks much better and you seem to like it better. I also love where your house is on map 2

 

[Debra]

Would you consider making an alt and place it's house near the beach so you can have map 1 and the benefit of map 2?

 

[Leen]

I personally like Map 1 better! I love how the town plaza and all of the buildings are located at the top of the town. I like that both beach entrances are leading off of your main's house. Your campsite in 1 has more isolation and isn't by the train tracks. When I think of the ideal camping spot, I wouldn't want it to be next to loud trains -- it spoils all the fun about camping in the great outdoors

Also, you have the perfect private beach set up in map 1. Although my private beach isn't as big as yours in Map 1, I have like cute little beach towels designed on the sand and have fruit baskets out. And it's so great because you can just cliff dive to get there and it's super nice, especially if you have friends over. Also, your private beach has an indent in it, which would make it easier to design cute things on it

I hope this helps give you another perspective on your maps and reach a decision on what you like better! ^_^

 

[N e s s]

I feel like you can do so much more with Map 2, Paths are smoother, the campsite works better, and overall your house by the beach is soooo good!

 

[gingerbread]

I like map two, the placement of your villager houses is great, and your own house.

 

[MintySky]

I like map 2 more because of where the town hall and re-tail is.