• Our 2026 Easter egg hunt has concluded and the egg locations have been revealed. Congratulations to Xara, Millysaurusrexjr, and xlisapisa for winning a Golden Easter Egg! Meanwhile, TBT's Fifth Egg Decorating Contest remains open for submissions through Thursday!

Peppy Villager Question-All About Cookie

Blueskyy

You gotta know that the sky belongs to no one.
Joined
Nov 7, 2015
Posts
7,238
Bells
210
Eggs
0
Christmas Candy
Green Star Fragment
Holiday Candy Cane 2021
Daisy Easter Egg
Prismatic Easter Egg
Happy Ditto Easter Egg
Sakura Easter Egg
Pikachu Easter Egg
Yoshi Easter Egg
Ok on here I have posted I'm looking for Rosie, Bunnie, Merry, or Peanut to be my newest peppy villager. Peanut was my first choice. However, I forgot about Cookie. Cookie is in my campsite right now. I am asking you for opinoins. Should I take her? I don't look for who is popular. I just ask because I posted who I was interested in, but now I like her too. Does anyone have opinions based on in game expereinces with any of these villagers? (Cookie, Rosie, Bunnie, Merry, or Peanut).
 
Cookie is adorable! I really wanted her as my last villager. But i took in Goldie, whom i love also.
I thknk some of the fun in this series is not just getting who is on your "want" list.
 
Cookie is adorable! I really wanted her as my last villager. But i took in Goldie, whom i love also.
I thknk some of the fun in this series is not just getting who is on your "want" list.

Peanut was my most wanted next peppy. I have her reserved as well as Merry but I somehow forgot about Cookie because I saw her before in game either through campsite when I didn't need her or dream towns. I'm looking at her eyes now and am so sold on her (since she's basically Peanut in dog form and I love the mostly black eyes).
 
I say for go it then!
Ive found that listening to your heart more then your mind for this game has much more lasting happiness for villagers.
 
I say for go it then!
Ive found that listening to your heart more then your mind for this game has much more lasting happiness for villagers.

I know! I still have my game open. I guess I just want to heaf from anyone who has had Cookie, Peanut, Merry, Rosie, or Bunnie. Is Cookie a decent peppy choice? My last peppy was Chrissy. Just waiting to hear of any opinions.
 
Ive seen her in camp and dreams , and she seems to make really cute faces and dialog.
I love Roise and Merry. Rosie is like a little pop star! Merry is a little more girl next door imo.
 
Ive seen her in camp and dreams , and she seems to make really cute faces and dialog.
I love Roise and Merry. Rosie is like a little pop star! Merry is a little more girl next door imo.

Well I'd say Chrissy was more the pop star type. So was Bubbles, my default peppy which I didn't like. Cookie is nice looking, but is she all about fame? Are all peppies all about fame?
 
A little bit yes. Some more so then others i think. If you wanna see Rosie in person though, i have i her.

I've seen Rosie, Merry, Bunnie, and Peanut all in game. I love them all. They were my 4 peppy options but somehow I forgot about cookie too. Peanut or Rosie were my number 1. Knowing that, would Cookie be a good option for me?
 
Well i think by saying you forgot to add her to list , kinda means she belongs on the list? Idk i don't wanna push Cookie on you and then you're unhappy in a week or so.
 
Well i think by saying you forgot to add her to list , kinda means she belongs on the list? Idk i don't wanna push Cookie on you and then you're unhappy in a week or so.

I dunno I usually just rush into decisions when I instantly like the look of a villager. I DO like Cookie based on looks, but then again I liked Chrissy for the same reason but got bored of her. I mean I did want Peanut and Cookie looks a lot like her, but just wanting to get full opinions from the experts on this fine forum before I make an impulse decision.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Is Cookie a better peppy than Peanut or Rosie?
 
I've had Cookie before and I feel like she toes the line between peppy and normal, like she's a little less crazy than the other peps c: I did get sort of bored of her though...Bunnie is my favorite out of your initial list, but if you've narrowed it down to Cookie, Peanut or Rosie, I'd say Rosie c:
 
Cookie is my favorite dog all around and she's soooo cute. Her eyes get really expressive when she's excited and all you want to do is cheer her up when she's sad. I say go for her. :)
 
Cookie is my second favourite villager! She's so pretty and her eyes are beautiful, she's just the sweetest and she's always really friendly. If she's in your campsite this is clearly fate ^^
I highly recommend you get her you wont regret it! :3
 
Cookie is my second favourite villager! She's so pretty and her eyes are beautiful, she's just the sweetest and she's always really friendly. If she's in your campsite this is clearly fate ^^
I highly recommend you get her you wont regret it! :3

I think I'm going to just because Peanut was my first choice peppy, and I forgot about Cookie. Cookie is a lot like Peanut but in dog form.
 
Cookie is cute as a peppy but I also have Merry as my peppy she is adorable (im warning you Peppies will BREAK your heart with sadness and patheticness when their sick :()
 
Last edited:
Cookie is cute as a peppy but I also have Merry as my peppy she is adorable (im warning you Peppies will BREAK your heart with sadness and patheticness when their sick :()

Yeah I have my options open . I have Cookie in campsite and then Merry and Peanut reserved in two threads haha.
 
Last edited:
I had Cookie in my campsite as well, I prefer her as a peppy even though I don't like or have any peppies.
 
Back
Top