Important note for the future:
You did not add that Dreamie Proof was required until 4:30PM EST. Because of this, anyone who requested before that even without proof has the right to receive it. It's your fault for not listing it ahead of time and denying those people because you forgot is incredibly unfair.
If you already gave the villager away to another person, there's not much that can be done, but if not, I hope you do the right thing.