Top 5 Over rated and under rated games of all time

Dimitri Petrenko

Get on the point maggots!
Joined
Jan 31, 2009
Posts
2,115
Bells
1,322
User Title Color Change
Ok first over rated

5 a tie.The Legend Of Zelda The Ocarina Of Time and Super Mario 64
Ok now im probably gonna get a lot of hate from this but i do like this game a lot but come on its rated 10/10 seriously its good but not perfect and Super Mario 64 i just didnt really like, it just wasnt mario too me.

4. Pokemon ( All but the first three )
I like pokemon but do they really need soo many sequels, spin offs , card games and a anime
i mean why sint there a mario card game or legend of zelda

3. Final fantasay 7
just check the rants people have made on youtube

2.Call Of Duty( All of them )
Ok soo now were in the 21st century where guns are cool and make games good :l

1. Halo1 , 2 and 3
Thesse agmes are basically " Omg look at me guyz im *censored.3.0*ing master chef i has a gun and i r 1337 because of it, :O omgz a giant ring planet lets go attack the grunts for sum reasonz and cortana is smexy

Ok under rated

5. Kid icarus
Man this game was a mix between zelda mario and metroid and yet ninty ignores it

4.Sonic unleashed
This game wasnt really that bad, the only reason people hate it is because :O omg sega has tried something new aaaah

3. Super mario rpg
This game is a perfect example of a rpg better than FF7 it had new villians, the first game you could play as bowser , 2 new side kicks and a intresting plot

2. Pac man junior
This is basically pac man but has more features but yet it was ignored

1. Toontown!
I love this game soo much its basically a rpg where mickey and friends are attacked by robots gone wrong made by screwge mc duck, the toons in toontown help mickey and friends fight the cogs this game is like final fantasay and duck tales put together to make a epic mmorpg but the reason its under rated is because disney advertise club penguin and not this game heres a link to try it http://play.toontown.com/webHome.php?r=712829&r=720991&r=495852&r=866285 i know it looks childish but its soo fun
 
Ugh, you're not a Nintendo Fanboy are you? =/
 
Kid Icarus said:
Ok first over rated

5 a tie.The Legend Of Zelda The Ocarina Of Time and Super Mario 64
Ok now im probably gonna get a lot of hate from this but i do like this game a lot but come on its rated 10/10 seriously its good but not perfect and Super Mario 64 i just didnt really like, it just wasnt mario too me.

4. Pokemon ( All but the first three )
I like pokemon but do they really need soo many sequels, spin offs , card games and a anime
i mean why sint there a mario card game or legend of zelda

3. Final fantasay 7
just check the rants people have made on youtube

2.Call Of Duty( All of them )
Ok soo now were in the 21st century where guns are cool and make games good :l

1. Halo1 , 2 and 3
Thesse agmes are basically " Omg look at me guyz im *censored.3.0*ing master chef i has a gun and i r 1337 because of it, :O omgz a giant ring planet lets go attack the grunts for sum reasonz and cortana is smexy

Ok under rated

5. Kid icarus
Man this game was a mix between zelda mario and metroid and yet ninty ignores it

4.Sonic unleashed
This game wasnt really that bad, the only reason people hate it is because :O omg sega has tried something new aaaah

3. Super mario rpg
This game is a perfect example of a rpg better than FF7 it had new villians, the first game you could play as bowser , 2 new side kicks and a intresting plot

2. Pac man junior
This is basically pac man but has more features but yet it was ignored

1. Toontown!
I love this game soo much its basically a rpg where mickey and friends are attacked by robots gone wrong made by screwge mc duck, the toons in toontown help mickey and friends fight the cogs this game is like final fantasay and duck tales put together to make a epic mmorpg but the reason its under rated is because disney advertise club penguin and not this game heres a ]http://play.toontown.com/webHome.php?r=712829&r=720991&r=495852&r=866285[/url] i know it looks childish but its soo fun
I don't agree with LOZ and SM64 being overrated, maybe it's because you weren't there during the time period when they came out, but when they came out they were the bomb.

The pokemon games are good, the card game OK, the tv show meh.

not a big fan of final fantasy

I thought the COD games were pretty good, maybe a little overrated.

Halo is overrated, but it's awesomenes makes up for some of that =p

Super Mario RPG is the game I turned to when the paper mario game for the wii was such a letdown, I love it.
 
