Villagers you would love to have, but your island is already full of dreamies.

[OiGuessWho]

Anyone looked at a villager and thought "WHOA! Me likey!" and then realised you can't bring yourself to kick anyone who's currently on your island?
I will never kick the Bubblegum Sisters, Wolfgang is my favorite cranky, Punchy's my favorite Lazy, Shep is my favorite smug, Reneigh and Agnes are awesome Sisterlys, and Coco, Pekoe and Maple are adorable and will never be leaving me. NEVER.
But, if I had space for a few more...

• Blaire
• Carmen
• Eloise
• Ione (I'd VERY much have Ione. I'd put her house on Starfall hill)
• Lolly
• Muffy
• Papi (Love his colours)
• Petri (Have you seen her eyes? )
• Rooney
• And Goldie.

It's nice to be able to have them in Happy Home Paradise, but there's just something different about having them on your island, y'know? Anyone else wish they could add more villagers to their island?

 

[Fey]

Oh gosh, so many. I try to go for a balance of personalities and species, which always means that several of my favorites are ruled out.

Currently the ones I’m missing most are Lolly, Beau, and Roscoe (because I already have a different cat, deer, and horse)

There’s also plenty of villagers I’d love to meet but never try because I ultimately prefer someone else over them. Examples there are Maple, Drago, Blanche, and Marshall.

I really, really hope that we get to over more than ten in the next installment of the game!

 

[VanitasFan26]

I know some of my favorite villagers are living at the Resort, but it doesn't bother me, because I know my island is shallow, but they enjoy their time at the resort so much better.

 

[Paperboy012305]

Based on each personality, I'd love to have:

Lazy:
Filbert
Hopkins
Sasha
Sherb

Jock:
Hamlet
Kid Cat
Rudy
Tiansheng

Cranky:
Boris
Bruce
Butch
Murphy
Static
Wolfgang

Smug:
Cephalobot
Jacques
Marshal
Shep

Normal:
Cally
Celia
Ione
June
Merengue
Molly
Norma
Skye
Sylvana

Peppy:
Cheri
Chrissy
Maddie
Penelope
Sprinkle
Winnie

Snooty:
Diana
Francine
Julia
Purrl
Tiffany
Vivian
Willow

Sisterly:
Cherry
Faith (She's a sisterly, right?)
Frita
Muffy
Quinn
Reneigh
Tammy

Any of the other villagers that I would like to have that I didn't mention I already am going to invite over to my 2nd island. Which are:

Lazy: Chabwick
Jock: Lyman
Cranky: Frank
Smug: Chadder & Roswell
Normal: Étoile
Peppy: Bonbon & Rio
Snooty: Azalea
Sisterly: Sylvia (Yes, I like this thing)

 

[. Rarity .]

Definitely Genji. I miss him so much, but I can't bring myself to replace anyone who's currently there.

Id also not mind having Chadder and Henry back for the same reason.

 

[Altarium]

Off the top of my head, I'd love to have Azalea, Blanche, Molly, Tasha, Lolly, Papi, Shep, and Whitney. And I'd bring back Ruby and Beau. Please Nintendo let us have more than 10

 

[Rosch]

This is my current top 10 right now:

If given a chance to have, say, another 10 villagers, I'd choose:

Buzz, Pierce, Keaton, Dobie, Whitney, Agent S, Curt, Kid Cat, Rod, & Elvis

 

[Magus]

Yeah I felt in love with a lot of villagers, it's hard to have only 10 on an island.
Here's the two that came in my mind right now : Audie and Lobo.

I miss not having a wolf villager honestly but they don't really fit my island I guess, + I already have 2 crankies that I love (Cyd and Kabuki) and soon 2 peppies too (Tabby and Shino tomorrow ).
Maybe if we could have 12 villagers

 

[azurill]

I would love to have more then 10 villagers. If we could have 14 I could have all the penguin villagers on my main island. For my second island I haven’t decided on my permanent 10 because there are just so many great villagers that would fit the theme. Having more villagers would be amazing.

 

[Insulaire]

I’d have Kiki back if I could. Just no room At least I can go visit her seafood restaurant in HHP

 

[MatchaMoonlight]

Judy, Sasha and Ione are at the top of my list. There're tons more, though. If only we could have a few more villagers on our islands!

 

[Anj2k6]

Shino and Ione, but I'm contemplating letting Merengue go for Ione. I'd want her to go to a good home ofc cause I've had Merengue pretty much since release.

 

[dragonair]

Maple and Diana are my absolute faves but I left them off my island this time bc of the limited slots and the fact that they've been on every island I've had. Other than them I would love Merengue, Agnes, Coco, and Stitches. They're villagers that I love but had to replace for others.

 

[PPUAlchemist]

My best friend and I talk about this a lot.
I have:
Pekoe, Ken, Margie, Shino, Phoebe, Cyd, Opal, Raymond, Flurry, and Clay.

However, due to my town’s general aesthetic, I plan to let my hamsters go for Chester and Tiansheng.

It’s such a tough call, though.
If we had more room, I would definitely keep the hamsters I have.

Some others I like, but have no room for include in no particular order:
Melba
Hopper
Rosie
June
Whitney
Pinky
Rolf
Tasha
Chai

 

[Faux]

I'm sure there's more, but between both of my islands, I have pretty much everyone I want ... except Eugene.

 

[pawprints]

I wish I could have Marty on my island, but I have Nate and Hornsby who are in my top 3 favs and I couldn't stand 3 of the same personality - even if lazy is my favorite.

 

[OiGuessWho]

I wish I could have Marty on my island, but I have Nate and Hornsby who are in my top 3 favs and I couldn't stand 3 of the same personality - even if lazy is my favorite.

Yeah. I like a LOT of the normal villagers, but you can only have so many of them before their personalities just become samey. I think I can only stand having Pekoe, Coco and Maple at once because Maple seems to be a bit of a recluse and I dont see her much unless I go talk to her.

 

[Marshmallows]

Merengue, Lolly, Merry, Felicity, Bonbon, Goldie, and Biskit are all villagers I'd love to have but haven't made the cut yet.

 

[Pig-Pen]

Kiki, I want her, but I like my current mix.

 

[inazuma]

all the male wolf. i currently only have dobie wolfgang and chief. other than that, of course, Ace, he is so cute but i dont want to kick anyone somebody PLS HELP