Top 10 horse villagers?

[silver_shroud]

So, I've got an all-horse village currently in the works and am trying to decide on which three horses to exclude, since there are 13 to choose from and sadly only ten spots. The horses include Annalise, Elmer, Julian, Savannah, Papi, Peaches, Ed, Buck, Roscoe, Colton, Winnie, Victoria, and Clyde. For visual reference, you can see them here: http://animalcrossing.wikia.com/wiki/Horse

Which ones do you think should be invited in and which should be put out to pasture, so to speak?

 

[Mentagon]

I'd say leave out Peaches, Buck, and Clyde. The rest are cool.

 

[zoetrope]

My three favorites are Colton, Savannah and Winnie. I wouldn't have Roscoe (haaaaaate), Julian (I don't actually hate him but he is very predictable/common) and Clyde (picked only because you can't have 11 villagers T_T ).

Really, though, horses are probably my favorite villagers. The only one I don't absolutely love is Roscoe. They can make glue out of him for all I care. :O

 

[tumut]

Roscoe and Ed are a must. Papi is also cool. Idc about the rest.

 

[honeymoo]

ed, winnie and papi are cuties.
other cute ones are victoria, savannah, roscoe, peaches, julian ed and elmer

 

[roseflower]

I like sweet Annalise, Savannah, Papi, Winnie and Roscoe, the other horses are okay. Maybe you choose one of each personality, so you have one of each and the two horses you like c:

 

[silver_shroud]

I like sweet Annalise, Savannah, Papi, Winnie and Roscoe, the other horses are okay. Maybe you choose one of each personality, so you have one of each and the two horses you like c:

I love all the ones that you listed too! I do like having the whole range of personalities as well. I kind of wish that Ed was still a jock personality like in the old days though, since that will leave with me Buck as my only jock option. Not that there's anything wrong with Buck, but between the two I would prefer Ed. Julian, Colton and Ed would be the ultimate trifecta!

 

[64BitGuy]

Clyde, Ed, Julian, and Roscoe are the only ones I know I've had. Out of those 4, I recommend all of them except Roscoe.

 

[FrostyPaws]

Roscoe.

 

[TamaMushroom]

I'd say leave out Ed, Peaches and Clyde, they are one's that would double with other personality types and I wouldn't care for them visually.
Here's a list of the Personalities & Horses:

Normal- Savannah
Peppy- Victoria, Winnie
Snooty- Annalise
Uchi- N/A
Lazy- Papi, Elmer
Jock- Buck
Cranky- Roscoe
Smug- Colton, Julian

TBH I would want an Uchi, but There aren't any Horse Uchi's, but this town line up looks pretty neat. I'd love to visit when you get them settled.

 

[QoQ]

Savannah is amazing <3. I say scratch Elmer, Buck and Peaches.

 

[silver_shroud]

I'd say leave out Ed, Peaches and Clyde, they are one's that would double with other personality types and I wouldn't care for them visually.
Here's a list of the Personalities & Horses:

Normal- Savannah
Peppy- Victoria, Winnie
Snooty- Annalise
Uchi- N/A
Lazy- Papi, Elmer
Jock- Buck
Cranky- Roscoe
Smug- Colton, Julian

TBH I would want an Uchi, but There aren't any Horse Uchi's, but this town line up looks pretty neat. I'd love to visit when you get them settled.

That *is * a pretty nice looking lineup. And consider yourself invited (once it's up and running of course)!

 

[TamaMushroom]

Thank You! I'll add you as a contact so I can keep up with you Haha.

 

[MayorDarryn]

Personally, I don't like the horse villagers that much but If I had to pick.
I'd say go for everyone except
Annalise, her eyes kinda creep me out plus I'm not too big of a fan on her color scheme
Buck or Clyde, Buck being the only Jock horse, if you want any Jock PWP, get Buck over Clyde.
Elmer, Don't really care for him. He seems like the most basic design-wise.

 

[silver_shroud]

Thank You! I'll add you as a contact so I can keep up with you Haha.

Great! I'm really psyched to get this project off the ground

 

[Stevey Queen]

I'd say leave out Peaches, Buck, and Clyde. The rest are cool.

I would personally keep Peaches and get rid of Winnie because her, Buck, and Clyde are all fugly.

I don't' really like horses that much in real life but I adore most of the horse villagers lol

 

[bigger34]

I would say leave out Julian, Buck, and Ed.

 

[ssvv227]

I'd leave out Buck, Clyde, and Winnie based on looks. Roscoe is pretty neat in his design. I currently have both Papi and Julian in my town and I adore the both. Papi is too cute <3

 

[KaydeeKrunk]

The horses I really like and would definitely keep are Elmer, Julian, Savannah, Roscoe, Colton, Peaches, Ed, and Annalise. The sub-par ones I could live with or without are Papi, Winnie, and Victoria. And by no means would I ever want Buck, or Clyde, I do not like their designs at all.

 

[ellabella12345]

Victoria is the cutest horse ever <3 C: