I recently saw a post on this LOL and I'm having exactly the same problem! I was doing the campsite method for Muffy, as I don't have an Uchi villager yet and I've regretted leaving the island with her + not inviting for ages. Although, I've gotten Lucky and feel like I can't say no, as I have Ankha on my island! However, I already have Beau and Stitches and can't part with them (I have a Stitches tattoo oof). Dunno whether to move him in or just keep Muffy hunting. Any thoughts appreciated tbh I'm struggling lmao ❤