Vivian and Whitney: Too Similar?

[Annak95]

I’m currently doing NMTs today to find a replacement for Melba who just moved out. Whitney is on the island I’m at now, and I know she’s really popular.

However, my most recent villager is Vivian, and I’m afraid they’ll be too similar since both are snooty wolves. Also, Vivian is still relatively new and idk how much I like snooty type get (my only other snooty was Annelise and I despised her!)

Looking for any quick advice here, should I:

a) invite Whitney then try to get her or Vivian to move out once I see which one I like better?
b) invite Whitney with the intent of keeping her and Vivian (if so, are there any differences between them?)
c) don’t invite Whitney and keep looking on other islands hoping I find someone else good, but less identical to anyone I have currently?

 

[Insulaire]

I have both. Their voices are noticeably different and they have different interests. They actually don’t seem that much alike, even after a few weeks

 

[Jam86]

i think maybe invite her then when you get vivian, see who you like better ^-^

 

[xChives]

Having both in my town for a few weeks now, I can say Vivian definitely comes off snootier than Whitney. It might be that they have the 2 subsets of the snooty personality but they’re definitely distinct (at least on my island).

 

[Annak95]

Thanks for the quick responses! I’ll invite Whitney and see how I feel about both of them once they’ve been on my island for a while.

 

[Bioness]

Having both in my town for a few weeks now, I can say Vivian definitely comes off snootier than Whitney. It might be that they have the 2 subsets of the snooty personality but they’re definitely distinct (at least on my island).

Whitney is Snooty type A and Vivian Snooty type B.

Personality Subtypes

Personality Subtypes? So you may have read the companion guide and came across this: It doesn’t elaborate beyond that, but we have found information that suggests these subtypes exist. It’s called NpcTalkType What does it do? As far as we know currently, the only thing NpcTalkType affect...

docs.google.com

Vivian's hobby is also Education and her style is Gorgeous and Elegant while liking Gray and Purple colors. Whitney's hobby is Fashion with an Elegant and Cool style liking Blue and Light Blue colors.

 

[tajikey]

There are a few like this. Stitches and Jeremiah are pretty much the same.