Should I Replace Skye With Rosie?

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Ok so, my ultimate dream villagers are Ankha and Rosie. I'm scheduled to get Ankha sometime today and I'm totally psyched about that, but I still want Rosie. The only villager I'm even the tiniest bit considering to get rid of in my town to have room for Rosie is Skye. But I'm still torn because a) she's a wolf and I love the AC wolves, b) she's extremely adorable and c) my friend who loved her very much gave her up because I wanted her so badly at the time. So the question is, should I get Skye to move out despite these factors?

 

[Xara]

well i have skye and i adore her, but really its all about personal preference

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Well the thing is I already have 2 normal villagers besides Skye and my town is sorely lacking in peppy villagers like Rosie.

 

[Xara]

Well the thing is I already have 2 normal villagers besides Skye and my town is sorely lacking in peppy villagers like Rosie.

well in that case, i think you should get rosie.
i have 3 normal villagers living in my town, and while i love them dearly, it does get boring having more than 2 normal villagers

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Exactly. I love Fauna and Merengue to pieces and wouldn't trade them for anything, but I like Skye slightly less and think it's time for a change. Thanks for your input!

 

[Sholee]

I also agree, you should definitely pick up Rosie if you're lacking in peppy personalities

 

[namiieco]

I also agree, you should definitely pick up Rosie if you're lacking in peppy personalities

agreed

i do really like skye tho

 

[Altarium]

If you lack a peppy and have too many normals, you should do it. Even still, Skye is 999x times better than Rosie will ever be

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Poor Rosie, she's 999x less loved than Skye XD

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also thank you everyone for your input! I will work on getting Skye out then.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, would anyone like her when she moves out? I'll take offers of IGB or TBT

 

[Leen]

Yes.

Rosie is everything <3

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Lol, Rosie is going from unloved to everything on this thread. It's funny how opinions differ so much on the same villager.

 

[Buttonsy]

Sure!! If she will make you have more fun in your town, go for it.

And if you feel bad about having gotten Skye from your friend, you could either let your friend do the 16 villager cycle and then give Skye back, or else sell Skye for TBT or IGB and then give it to your friend as a gift, just as suggestions.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

That's a good idea! I mean I feel bad because I pretty much begged for her and promised I'd keep her forever but I got tired of her

 

[Altarium]

Lol, Rosie is going from unloved to everything on this thread. It's funny how opinions differ so much on the same villager.

lol sorry, I just find her and Lolly a bit overrated

She's still definitely a nice peppy. She's no Ruby though, but still nice.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

It's ok! Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I myself, for instance, don't understand why people like Genji. XD

 

[pika62221]

Rosie is pretty adorable too, and starred in the movie. Skye is new to New Leaf, and a normal. Ankha and Rosie are both cats though, and both are pretty desired top tier villagers, so even though I have both Skye and Rosie, if I were you choosing between the two, Rosie gets it.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Yes I had Rosie for quite a while and she was lovely....but I got bored of her after a while. Whereas Skye I still love as much as ever. Find her more unique for some reason and I love her colouring. Plus, she goes so well with fang who is one of my favourites villagers ever

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Thanks for commenting, everyone! I did indeed get Rosie and I even managed to plot reset her into a good spot. She's such a cutie omg <3