I've decided to just switch my crankys from my two towns, moving Bruce to Atlantis and Rolf to Sheol(where Bruce plotted badly). I appreciate some of the advice but not the rude ones. In answer to some of these questions:
I usually do plot reset but I had forgotten he was moving in when I started up my town that morning.
Literally anywhere but right in front of retail or town hall would have been fine.
I'd have to find a new dreamie because I have too many achieved to cycle 16 villagers and it not take months. But I'm switching him for Rolf so problem solved.
Thanks everyone. No more advice needed