Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
this one, i thought you are saying here rubber ducky role makes sense as cop
Mafia Squeaky Clean Mafia - Day 3 - Ends Monday May 25 at 7pm EST
- Thread starter toadsworthy
- Start date
this one, i thought you are saying here rubber ducky role makes sense as cop
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
oh no i was saying it makes no sense and trying to connect roles with names is pointless
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
thanks Daniel for clarifying that point. I am going back and forth to Geoni and Trundle. I feel like Trundle and Geoni must both show up and say something before I could make a decision on who to vote. But six hours into it, I have a feeling they won't show up. I am inclined to vote Geoni but Trundle's inactivity bothers me a lot. And he didn't even vote.
As for Illunie, my biggest impression was when said "omg, Antonio is so scummy" or something to that effect. Which my impression is that is so townreaction if I see one. Is Illunie a different username for one of our older members?
Damniel, epona and dinotown. I am not going to vote them as I believe they have racked up towniepoints to their merit.
Post automatically merged:
So we have 7 people left...
If Kat and Mayor are town
a) in a three mafia worst case scenario, we have 3 vs. 4....which means we are at MYLO.
b) in a 2 mafia, 1 TP, we have 2 vs. 4 vs. 1 which means if we get it right today, it will be 1 vs. 4 vs. 1 and the game will continue.
if we have mislynch, it will be 1 vs. 3 vs. 1
If one of them is scum
a) In a three mafia worst case scenario, we have 2 vs. 5, we get it right, we get 1 vs. 5, game continues, we dont get it right , its 2 vs 4
b) in a 2 mafia , 1 TP , we have 1 vs. 5 vs .1
If both are scum
a) in a three mafia worst case scenario, we have 1 vs. 6
b) in a 2 mafia, 1 TP, then we should have won by now which we didnt.
Last edited:
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
Why would we have won in a 2 mafia 1 TP scenario if Kat+Mayor were scum? There's still threats to the town alive-
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
oh i was thinking if TP is not a threat like survivor, So if infector is a third party, they still need to die, you're right. so if TP is not hostile to town, then we would have won
had a weird weekend so sorry for being a bit less active than i have been up until now (the game has also been incredibly slow because a decent enough portion of players who are left alive aren't really posting at all)
realistically i'm not townreading anybody anymore but i agree that geoni and trundle are the two most urgent lynch candidates at the moment so will try to ISO them both tomorrow and make a substantial enough post so i can decide who i want to vote for
it's so annoying that the lynches so far have been flipless because we literally have no idea whether or not we're close to (or potentially at) MYLO or not
realistically i'm not townreading anybody anymore but i agree that geoni and trundle are the two most urgent lynch candidates at the moment so will try to ISO them both tomorrow and make a substantial enough post so i can decide who i want to vote for
it's so annoying that the lynches so far have been flipless because we literally have no idea whether or not we're close to (or potentially at) MYLO or not
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
Agree with Damniel, this game without many flips is just not for me.
Geoni did at least appear with a spectacularly lacklustre post while Trundle is still totally MIA, so Geoni is probably the safer vote in terms of avoiding a potential MK.
Geoni did at least appear with a spectacularly lacklustre post while Trundle is still totally MIA, so Geoni is probably the safer vote in terms of avoiding a potential MK.
i don't follow this logic
voting geoni doesn't avoid trundle being modkilled it just means they'll both probably die lmao
DinoTown
Festive Fossil
I'm not trying to avoid Trundle being MK'd, I'm trying to avoid voting for someone who will probably just get MK'd anyway
Post automatically merged:
I realised I worded it weird at first, sorry. But I meant avoid voting for an MK
yeah okay i've done a quick ISO of both trundle and geoni but can't really be bothered actually quoting anything/making cases because i doubt either of them will be around to make any sort of response to it
trundle has 3 pages worth of posts all game vs. geoni's 5 pages
trundle hops in every now and then to make a comment about something, respond to something somebody said about him, or scumread me (lol)
his last post was thursday, saying that he was going to ISO my posts and make a decent enough case against me which never materialised and he hasn't posted since
geoni by contrast has actually alluded to his schedule being crappy at the moment and recent inactivity aside, has been engaging with the game a lot more than trundle has (asking questions, giving reads etc etc)
ya i'm too lazy to quote but you can see it fairly starkly if you just ISO them both. neither of them have posted much so it's not hard to do
i don't think they're both scum for reasons i've stated earlier (although honestly RIP if they are, no danger in buddying if you know lynches won't flip anyway, and we've all had the tendency to sort of group them together in town reads as a result) so i'm thinking one is scum and one is town
my hypothesis (potential modkills aside):
if trundle is scum, daniel is also scum
looking back through their posts i can't see why dan is so pushy about lynching geoni when trundle's contributions have been even less satisfactory
if geoni is scum, i think he's either the last remaining scum (most likely) or dino/illunie is also scum
i'm interested in hearing what @illunie has to say (if anything) but at this point i'm more comfortable lynching trundle than geoni
thank u
yeah okay i've done a quick ISO of both trundle and geoni but can't really be bothered actually quoting anything/making cases because i doubt either of them will be around to make any sort of response to it
trundle has 3 pages worth of posts all game vs. geoni's 5 pages
trundle hops in every now and then to make a comment about something, respond to something somebody said about him, or scumread me (lol)
his last post was thursday, saying that he was going to ISO my posts and make a decent enough case against me which never materialised and he hasn't posted since
geoni by contrast has actually alluded to his schedule being crappy at the moment and recent inactivity aside, has been engaging with the game a lot more than trundle has (asking questions, giving reads etc etc)
