Punchy or Beau?

[gem83]

Thanks to those of you who let me visit some villagers in your dream towns, I'm pretty sure I've narrowed my list down to these two lazies! I'll do a little pros-and-cons type thing since whichever one I get will be my last villager and if I don't like him I can't get rid of him. ._.

Beau
Pros:

• Adorable
• Tier 1 (so he won't be hard to find)
• Cute music!!!
• Another deer (love them)

Cons:

• Another deer (I already have one)
• Expensive :/ (saving up to help my little brother with his future town)
• Everyone ever has him

Punchy
Pros:

• Cat (more species variation)
• Cute house
• Cute face

Cons:

• I can't seem to find him anywhere
• My close friend has Bob, another lazy cat, and we already share two villagers (Chief and Deirdre)
• ???
• Idk?
• Did I just render this whole post pointless

So, from what I said up there, vote on who you think I should get!

Since I forgot to make the poll, I have to count the votes myself wow so strenuous aaaaaa
Beau: 4
Punchy: 13

 

[yukikotobuki]

Personally, and even based on your pros and cons list, I'd pick Punchy.

 

[Ichigo.]

gonna argue for beau, just because i have him in my town and i love him. i've always been in love with his design ever since i saw him on someone's let's play it is sorta annoying that everyone has him, but i don't let that bother me!

 

[edsett]

I'd go with Punchy. I find Beau very bland. Still, you listed more personal pros for Beau than Punchy.

 

[gem83]

Personally, and even based on your pros and cons list, I'd pick Punchy.

Thank you! (I'll count these up since I forgot to add a poll fml)

- - - Post Merge - - -

gonna argue for beau, just because i have him in my town and i love him. i've always been in love with his design ever since i saw him on someone's let's play it is sorta annoying that everyone has him, but i don't let that bother me!

Thanks! (Omg that's how my love for the eagles began. I watched an LP and the dude had Amelia and Apollo as starters)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'd go with Punchy. I find Beau very bland. Still, you listed more personal pros for Beau than Punchy.

Thank you! I love your town names omfg

 

[Mothership]

I'd pick Punchy! Beau's eyes bother me...dunno why exactly. Besides Punchy is a cat and cats are awesome

 

[Ichigo.]

Thanks! (Omg that's how my love for the eagles began. I watched an LP and the dude had Amelia and Apollo as starters)

omg i wonder if this was the same guy? i think it was zackscottgames or something like that. he hated beau though, and i couldn't understand why he'd let him leave!

 

[Adaberny]

Beau all the way! Hes such a lovable guy, its hard not to get attached to him.

 

[gem83]

omg i wonder if this was the same guy? i think it was zackscottgames or something like that. he hated beau though, and i couldn't understand why he'd let him leave!

OMG YES IT WAS THE SAME GUY I didn't know he ever had Beau! His LPs were what helped me decide to get ACNL when I was weighing other game options. (I've always been bad at decision-making lmao)

 

[Kittyinpink87]

Punchy for sure

 

[AkiBear]

Beau bcus deers are adorable.

 

[gem83]

Beau all the way! Hes such a lovable guy, its hard not to get attached to him.

Thank you! Counted c:

- - - Post Merge - - -

Beau bcus deers are adorable.

Another one for Beau!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy for sure

Counted! Thanks!

 

[Two-Face]

I have Punchy in my town, and I really like him.

 

[Ichigo.]

OMG YES IT WAS THE SAME GUY I didn't know he ever had Beau! His LPs were what helped me decide to get ACNL when I was weighing other game options. (I've always been bad at decision-making lmao)

there's no shame in that! i'm glad he helped you decide to get acnl; it's a great game! ^^ when'd you get into it? i actually watched his LP after getting the game just because i like watching people play it

 

[gem83]

there's no shame in that! i'm glad he helped you decide to get acnl; it's a great game! ^^ when'd you get into it? i actually watched his LP after getting the game just because i like watching people play it

My friend (the same one I mentioned in the OP) told me about it back in June...? I think it was June. I bought my copy in late July but deleted my town early in August. I've had my current town since then!

 

[Ichigo.]

My friend (the same one I mentioned in the OP) told me about it back in June...? I think it was June. I bought my copy in late July but deleted my town early in August. I've had my current town since then!

this year? it's nice to hear people are still getting into it even 2 years after the release i didn't get my game until march 2014, and even then it felt like people have had their towns for so long. it's really great experiencing all the town events in game!

 

[gem83]

this year? it's nice to hear people are still getting into it even 2 years after the release i didn't get my game until march 2014, and even then it felt like people have had their towns for so long. it's really great experiencing all the town events in game!

Yes, this year! Sorry, I didn't clarify that! Ikr? Everyone on here is like "Oh I've had my town for 2 years" and I'm over here thinking "Hehe... I've had mine for 3 months" I'm excited for all the events. Halloween was a lot of fun! I dressed up two of my characters.

 

[Coolio15]

I'd personally go with Punchy since I love the cats. Beau is kind of plain and boring in my opinion. Still cool, but Punchy takes the cake for me.

 

[Kristen]

Punchy! You can never get enough cats.

I have him in my cycling town and he's completely free if you'd like him.

 

[gem83]

Punchy! You can never get enough cats.

I have him in my cycling town and he's completely free if you'd like him.

Truuuue. B) Aww, thanks! That's super sweet of you! If I can get Olaf to my friend before Punchy's in boxes, I'll gladly take him!

(Oh yeah probably gonna go with Punchy and not Beau at this point, he's winning amd I realize I like him more)