Rosie or Bluebear?

[fenris]

So, I'm pretty much settled on a list of dreamies for my all-blue town, but I can't seem to pick a peppy villager.

I've got it narrowed down to either Rosie or Bluebear, but they're both too cute to pass up.

Here's my current list:

Smug: Julian
Jock: Bam
Lazy: Hugh, Jeremiah
Cranky: Wolfgang
Normal: Skye, Bertha
Snooty: Naomi
Uchi: Flo
Peppy: (??)

Ideally, I'd like all my villagers to look nice together. Also, if anybody has suggestions for other villagers that might look nice, I'd be happy to consider them!

ETA: I'm very tentatively considering replacing Jeremiah with a second peppy, but I'm not sure I want to. I've had him before, and he's adorable... still, I thought I'd put the option forward.

 

[Mink777]

I would chose Bluebear because she is less popular.

 

[Ursaring]

They're both very cute, but I prefer Bluebear.

 

[GTsTentacleChow]

BLUEBEAR OMG

 

[DaCoSim]

Bluebear is the sweetest little cub. Luv her!

 

[helloxcutiee]

I like Bluebear a lot more than Rosie. She's adorable!

 

[fenris]

Wow, as popular as Rosie is, I was kind of expecting her to be in the lead. I'm not displeased, though - Bluebear is a total cutie.

Still, I'd like to get some more votes before I make up my mind.

 

[Kirbystarship]

I pick Rosie. She is a nice villager.

 

[AquaStrudel]

I voted Rosie, she's a classic.

 

[Cascade]

Both cute but i prefer Rosie than Bluebear

 

[ZebraQueen]

Blue bear it's cute but I just pick Rosie because I never experienced blue bear

 

[HungryForCereal]

i voted for rosie and im actually surprised at how bluebear is winning the vote currently o.o anyway, go for rosie definitely. shes a cat and her design is so simple and cute. whats not to love about her seriously? bluebear is kinda ugly imo. please dont hate me bluebear fans

 

[BuckOfTheFawns]

They're both in my town and have no offers lol. Whichever one wins, I'll trade them with you.

 

[Rabirin]

Usually popular villagers are the most dissapointing for me, because I set so many high expectations for them because they wouldn't be popular for no reason, right? and often I find that they are just idk, kinda boring when you have them? I know the majority of villagers say the same things but it just feels like you can have some villagers who are really quirky and add something to the town but with higher tiers I don't feel that way and I find the majority of them boring but that's just my opinion. Personally I'd go with Bluebear following with what i've said, because most higher tier villagers i've had i've found boring and I just find Bluebear's catchphrase really cute. Even cuter than Rosie's tbh, I say go with what you feel or character model you like better. For example say you prefer cats in game to dogs in game. Maybe it'll help you to choose if you pick that way.

 

[HungryForCereal]

i voted for rosie and im actually surprised at how bluebear is winning the vote currently o.o anyway, go for rosie definitely. shes a cat and her design is so simple and cute. whats not to love about her seriously? bluebear is kinda ugly imo. please dont hate me bluebear fans

 

[kenna]

I think Bluebear is cuter!

 

[louise23]

I would say Rosie but it is up to you

 

[Kurashiki]

I love both of them, but i'd go for Bluebear

 

[namiieco]

Rosie because I hate cubs