Villager help...

[LoonieToonies]

So I'm doing some cycling on both my systems to get Biskit and Teddy for my main town and get Papi to move out of my main town for someone else on the forum, and then? Kidd the smug goat moved into my cycle town.

This goat is the cutest creature I have ever laid eyes on and I kinda want him in my town. I have Marshal now but I'm not sure if I want to let him go (he's really cute with Molly, one time I found them in Molly's house hanging out lol). I can only have one or the other, and I'm really torn. What do you think I should do? (P.S try not to let your personal feelings for a villager get in the way of your decision!)

Thanks!

 

[tumut]

Molly is kinda boring, keep the popular white squirrel.

 

[HoennMaster]

Molly is kinda boring

BLASPHEMY. I demand you repent for your sin immediately.

 

[00ToxicLove00]

Marshal is better than Molly

 

[Nunnafinga]

I believe the O.P. was trying to decide between Kidd and Marshal not Molly and Marshal.I have both of these smugs and they've both been good villagers but I prefer Marshal a tad over Kidd.

 

[roseflower]

Sounds like you want Kidd to stay in your town?

 

[Raffy]

Molly is kinda boring, keep the popular white squirrel.

but you are comparing a normal villager to a smug villager

 

[tumut]

Well if it's between Kidd and Marshal they're both great but I guess I like Kidd a bit more.

- - - Post Merge - - -

but you are comparing a normal villager to a smug villager

Well that's what I thought they needed to choose from originally, yes I am going to compare a normal and smug villager if they ask for whcih of the two. Honestly normals are always kinda bland.

 

[LoonieToonies]

Lolol it's between Kidd and marshal but I appreciate everyone's enthusiasm! (P.S id say marshal is way more boring than molly in terms of design) anyway I've let marshal go and Kidd is moving in. Thanks everyone for helping this indecisive person out!

 

[Katelyn]

Definitely keep Marshal ;w;

 

[toadsworthy]

Try to make it work! anyone else you can send out? I switch who I have doubles of all the time... Marshall looks like a small child trying to be what people think of as smug... Kidd is just blah, so go with what you think is right! don't feel indebted to keep marshall because he is tier 1 or been in longer, go with what makes you happy and you like for your town!

side note: I just went through the same thing with Molly... I brought her in because she was so cute!!! but then I got bored and let her go...

 

[Nunnafinga]

Good luck with your new Kidd.Here's my Kidd suggesting his first PWP.I've managed to keep him wearing his original Gracie waistcoat which is good because his taste in clothing is terrible but otherwise he's a good guy.

 

[dj_mask]

Molly >>>>>>>>> Marshal imo. Not necessarily any reason though haha

 

[toadsworthy]

View attachment 91286

Good luck with your new Kidd.Here's my Kidd suggesting his first PWP.I've managed to keep him wearing his original Gracie waistcoat which is good because his taste in clothing is terrible but otherwise he's a good guy.

whats wrong with the totem pole?!? I couldn't wait to get it!

 

[Nunnafinga]

whats wrong with the totem pole?!? I couldn't wait to get it!

Huh?I dunno....seems like a cool PWP to me.

 

[LoonieToonies]

Kidd has moved in and marshal has gone to a good home! I appreciate all the advice from everyone, but I am happy with my decision. Marshals house exterior looked to modern for my town anyway, and it wasn't in the best of spots.