Tangy or Rosie?

[cosmic-latte]

I currently have Rosie in my town, but I'm wondering if I should trade her for Tangy.

 

[AkaneDeath]

If it were me I'd definitely go for Tangy as I think she's cuter but Rosie has always been a 'meh' villager for me so I might be a little biased.

 

[Charirii]

They're both fab! I had Tangy in ACWW, but I have Rosie in ACNL, and I loooove them both. <3

 

[Vizionari]

I like Rosie better, she appeals to me better than Tangy does.

 

[roseflower]

Rosie is so lovely, I have her in my game cube town. I think Tangy has weird eyes in New Leaf, so I wouldn?t recommend her, she was way cuter in the older games.

 

[Arabelle]

Rosie is really cute c:

 

[Kittilicious]

I might be a bit biased, but I picked Rosie because of the animal crossing movie.

 

[regigiygas]

I love them both honestly. I'm a complete sucker for the peppy babies and I've had them both in my town at one point, heh.


I like Tangy's house/music better though

 

[cosmic-latte]

This is honestly such a hard decision, but thanks for the opinions!

 

[ShinyYoshi]

I personally like Rosie better, but sometimes it makes the game more fun to have a new face around town.

 

[FancyThat]

Rosie is my favourite villager so I have to vote for her :3, Tangy is very cute though.

 

[EmmaFrost]

Tangy c:
She's such a cute little orange.

 

[Lualdara]

I used to dislike both of them for some reason, but after having them I like both! I have Tangy in my current town and she was a random move in who plotted too close to the town hall so at first I was going to sell her, but after interacting with her I decided I'm gonna keep her. I like to headcanon her as a cat with dermatillomania (a mental illness I have; it makes you compulsively pick at your skin until it's all scabbed, I thought it fit with the orange-like "pores" on her face plus it makes me feel better about my own dermatillomania). She also randomly picked up other villager's shirt (it's a green+light green striped one) and, even though I like to keep my villagers all original, I thought it fit her better than her original one so it's staying that way, haha. It also doesn't help it that I have oranges as my native fruit, so honestly she fit right in. So I voted Tangy c:

 

[toadsworthy]

Rosie is super cute, I will admit... but Tangy is so quirky and fun to have around! she is a cat-orange, like who thinks of that lol!

she was the first move-in to my original GC town and she has been my absolute favorite since!

 

[eggs]

tangy is cute and all, but i prefer rosie! there's just something about her aura that really appeals to me. she's sweet, adorable, and you can act like she's your little sister or something of the sort. kind of like lolly, you know? U//v//U

 

[daiyuflower]

I guess it depends on who else you have in your town ^__^ They're both adorable but between the two, Rosie is my pick. I have her in my town and she's so cute!

 

[isebrilia]

I had Rosie in my town and she moved unexpectedly ;-;
They're both adorable, but I would pick Rosie!