Raymond vs Judy

[-Apples-]

I voted Judy, not because Raymond is overrated, but because Judy is the best of the new villagers introduced in ACNH.

 

[Sloom]

not being horrible to people who like raymond or anynothing, but he's one of my least favourite new ones
he's just kinda plain, and the competition is way too good imo

clearly people disagree tho lmao

 

[Heartcore]

I have both. I definitely like Raymond more but I really adore Judy as well. But the real answer is Sherb.

 

[Han Solo]

Judy is hideous, especially her eyes. Raymond is okay. Sherb is the best out of the new ones imo.

 

[honeypuff]

Judy is hideous, especially her eyes. Raymond is okay. Sherb is the best out of the new ones imo.

Ya I have Sherb I love him

 

[RoyNumber1]

Picked Judy, not because she's in my island, but because I like her design more than Raymond.

 

[Ezamoosh]

I adore Judy's colour scheme anyway but this tweet really was the one that hooked me:

https://twitter.com/x/status/1230624872713224192

I can't look at Raymond and not think of my edgy teen anime friends and OCs (down to the heterochromia...) so I find it hard to like him LOL

 

[tybalt_cake]

Judy is cute , but if it wasnt for her eyes I would like her more

 

[Faery Whimsy]

Definitely Raymond, no contest. Judy looks weird to me, I don’t really like her.

 

[trashpedia]

I know everyone else is dissing Judy for her eyes but I wanna say it: Her eyes and overall design reminds me of those Deviant Art chibi bases people would recolor over and post without crediting the original artist back in 2011.

But I do like both of them! I lean more towards Raymond but Judy is lovely as well.

 

[TearsFromEatingFlan]

I have Judy and she is kinda annoying. Sometimes she just stands in the same place dancing and never walks anywhere
I am still keeping her in the meantime but she's not a dreamie for sure. Raymond is one I hope to have someday, I'm patiently waiting.

Sherb >>>>> Raymond >> the others tbh

 

[ayeeprill]

Not a big fan of either one (Audie, Sherb, Megan, Cyd, and Reneigh are my fave new villagers)

I like Judy a little more than Raymond though.

 

[LatenDale]

I like both, though overall prefer Raymond as Judy's eyes can be a bit odd at times. Out of the new villagers I have, I'd probably rank them as Raymond, Audie, Judy and then Reneigh who is a sleeper hit I reckon.

 

[Laureline]

I like them both and want both, but I votes Judy as she is number one dreamie.

 

[fallenchaoskitten]

Literally the moment I saw his design before the game launched I (...and all my friends knew...) I wanted him. So business. So cute.

His name disappointed me, but didnt deter me.

Guessed he'd be smug and he was so looks like my dream island now will have two smugs. Lol

I have a thing for grumpy kitties....
My #1 is Kabuki who is a Cranky Cat and looks grumpy (...and evil per my BF)
One of my IRL cats have a flat head that makes him look angry or distressed 90% of the time.

So, i am pretty disappointed he is very hyped and thus hard to get right now. But thats ok. I'm sure he will be worth the wait in the end when I eventually have him on Wishdrop.

 

[Murin]

I found Judy on an island while searching for Raymond. I felt bad passing her up since she's new/sought after, so I invited her. She's growing on me, but I would still rather have Raymond. I just love cats :/

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Raymond is Lameond. Judy is.. Goody

I also really like Megan and Sherb (of course)

 

[Flare]

I like Raymond more for his simple design. I think Judy has the more creative design out of the two. I always thought Judy was gonna be the most popular villager of the new ones.

 

[honeypuff]

bump

 

[Envy]

Definitely Raymond. I always thought he looked neat. Judy has never stuck out to me.