Should I let Peanut go?

[Stalfos]

It's decision time!

I've had Peanut for over a year now. A few days ago she asked to move and tomorrow is the day she'll be all packed up. Problem is I still haven't decided if I should let her. I currently have 3 peppy villagers - Peanut, Bella and Anabelle. I can't get rid of Anabelle at the moment since she was the last one to move in so it's either Peanut or Bella. I just don't know who I should keep. Also, plot resetting for new villagers is a huge pain in the behind.

So here's where you guys come in. I really need some advice on what to do. Thanks.

 

[Vizionari]

Peanut is one of my favorite peppies, if I were you I would keep her. But since you have 3 peppy villagers already, I suppose it's up to you to decide

 

[HHoney]

Three is too many of one type of villager. It's a hard decision.

But if Annabelle moved in as number 10, it's time to let Bella or Peanut.

Yes. I am actually in a similar position. I have 2 peppies, Peanut - one of my first 5, and Wendy moved in as number 10.

I've had Peanut in every Animal Crossing town in all the versions, so we have history. It used to make me mad that it was always her, but she just wants to be a part of my AC world. I'm curious to see who wants to ping me next.


Maybe there are other villagers you have never had that you could experience.

Who would you like to see in your town?

 

[Stalfos]

Yeah, she's a sweetie and I've grown quite fond of her but one year is a long time. Maybe it's time for a change?

 

[ams]

I'd personally keep her since I prefer her over Bella.

 

[Stalfos]

Three is too many of one type of villager. It's a hard decision.

But if Annabelle moved in as number 10, it's time to let Bella or Peanut.

Yes. I am actually in a similar position. I have 2 peppies, Peanut - one of my first 5, and Wendy moved in as number 10.

I've had Peanut in every Animal Crossing town in all the versions, so we have history. It used to make me mad that it was always her, but she just wants to be a part of my AC world. I'm curious to see who wants to ping me next.


Maybe there are other villagers you have never had that you could experience.

Who would you like to see in your town?

There's so many villagers I'd like to experience; Beau, Lionel, Diva, Hazel, Whitney and Diana are the first to come to mind.
But since I'm lacking snooties and uchis, I guess those marked in bold would be best.

 

[jiny]

I have so many normals in my town if you can tell by my sig xD

I'd say don't let her leave, since she's really cute and Bella's.... ehhh

I only have one peppy and it's Rosie and I'm kind of getting tired of her, I want a new peppy.
Maple moved out and her spot's reserved for Caroline, who I reserved on a cycle thread.
But when Rosie wants to leave, I'll replace her with either a snooty or a smug. I've never had smug villagers in my town ever.
So yeah! Let Peanut stay. You won't regret it.

 

[HopeForHyrule]

Peanut is such a sweetheart...I had her in Bunifrey and was so sad when she unexpectedly moved out. Thankfully she moved into my boyfriend's town from my void, so I can still visit her.

I say keep her. Because she's great.

 

[Stalfos]

I have so many normals in my town if you can tell by my sig xD

I'd say don't let her leave, since she's really cute and Bella's.... ehhh

I only have one peppy and it's Rosie and I'm kind of getting tired of her, I want a new peppy.
Maple moved out and her spot's reserved for Caroline, who I reserved on a cycle thread.
But when Rosie wants to leave, I'll replace her with either a snooty or a smug. I've never had smug villagers in my town ever.
So yeah! Let Peanut stay. You won't regret it.

Yeah, but normals are the best.

It'd much easier to plot Bella's replacement since she has a more open area. If I move out Peanut I'd have to plot her replacement in that exact same 3x3 spot. :/

 

[HHoney]

Yeah, but normals are the best.

It'd much easier to plot Bella's replacement since she has a more open area. If I move out Peanut I'd have to plot her replacement in that exact same 3x3 spot. :/

You said the magic words. If Peanut moved out In my town I think I would want someone in her same 3x3 spot.

Don't let Peanut go!
Wait for Bella. More plot options is ALWAYS less stressful.

And then get Hazel - Peanut just told me this morning she had a makeup accident with her eyeliner and she drew a unibrow! I think it is a sign!

 

[Stalfos]

You said the magic words. If Peanut moved out In my town I think I would want someone in her same 3x3 spot.

Don't let Peanut go!
Wait for Bella. More plot options is ALWAYS less stressful.

And then get Hazel - Peanut just told me this morning she had a makeup accident with her eyeliner and she drew a unibrow! I think it is a sign!

Lol! Yeah, I think so too! It's decided then. I'm gonna go tell Peanut to stay. Thanks for all your help.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I just asked her to stay so now it's settled!