Villagers leaving and is it possible to keep villagers you really like in?

Therhodian

Unicorn Avant-garde
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Posts
310
Bells
20
Switch
7385-6233-4518
User Title Color Change
Silver Mailbox
Hello people!

I know in the old ds animals could leave and I was heartbroken when Apollo left... However when he was in boxes I could talk to him and make him stay! :D YAY!!!!

However sometimes someone would leave, and you couldn't do much how does this work in New leaf? I could look it up but I would be really sad if I get my information wrong, and my favorite Wart Jr leaves... I really am attached to Wart Jr I also kind of like Boone..
 
In new leaf, if your villager is in boxes already, you cannot change his mind as you could in previous games. I am sorry your favorite guy is about to leave. :(
 
In new leaf, if your villager is in boxes already, you cannot change his mind as you could in previous games. I am sorry your favorite guy is about to leave. :(

Oh no on the old ds game one of my favorites left but I do not play it anymore. But I would like to know is there any sign before they go in boxes? Like could you play the game and make sure they never go in boxes? And what happens when they go in boxes, with internet and all do they just dissapear or go to another town you visited?
 
Oh no on the old ds game one of my favorites left but I do not play it anymore. But I would like to know is there any sign before they go in boxes? Like could you play the game and make sure they never go in boxes? And what happens when they go in boxes, with internet and all do they just dissapear or go to another town you visited?

That villager with come talk too you about moving you can say no or yes if that villager is in boxes there gone but I have seen a few tricks to get them back you just have to look threw that threads anywho after they move they go into your void the void is were all your villagers go so the next time you go to someones town who has less then 10 villagers one of your voided villagers has a chance to move into there town
Hopeed this helped!
 
Villagers usually tell you when they're thinking about moving (they make a pinging noise and get those alarmed symbols over their heads when they see you) and you get the option to tell them to stay. If you're unsure about which dialogue means they're telling you about moving, I believe there's lists of the things they say. They'll usually tell you that they want to travel the world or go to another town.

You can also hear about it by talking to other villagers. If you talk to them enough, sometimes they'll tell you that another villager is thinking about moving. In that case, you can go find that villager so that they can ask you the question. If they aren't asking but you know they're moving, you can talk to them a few times, save your game, reload, and try to find them again. In one case, I did that a few times and the villager still wasn't asking me, so I set my 3DS clock a month forward, started as a new character, quit without saving, and set the date back to load the game as my mayor again. Then I repeated the process of finding them, talking to them, saving and quitting, reloading, and finding them again until they did. Using a new character to time travel into the future sped up the process.

Villagers won't ping you about moving if there are any events coming up, though, so sometimes you have to be careful and patient.

Once a villager has made up their mind to move (either automatically or because you told them to go), if you talk to them a few times, they'll usually tell you something about how they're thinking about their decision and you can ask them to stay. Sometimes it's also possible to do this when a villager is in boxes, but not always.

If your villager is in boxes and you want to keep them but they're not asking you about it, you can find someone to hold your villager for you by inviting them into their town. After that, once you move out a total of 16 villagers, you can invite your old villager (or an identical version of them, if you couldn't find someone to hold them) back.
 
Villagers usually tell you when they're thinking about moving (they make a pinging noise and get those alarmed symbols over their heads when they see you) and you get the option to tell them to stay. If you're unsure about which dialogue means they're telling you about moving, I believe there's lists of the things they say. They'll usually tell you that they want to travel the world or go to another town.

You can also hear about it by talking to other villagers. If you talk to them enough, sometimes they'll tell you that another villager is thinking about moving. In that case, you can go find that villager so that they can ask you the question. If they aren't asking but you know they're moving, you can talk to them a few times, save your game, reload, and try to find them again. In one case, I did that a few times and the villager still wasn't asking me, so I set my 3DS clock a month forward, started as a new character, quit without saving, and set the date back to load the game as my mayor again. Then I repeated the process of finding them, talking to them, saving and quitting, reloading, and finding them again until they did. Using a new character to time travel into the future sped up the process.

Villagers won't ping you about moving if there are any events coming up, though, so sometimes you have to be careful and patient.

Once a villager has made up their mind to move (either automatically or because you told them to go), if you talk to them a few times, they'll usually tell you something about how they're thinking about their decision and you can ask them to stay. Sometimes it's also possible to do this when a villager is in boxes, but not always.

If your villager is in boxes and you want to keep them but they're not asking you about it, you can find someone to hold your villager for you by inviting them into their town. After that, once you move out a total of 16 villagers, you can invite your old villager (or an identical version of them, if you couldn't find someone to hold them) back.

Thanks a lot for the detailed explanation, thanks a lot!
 
No problem, I'm glad I could help! :)

- - - Post Merge - - -

If you have any other questions about that, feel free to ask. I tried to keep my post short. :)

Well you said sometimes a animal can be in boxes but can still be prevented to go away? So it is always worth trying to talk with them quite some time?
 
Well you said sometimes a animal can be in boxes but can still be prevented to go away? So it is always worth trying to talk with them quite some time?

I've never really experienced them being in boxes and giving me that option, so I don't know if that's actually possible. I was just saying what you said in your post and what I've seen people claim. I talk to my villagers when they're in boxes a few times to read their goodbye dialogue when I'm bored but they've never asked me to stay. Maybe I just don't remember it because I've only moved out villagers I wanted to adopt out of my town.

The only times that a villager has asked me for an opinion after I've told them to move was before they were in boxes, when I saw them wandering around or went to their house.

I hope that explains it better. :)
 
Back
Top