To replace or not to replace; Help me decide!

[BubbleBlowinDoubleBaby]

Hi guys!
So right now, I really wanna try to get Gabi in my town via the campsite method. I think she's really cute in her own special way. The issue with that is.. I already have a peppy in my town--Audie!

If it was literally any other peppy I'd have no issue booting them. But Audie doesn't have an amiibo card and may be impossible to get back! I'm not a huge fan of wolves but she's kind of grown on me. Help me make a decision!

 

[Xara]

if you like gabi more than audie, i’d say replace her. but if there’s any doubt in your mind about that decision, i would just keep audie for the time being - if you decide to get gabi sometime in the future, she’ll be a lot easier to obtain than audie would be

 

[Fluuffy]

I feel your pain. I’m currently in the same situation with Judy and Blanche

 

[Annika.]

Go get your dreamie. Audie isn't more special than other peppys, and I'm sure the amiibo cards for the new villagers are already in production.

 

[Spooky.]

I mean, you're gonna have doubles of personalities anyway. Unless you dislike peppy why not have both?

 

[BubbleBlowinDoubleBaby]

I feel your pain. I’m currently in the same situation with Judy and Blanche

AAAA I *love* Blanche!! I'd like to get her in my town but I already have Diana and I think I like her too much to let her go. I have a Willow card coming in the mail.. maybe I should've gotten Blanche instead!

Post automatically merged: Apr 28, 2020

I mean, you're gonna have doubles of personalities anyway. Unless you dislike peppy why not have both?

It's moreso that I was planning on doing this via the campsite method, which requires you to have every personality type *but* the one you want. So if I wanted this to work, Audie would have to get the boot.

 

[Fluuffy]

If you want to keep both and have space plots for both. Maybe you can ask a friend to hold Audie while you try to get Gabi. You can also try looking for Gabi in the neighbor network. Since she is not popular, you may get her for an affordable price or even free from someone that’s moving her out and want her to go to a good home

 

[DJStarstryker]

The problem with only 10 villagers is that, if you want to have at least 1 of every personality, that only leaves 2 extra slots. It makes the decisions so hard. It's easy to find more than 10 to like since there's so many.

Do you have space for 2 peppys on your island? You could potentially keep both, depending on how much you like your other villagers.