The Most _______ of Each Personality

[Shawna]

I made this thread a looooooong time ago back in 2015, but I decided to just make a new one, rather than bring back the old one, as the former is preferred. All you gotta do is list down your best, worst, most beautiful, most handsome, etc. from each personality. Feel free to come up with your own categories! You can also do honorable mentions and dishonorable mentions if you wish

Best
Normal: Marcie
Peppy: Tammi
Snooty: Astrid, Mathilda, or Ankha (HM: Velma)
Uchi: Sylvia
Lazy: Big Top
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: Rooney (HMs: Walt and Apollo)
Smug: Eugene

Worst
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Blaire (DHMs: Mint and Portia)
Uchi: Canberra
Normal: Al
Jock: Samson or Boone
Cranky: Rolf (DHM: Gaston)
Smug: Hans

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Celia
Peppy: Tammi or Rosie
Snooty: Ankha
Uchi: Phoebe

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Big Top
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Lopez or Zell

Least Attractive/Ugliest
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Violet
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Al
Jock: Coach
Cranky: Gaston
Smug: Hans

Most Overrated
Normal: Mitzi
Peppy: Peanut
Snooty: Blaire or Diana (I don't hate Diana, but I also don't care her very much)
Uchi: Canberra (the only other uchi I dislike is Rocket, but she gets more hate)
Lazy: ?
Jock: ?
Cranky: Rolf
Smug: Marshal

Most Underrated
Normal: Peaches
Peppy: Tammi
Snooty: Velma
Uchi: Sylvia
Lazy: Anchovy
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Eugene

Remember: Make lots of lists, respect others' opinions, and have fun with this topic!

 

[cicely]

i'm only doing the nice ones

Best
Normal: Vesta
Peppy: Ketchup
Snooty: Amelia
Uchi: Muffy
Lazy: Lucky
Jock: Teddy
Cranky: Roscoe
Smug: Julian

Most Underrated
Normal: Lucy
Peppy: Pompom
Snooty: Timbra
Uchi: Pashmina
Lazy: Papi
Jock: Drift
Cranky: Avery
Smug: Phil

Cutest
Normal: Merengue
Peppy: Bunnie
Snooty: Pecan/Willow
Uchi: Phoebe
Lazy: Stitches
Jock: Genji
Cranky: all the wolves
Smug: Marshal

 

[Mayor Monday]

Best
Normal: Eunice
Peppy: Dotty
Snooty: Tipper
Uchi: Agnus
Lazy: Beau
Jock: Rudy
Cranky: Octavian
Smug: Tex

Worst
Normal: Daisy
Peppy: Pinky
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Ursala
Normal: Al
Jock: Jitters
Cranky: T-Bone
Smug: Colton

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Margie
Peppy: Anabelle
Snooty: Olivia
Uchi: Agnus

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Lucky...?
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Dobie
Smug: O'Hare, I suppose? His design is pretty sharp.

Least Attractive/Ugliest
Normal: Alice
Peppy: Chrissy
Snooty: Cashmere
Uchi: Sylvia
Lazy: Joey
Jock: Curly or Stinky
Cranky: Chow
Smug: Beardo

Most Overrated
Normal: Merengue
Peppy: Apple
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Muffy
Lazy: Bob
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Fang
Smug: Marshal and Julian

Most Underrated
Normal: Margie
Peppy: Felicity
Snooty: Monique
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Alfonso
Jock: Bud
Cranky: Gaston
Smug: Lucha

 

[Snowesque]

Best Favorite
Normal: Kiki
Peppy: Dotty
Snooty: Blanche
Uchi: Plucky
Lazy: Stitches
Jock: Bill or Drift
Cranky: Rasher
Smug: Marshal

Underrated
Normal: Eunice
Peppy: Winnie
Snooty: Baabara
Uchi: Agnes
Lazy: Spork
Jock: Sly
Cranky: Spike and Rasher !!!
Smug: Hans

Very opinionated of course.