ya i'm too lazy to quote but you can see it fairly starkly if you just ISO them both. neither of them have posted much so it's not hard to do
i don't think they're both scum for reasons i've stated earlier (although honestly RIP if they are, no danger in buddying if you know lynches won't flip anyway, and we've all had the tendency to sort of group them together in town reads as a result) so i'm thinking one is scum and one is town
my hypothesis (potential modkills aside):
if trundle is scum, daniel is also scum
looking back through their posts i can't see why dan is so pushy about lynching geoni when trundle's contributions have been even less satisfactory
if geoni is scum, i think he's either the last remaining scum (most likely) or dino/illunie is also scum
i'm interested in hearing what @illunie has to say (if anything) but at this point i'm more comfortable lynching trundle than geoni
thank u
trundle has 3 pages worth of posts all game vs. geoni's 5 pages
trundle hops in every now and then to make a comment about something, respond to something somebody said about him, or scumread me (lol)
his last post was thursday, saying that he was going to ISO my posts and make a decent enough case against me which never materialised and he hasn't posted since
geoni by contrast has actually alluded to his schedule being crappy at the moment and recent inactivity aside, has been engaging with the game a lot more than trundle has (asking questions, giving reads etc etc)
ya i'm too lazy to quote but you can see it fairly starkly if you just ISO them both. neither of them have posted much so it's not hard to do
i don't think they're both scum for reasons i've stated earlier (although honestly RIP if they are, no danger in buddying if you know lynches won't flip anyway, and we've all had the tendency to sort of group them together in town reads as a result) so i'm thinking one is scum and one is town
my hypothesis (potential modkills aside):
if trundle is scum, daniel is also scum
looking back through their posts i can't see why dan is so pushy about lynching geoni when trundle's contributions have been even less satisfactory
if geoni is scum, i think he's either the last remaining scum (most likely) or dino/illunie is also scum
i'm interested in hearing what @illunie has to say (if anything) but at this point i'm more comfortable lynching trundle than geoni
thank u
Post automatically merged:
yeah okay i've done a quick ISO of both trundle and geoni but can't really be bothered actually quoting anything/making cases because i doubt either of them will be around to make any sort of response to it
trundle has 3 pages worth of posts all game vs. geoni's 5 pages
trundle hops in every now and then to make a comment about something, respond to something somebody said about him, or scumread me (lol)
his last post was thursday, saying that he was going to ISO my posts and make a decent enough case against me which never materialised and he hasn't posted since
geoni by contrast has actually alluded to his schedule being crappy at the moment and recent inactivity aside, has been engaging with the game a lot more than trundle has (asking questions, giving reads etc etc)
ya i'm too lazy to quote but you can see it fairly starkly if you just ISO them both. neither of them have posted much so it's not hard to do
i don't think they're both scum for reasons i've stated earlier (although honestly RIP if they are, no danger in buddying if you know lynches won't flip anyway, and we've all had the tendency to sort of group them together in town reads as a result) so i'm thinking one is scum and one is town
my hypothesis (potential modkills aside):
if trundle is scum, daniel is also scum
looking back through their posts i can't see why dan is so pushy about lynching geoni when trundle's contributions have been even less satisfactory
if geoni is scum, i think he's either the last remaining scum (most likely) or dino/illunie is also scum
i'm interested in hearing what @illunie has to say (if anything) but at this point i'm more comfortable lynching trundle than geoni
thank u
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
i haven't pushed trundle bc i haven't been able to interact with him. he disappeared when i came in
i just figured trundle is just gonna be mod killed so id rather lynch geo who i have sus on than an inactive. he didn't vote D2 and hasn't posted since N2 so I think he's gonna be mod killed by EoD
by PoE if the game isn't over by the time those two are bed its probs just illunie
i just figured trundle is just gonna be mod killed so id rather lynch geo who i have sus on than an inactive. he didn't vote D2 and hasn't posted since N2 so I think he's gonna be mod killed by EoD
Post automatically merged:
by PoE if the game isn't over by the time those two are bed its probs just illunie
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
okay trundle posted a bit when i came in but he was most active in D1 which i wasn't here for. he just feels like an inactive to me. i don't think scum who cared would be borderline breaking the activity rules
Post automatically merged:
do you think that is more sus than geo's behavior tho
i kinda think he doesn't care, he's been extremely limited in his activity since the beginning but weirdly (as bell pointed out - RIP) responded almost immediately when dino called him out for something so i think he was deliberately reading and not posting for the first half of the game at least
my guess is he randed scum in a game full of a lot of new (or in my case extremely rusty) players and figured he'd walk it by being townread at the start and then posting less and less until he was kind of just forgotten about or at least fell very very far down in everyone's priority list
Damniel
Openly Wolfing
i mean if he doesn't post and vote within the next 5 hours i think that's just a mod kill. i don't doubt he's not scum but i think he's gonna be mokdilled anyways and therefore a waste of a lynch
if he does come in tho to just barely avoid the mod kill its probably him
yea true
i'll keep my vote on him for now and switch to geoni (or honestly illunie) if trundle doesn't stick his head in by tonight
at this stage i am finding it hard to care LOL unless the scumteam is literally you, me and dinotown (lmao) we got either a very inactive or very dead mafia
i'll keep my vote on him for now and switch to geoni (or honestly illunie) if trundle doesn't stick his head in by tonight
at this stage i am finding it hard to care LOL unless the scumteam is literally you, me and dinotown (lmao) we got either a very inactive or very dead mafia
