Rosie or Tangy

[heirabbit]

I found Rosie in my campsite today and I have been eyeing her for a very long time but I already have Tangy. I'm only planning on keeping one peppy villager.

So the question is, Rosie or Tangy? I'm easily convinced!

- - - Post Merge - - -

I love Tangy so much though, but Rosie would really fit well with my pastel-themed town.

 

[sn0wxyuki]

I never like Tangy at all, lol, maybe cause I don't like the "pimples" on her face xD so yea bias to ROSIE!! dang dang dang~

 

[Chime]

Rosie!
I'm not a huge fan of Tangy

 

[UchiCherry]

I prefer Tangy, Rosie was a dreamie but I kicked her off my list, I found her boring.

Tangy left my town with no notice. :'(

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Tangy.
I like both, but I prefer Tangy.

 

[Hound00med]

DEFINITELY ROSIE

Ugh I hate Tangy so much >.>

 

[Gizmodo]

^How dare you!

Tangy is amazing.. ill never forget being 5, and following her arounnd everywhere in GC, and just thinking she was fab
Tangy>>>>>>All Cats

 

[MannyK]

I LOVE Tangy, Rosies just a plain ol cat, Tangy is a living orange!

 

[fairyring]

I just think Tangy is awesome. Also, something about Rosie has always put me off. Maybe it's the shape of her mouth? I think Tangy is much more interesting, since she's got a theme to her rather than just being a plain old blue cat. But pick whoever you like the best!

 

[Waluigi]

Do you want food or a kitten?

I would go with rosie, she is so cute and until new leaf she was my fav villager ever, being my main wild world bff

 

[ALLCAPS]

I like both, but I'm really partial to Tangy. I mean... she's a fruit kitty. Regular cats can't even begin to touch that. Plus I love orange. o wo

I never knew about Tangy until ACNL, to be honest. She was one of the first villagers I ever wanted as a dreamie since I discovered the notion of "dreamies". She's perfect.

 

[Gizmodo]

I like both, but I'm really partial to Tangy. I mean... she's a fruit kitty. Regular cats can't even begin to touch that. Plus I love orange. o wo

I never knew about Tangy until ACNL, to be honest. She was one of the first villagers I ever wanted as a dreamie since I discovered the notion of "dreamies". She's perfect.

Preach It
Tangy 4 Life<33
I hadn't had her since Gamecube when i was 5/6 so to have her in New leaf is amazing<33 i missed her in WW & CF

 

[Plupap]

Honestly, they both look unnatural and creep me out. I don't like either of them and I really dislike Tangy. If you need a new dreamie pick an actually cute cat like Kiki or Ankha.

 

[KidKat]

Definitely Tangy, ive had both and found Rosie to be really plain and boring. Tangy is so much more unique and a lot cuter in my opinion. Plus it will save you the hassle of trying to move her out

 

[uwuzumakii]

This was so hard for me to choose, but Tangy is more awesome than Rosie in my opinion. I liked Rosie in the movie, but I have Tangy in my GameCube town and he is so cool!

 

[PsychoGeek]

Definitely Rosie! I guess I'm biased because I have a sentimental attachment to her (she was in my first AC town in the game cube version) but I prefer Rosie 100%. Ultimately it's your decision though

 

[Bosca]

This seems to be an old thread, but ofc Tangy. Best villager in the whole game.

 

[Dunquixote]

I just met Rosie for the first time today in a dream town and I haven't met Tangy yet; based on appearance, I think Rosie is the cuter one. :] But, I'm sure they're both cute and unique in their own ways

 

[Nizzy]

Tangy is bae forever

 

[Infatuation]

Rosie! She was my BFF in AC:WW. I don't like Tangy's face as much too u-u