View attachment 310340
Here is my tier list. Normally I only use the S, A, B, C, and D tiers, but none of the sisterly villager are below average or awful to me and therefore, I added an A+ and an S+ tier. Here are my opinion for each villager:
S+: Agnes is my favorite pig, and has a unique color scheme that I wholeheartedly love. Hazel is my favorite villager of this personality and I love the unibrow she has. She is proud of it, as her catchphrase suggests, and is such a cutie. Plus, a Twitter post by the YouTuber littlesiha (who I'm subscribed to by the way. Go check it out, she has some awesome content of the Just Dance video game series, which I like a lot.) that depicts her cosplaying Hazel has made love her even more. Mira is a cool rabbit with an awesome house interior. I really love her heroine aesthetic, and is super unique. The primary color combo suits her well. Muffy is a goth sheep, with makes her stand out. I really like how her horns remind me of earmuffs. Pashmina has been on my island since the beginning, and she is such a sweetie. I dig her cerulean horns. Phoebe is a phoenix, which is incredible and I adore her for that. Plucky is a cutie; I especially like the blue on the top of her head. She also gets points for being one of the few sisterly villager to make her debut before New Leaf.
S: Cherry is a standout dog, and is cherry red, as her name suggests. I do think that her name is a bit too similar to the cub named Cheri, though. Rocket is an awesome Power Ranger gorilla and I wish received more love. I do think it is strange that whenever you give her any other clothing, she puts it on top of what she already has on. Shari is the best monkey and I like how she resembles a squirrel monkey. I will defend her with all my heart.
A+ Fuchsia's name makes sense to her fur color, and has great bangs. I just find it problematic that I've seen her have the catchphrases of "precious" and "girlfriend." What triggers her to have these two phrases? I do hear her say "precious" more often, though. I have a soft spot for Katt. She was the first villager of this personality that I knew of (thanks to ZackScottGames) and though her eyes are too close to each other, she stands out compared to other female villagers. Paula is a cool-looking hippie bear and is criminally underrated. I have a younger sister whose middle name is Paula, and therefore I'll always like fer for that. Reneigh is a great addition to the sisterly personality and while she has a very similar name to another villager of the same personality, she is superior to me. Sylvia is my favorite of the kangaroos; her bright purple fur is good, as it makes her standout, and points go to her for being one of the first villager of this personality to be introduced. I can say the same thing to Ursala, and she also has the distinction of being the only villager as of now to have their name start with the letter U. I also think she's a sweetheart.
A: Diva is a unique frog and i especially like her blue-violet skin. I don't understand why it looks like she has hair or her ancient Egypt-themed house, though. Flo is a unique emo-looking penguin. I don't have much to say about her after that. Aside from her style, she look also much like a normal penguin. Tammy is a unique cub with a very interesting bear cub, but I will admit, she has a very similar to another villager. I do think this Tammy is much cooler, though.
B: Canberra's angry looking face is something that I can't really get over. Despite that though, I don't think she's all that bad. Charlise has a very unique color scheme, but to some, It can really be a problem. I also don't like her as much as Paula or Ursala, though she is, at the very least, a bit caring. Deirdre is a bit of an unusual case. I like her house interior and gray fur, but the white lips and eye makeup creep me out, especially considering how the lips look like teeth. Frita has a unique design that reminds me of fast food. I do think it makes her look like she is good enough to eat, which I feel bad for. I really hope no one tries to even think of eating Frita. And finally is Renee, who looks angry and I don't find her to be as good as any of the other rhinos. I do think her design is at the very least good.
P.S. I do wish for more villagers of this personality. A sisterly bird (probably named Skylar) or elephant/hippo would be welcome.
