What's up with Marshal?

[AnimeK]

You wouldn't last a day on ACC.
totallynotofftopic

I don't have dreamies, which means I don't have heart attacks, which means to me Marshal's just a random villager who's moved into my town.

You should have seen the old app, High School Hero. If your thread didn't have value, you'd get many "rude" comments. On one hand, they could be really offending, but it made the forums really interesting. c:

I have Filbert right now, but if I were to choose between the 2 to keep, I'd choose Marshal. Filbert is alright, but I just like Marshal's design more.

 

[Gizmodo]

He's a cutie Marshmalllow and so fits my food town that i need (eg in my signature)

 

[averylee97]

You should have seen the old app, High School Hero. If your thread didn't have value, you'd get many "rude" comments. On one hand, they could be really offending, but it made the forums really interesting. c:

I have Filbert right now, but if I were to choose between the 2 to keep, I'd choose Marshal. Filbert is alright, but I just like Marshal's design more.

Sure Marshal's cool. I like Filbert's color though. That's my favorite color. And his personality is like mine.

- - - Post Merge - - -

He's a cutie Marshmalllow and so fits my food town that i need (eg in my signature)

I saw you post somewhere else on here and I read you signature. I thought that was really cool!

 

[Darumy]

These threads are kind of rhetorical! I feel like they're made more to start a little circle of "why does everyone like this villager when I don't how silly!" rather than actually discuss or ask the question, since you already know the answer. You /know/ he hits the cute factor for a lot of people, and that's why people want him.

Aesthetics are usually the reason why people put things on their dreamie list, after all. Unless you think Marshal is so morbidly hideous everyone is 1.) delusional 2.) has some kind of personal anecdote to justify wanting him.

 

[PinkWater]

Well, OP, why do you like Julian? His another super-popular villager. To each his own, cuz I sure don't get Marshall, either.

 

[Kanapachi]

Fancy cute grumpy face squirrel with manners AND he's smug.

#MarshmellowFace4lyfe

 

[averylee97]

Well, OP, why do you like Julian? His another super-popular villager. To each his own, cuz I sure don't get Marshall, either.

I like Julian because he's a unicorn, a gentleman, and my favorite blue color. I had him before I knew he was popular.

I'm not saying "Everyone who likes Marshal is crazy!!! He should be voided everywhere!!!" I knew he was popular and wanted to know what others thought of him. I like him. I'm just not gonna spend 50+ million bells on him.

 

[Marii]

I wish people wouldn't base what villagers they like based on how popular or unpopular they are, and just feel free to like whoever they like. e_e I just like who I like, and my opinions just so happen to be shared by many other people. I wish it could be that simple, and not a matter of "oh, look at me, I have this super popular villager that everyone wants and you don't, hah~" or even, "wow, you guys are all so mainstream; look at me, I feel entitled to brag about how special I am because I like less popular villagers. 8)"

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well, OP, why do you like Julian? His another super-popular villager. To each his own, cuz I sure don't get Marshall, either.

There's nothing to "GET". It's their opinions, after all. >_>

 

[Vox]

Some of the hypocrisy in this thread is dizzying, haha.

I've been kinda indifferent about Marshal. I think most people like him because he's cute or because everyone else does. Which is rather high-schoolish. Personally, I find his design rather boring.

 

[Ami Mercury]

Marshal is such an overrated character......Hopper is so underrated, yet so awesome!!!!

 

[Kitty2201]

I don't know why he is so popular, I have him in my second town and am waiting until I can get somewhere with better internet so I can sell him because I don't like him that much

 

[averylee97]

Marshal is such an overrated character......Hopper is so underrated, yet so awesome!!!!

I like Hopper cuz of his role in the movie!

 

[Ami Mercury]

I like Hopper cuz of his role in the movie!

Honestly his was my favorite part of the movie.

 

[averylee97]

Honestly his was my favorite part of the movie.

I liked it when the real aliens showed up! And when everyone fell in pitfall seeds!

 

[Gizmodo]

Sure Marshal's cool. I like Filbert's color though. That's my favorite color. And his personality is like mine.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I saw you post somewhere else on here and I read you signature. I thought that was really cool!

Thank you! i really hope i complete the town one day

 

[averylee97]

Thank you! i really hope i complete the town one day

Please let me know when you do! I'd love to dream of or visit your town!

 

[Shirohibiki]

As it's been said, people like what they like.

I personally hate Marshal as a smug. Slap cranky onto him and he'd be fine. I prefer Nibbles and Caroline in the squirrel department, however.

 

[111]

This thread and the thread that (should be) below it...hm...

 

[LadyVivia]

How could you not like such a gentleman??

 

[Big Forum User]

Honestly, I don't know. I'd like to have him to show off.

I know, right?