Definitely Judy. I like the pastel gradients on her fur, her snootiness, and I think her big sparkly eyes are pretty. Raymond doesn't appeal to me at all. Not even being a cat, smug, or the heterochromia is enough for me to like him. I'm not into the glasses, either.
Gotta go with Raymond, one day... he will come home.
I do love pastel colors but I'm also that person that will use a dark theme over a light theme, its just more pleasing to my eye.