Overrated:
1. Ocarina of Time
2. Super Mario RPG
3. Chrono Trigger
4. Super Mario 64
5. Super Mario Galaxy

Underrated Games:

5. EarthBound
4. Banjo Kazooie and Tooie
3. Conker's Bad Fur Day
2. EarthWorm Jim
1. The Contra Series.
 
Kid Icarus said:
Master Crash said:
Ugh, you're not a Nintendo Fanboy are you? =/
Do fan boys of nintendo have every play station apart from psp go and psp slim?
Okay, so do you have/like/hate Xbox?
 
Kid Icarus said:
Master Crash said:
Ugh, you're not a Nintendo Fanboy are you? =/
Do fan boys of nintendo have every play station apart from psp go and psp slim?
He means you're saying Halo sucks, have you even played it? lol. It's a pretty fun game for the most part, except all the little kids who play it. Trust me, this is coming from someone who's played from NES to Wii (Excluding Virtual Boy, I never managed to get one of those)
 
Nikoking said:
Overrated:
1. Ocarina of Time
2. Super Mario RPG
3. Chrono Trigger
4. Super Mario 64
5. Super Mario Galaxy

Underrated Games:

5. EarthBound
4. Banjo Kazooie and Tooie
3. Conker's Bad Fur Day
2. EarthWorm Jim
1. The Contra Series.
I agree with most but are sure about banjo games, i thought theey was quite popular
 
Master Crash said:
Kid Icarus said:
Master Crash said:
Ugh, you're not a Nintendo Fanboy are you? =/
Do fan boys of nintendo have every play station apart from psp go and psp slim?
Okay, so do you have/like/hate Xbox?
Sorry for double post but i do like halo its kinda fun but its over rated + the fans make it as if its the god of games
 
Top 5 Overrated:
1. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time a.k.a. GAME OF THE YEAR EVERY YEAR!
2. Halo 3
3. Starcraft
4. Little Big Planet
5. Grand Theft Auto IV Final Fantasy (Thanks, Travis. Forgot this one)

Top 5 Underrated:
1. Homeworld II
2. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
3. Grim Fandango
4. Command and Conquer Red Alert 2
5. Fallout 2
 
Top 5 Overrated Games:

5. Final Fantasy

4. Call of Duty Series

3. Kingdom Hearts

2. 3rd and 4th Generation Pokemon, along with the Dungeon spin-offs.

1. Halo Series


Top 5 Underrated Games

5. Zack and Wiki

4. God Hand

3. Beyond Good and Evil

2. Viewtiful Joe

1. Ace Attorney Series
 
TravisTouchdown said:
Top 5 Overrated Games:

5. Final Fantasy

4. Call of Duty Series

3. Kingdom Hearts

2. 3rd and 4th Generation Pokemon, along with the Dungeon spin-offs.

1. Halo Series


Top 5 Underrated Games

5. Zack and Wiki

4. God Hand

3. Beyond Good and Evil

2. Viewtiful Joe

1. Ace Attorney Series
YES.
 
TravisTouchdown said:
Top 5 Overrated Games:

5. Final Fantasy

4. Call of Duty Series

3. Kingdom Hearts

2. 3rd and 4th Generation Pokemon, along with the Dungeon spin-offs.

1. Halo Series


Top 5 Underrated Games

5. Zack and Wiki

4. God Hand

3. Beyond Good and Evil

2. Viewtiful Joe

1. Ace Attorney Series
I forgot kingdom hearts and ace attorney :(
 
3. Super mario rpg
This game is a perfect example of a rpg better than FF7 it had new villians, the first game you could play as bowser , 2 new side kicks and a intresting plot

It was by the same people, idiot.
 
AverageSean said:
3. Super mario rpg
This game is a perfect example of a rpg better than FF7 it had new villians, the first game you could play as bowser , 2 new side kicks and a intresting plot

It was by the same people, idiot.
Um i knew that
 
Kid Icarus said:
Ok first over rated

1. Halo1 , 2 and 3
Thesse agmes are basically " Omg look at me guyz im *censored.3.0*ing master chef i has a gun and i r 1337 because of it, :O omgz a giant ring planet lets go attack the grunts for sum reasonz and cortana is smexy
I lol'd.

I think that many games are under rated, and many are over rated, like Halo 1-3, or pretty much MOST of whats on 360.
 
nephewjack said:
You don't know how much ridicule is attached to that game.

"Basically, the game is for *censored.7.61*. You just yell out Objection to the DS."
"Are you kidding me? I'm not gonna play Ace Attorney. It's really gay. You'll just embarrass yourself in public playing that."

My point is, people stereotype that the game's main feature is you yelling Objection! to your DS.
 
Back
Top