 

[Shawna]

Bump!~

 

[Xara]

i’m only gonna do best and worst cause i’m lazy

best
normal: skye
peppy: sprinkle
snooty: vivian
uchi: fuchsia
lazy: beau
jock: bam
cranky: dobie
smug: zell

worst
normal: deena
peppy: anicotti
snooty: cashmere
uchi: rocket
lazy: clyde
jock: honestly - all of them except bam and rudy lmao
cranky: chow
smug: quillson

 

[carackobama]

I’m only doing the nice ones too :’)

Best
Normal: Kiki, Skye, Etoile
Peppy: Tangy, Cookie
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Fuschia
Lazy: Beau
Jock: Bam, Rudy
Cranky: Fang
Smug: Julian

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Skye, Etoile, Merengue
Peppy: Rosie, Peanut
Snooty: Ankha, Diana
Uchi: Cherry

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Beau
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Fang, Wolfgang
Smug: Julian

Most Underrated
Normal: Gayle
Peppy: Wendy
Snooty: Blanche
Uchi: Tammy
Lazy: Rex
Jock: Sly
Cranky: Kabuki, Rolf
Smug: Phil

 

[sierra]

You need to back up on my girl Mint ��

 

[Verecund]

Best
Normal: Poppy
Peppy: Gabi
Snooty: Francine
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Filbert
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Bruce
Smug: Marshal

Worst (all the special amiibo ones would go under here, so I'm putting my least favourite of the normal 383)
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Cashmere
Uchi: Katt
Lazy: Benjamin
Jock: Stinky
Cranky: Harry
Smug: Beardo

Most Attractive
Normal: Poppy
Peppy: Peanut
Snooty: Mint
Uchi: Fuchsia
Lazy: Filbert
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Tom
Smug: Marshal

Least Attractive
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Cashmere
Uchi: Katt
Lazy: Al
Jock: Cousteau
Cranky: Limberg
Smug: Beardo

Most Overrated
Normal: ?toile (but if special amiibo villagers are excluded, then Fauna)
Peppy: Maddie
Snooty: Vivian
Uchi: Cherry
Lazy: Zucker
Jock: Boots
Cranky: Chief
Smug: Shep

Most Underrated
Normal: Caroline
Peppy: Gabi
Snooty: Pecan
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Filbert
Jock: Sheldon
Cranky: Vladimir
Smug: Colton

 

[Jas]

Best
Normal: Marina, Gayle
Peppy: Ruby
Snooty: Blanche
Uchi: Mira
Lazy: Zucker
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Camofrog, Octavian
Smug: Marshal

Worst
Normal: Coco maybe?
Peppy: Anabelle
Snooty: Annalise
Uchi: Paula
Lazy: BOB sorry
Jock: Bud
Cranky: Wart Jr.
Smug: Klaus

Most Attractive
Normal: Tia, Fauna
Peppy: Sprinkle
Snooty: Whitney
Uchi: Phoebe
Lazy: Tucker????
Jock: Ribbot????????????
Cranky: Dobie
Smug: Tex, Ken

Least Attractive/Ugliest
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Monique
Uchi: Diva, Katt, Muffy LOL
Lazy: Al, Barold, Spork
Jock: all of them but Mott comes to mind first
Cranky: Rowan
Smug: Rodney

I only did a few because I was lazy loool

 

[Abyrae]

A lot of my choices for the best categories ended up being my dreamies, or some of my first NL villagers, lol. What can I say, NL was my first game in the AC series and I grew attached to my first crew.

Best
Normal: Pekoe
Peppy: Bonbon
Snooty: Olivia
Uchi: Phoebe
Lazy: Ozzie
Jock: Snake
Cranky: Knox. I WILL FIGHT FOR MY KNIGHT CHICKEN BRO
Smug: Shep

Worst
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Alli
Uchi: Muffy
Lazy: Barold
Jock: Stinky
Cranky: Gaston
Smug: Pietro

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Fauna
Peppy: Sprinkle
Snooty: Whitney
Uchi: Phoebe

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Cole
Jock: Antonio
Cranky: Fang
Smug: Colton

Least Attractive/Ugliest
Normal: Jambette, again
Peppy: Again, Tabby
Snooty: Cashmere
Uchi: Hazel (dat unibrow...)
Lazy: Need I say it, again? Barold
Jock: Coach
Cranky: It's really a tie between Gaston and Limberg for me
Smug: Beardo

Most Overrated
Normal: Goldie
Peppy: Chrissy
Snooty: Diana, even though I love her
Uchi: Canberra (I don't hate her, I just don't get why people love her)
Lazy: Bob
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: For the third time, Gaston. IDK why, he looks super popular among a lot of AC players I follow on Twitter and Tumblr. Does not compute
Smug: Marshal

Most Underrated
Normal: Gladys
Peppy: Patty
Snooty: Julia
Uchi: Rocket. She's my girl. I will fight for her.
Lazy: Rex
Jock: Tybalt
Cranky: Bruce
Smug: Keaton