Top 5 Over rated and under rated games of all time

[Thunder]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

Well it was the 64, you can't get as good of graphics on there.

 

[Zex]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

Not a single Mario game ever impressed you?

Its the Simon of video games.

 

[cornymikey]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

Well, in your opinion, they might not be great, but it should still be decent to you. You didn't think any parts of any mario game were fun?

 

[Pear]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

Not a single Mario game ever impressed you?

Its the Simon of video games.

Galaxy was just above the mediocre range, but not enough to really impress me.

In retrospect, it probably wasn't a good idea to say I disliked Mario on a Nintendo forum.

 

[The Sign Painter]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

Not a single Mario game ever impressed you?

Its the Simon of video games.

Mario games are fun, but once you go to 3D, it is not the same game. Galaxy and the originals were good, excluding the first one. >.<

ANd has anyone seen the Guiness Book of World Records Top 50 Console Games of all time? For those who haven't, one word: Ithadsomegoodgamesbutmostofthemwerecompletecrap

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

No. Halo is the most overrated game ever created.

 

[Zex]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

Not a single Mario game ever impressed you?

Its the Simon of video games.

Galaxy was just above the mediocre range, but not enough to really impress me.

In retrospect, it probably wasn't a good idea to say I disliked Mario on a Nintendo forum.

Yea. It was a horrible idea.

 

[bittermeat]

Stop playing Toon Town and play Kingdom Hearts, baby.

 

[Dimitri Petrenko]

Isnt that stitch in your avatar :l

 

[Pear]

Dude. OOT and Sm64 are not overrated. They are as good as everyone says they are.

I downloaded both of them for VC. I couldn't stand SM64, because everything was so blocky. They should've kept it a 2.5D side scroller.
OOT was basically TP with crappy graphics.

It was the Nintendo 64.
If they hadn't made Sm64 then there wouldn't be sunshine, galaxy, or any other mario like that.
NINTENDO 64 HAD GREAT GRAPHICS FOR BACK THEN!

And also, you cant judge everything on graphics. OOT ending almost made me cry.

Really, the mario series imo is the most overrated game ever created. I realize now it should be on my #1 spot on my list. There has not been a single Mario game that has even mildly impressed me.

And graphics matter to me. I was raised on the Gamecube and PS2, so it really bugs me to go back to the N64.

No. Halo is the most overrated game ever created.

Halo is somewhat overrated, but not to the extent that some people say. The story mode is good, but not incredible. However, it has the best online of any game I've ever played.

 

[Sonicdan369]

Under Rated
1.Super Mario Sunshine
I may be a minority on this one....

 

[Garrett x50 cal]

I messed up my Bad, hm Not sure. =P

 

[AC_Goddess]

Underrated are Skies of Arcadia and Tales of Symphonia

 

[Dimitri Petrenko]

Under Rated
1.Super Mario Sunshine
I may be a minority on this one....

I would put that at 6

 

[Sonicdan369]

Under Rated
1.Super Mario Sunshine
I may be a minority on this one....

I would put that at 6

>->

 

[JasonBurrows]

Overrated:
1. Ocarina of Time
2. Super Mario RPG
3. Chrono Trigger
4. Super Mario 64
5. Super Mario Galaxy

Underrated Games:

5. EarthBound
4. Banjo Kazooie and Tooie
3. Conker's Bad Fur Day
2. EarthWorm Jim
1. The Contra Series.

That was the best game my friend ever showed me for the Nintendo 64!

 

[Rockman!]

Okay, I just have one question.

If you don't like Nintendo games then why is your name Kid Icarus?

 

[Thunder]

"2.Call Of Duty( All of them )
Ok soo now were in the 21st century where guns are cool and make games good :l"

What's the difference if Kid Icarus has a bow & arrow?

 

[Dimitri Petrenko]

Under Rated
1.Super Mario Sunshine
I may be a minority on this one....

I would put that at 6

>->

Its not really that underated my nintendo magazine put it as 5th best mario game

 

[Conor]

Overrated

Ocarina of Time
Twilight Princess
Crash Bandicoot
Super Mario Galaxy

Underrated

Super Mario Sunshine
Banjo Kazooie
Banjo Tooie
Banjo Kazooie Nuts and Bolts
Ricochet(sp?)

Both Ocarina of Time and Twilight Princess are great games but they have too much hype, my own opinion is that Zelda: A link to the past is the best Zelda game.

The 3 main Banjo Kazooie games I think are underrated, I think they are the best games ever(well the first 2). Again that's my opinion .

Other games that didn't make any of the lists...

Conkers Bad Fur Day
Team Fortress Classic
Team Fortress 2
Spiderman 2
Halo 3
Perfect Dark

Remember every game I have mentioned I have played, they are all very good and have enjoyed every single one.