If I was you... I probably wouldn't give up. I'd like rip the deck apart, hahaha. I don't like getting new things.
Off topic, but I recently had to get a new pokemon pearl, even though i'd much rather have tried to find my old one but I couldn't find it absolutely anywhere. The same with the sims, I hate having to get a new one because it's on my computer but it no longer works. It's just there taunting me.
Anyway on topic, i'm sorry about your game. I too am a butterfingers and I tend to drop everything and anything, I get quite annoyed at myself too. Sometimes even angry, because i'm that clumsy and I wish I hadn't been so careless. Like others have said personally i'd probably rip the decking off by force like the incredible hulk or something, since most of the time im broke and I know the game must be there somewhere so I can't just give up on it. If it's still there somewhere I don't see why I should want to buy a new one tbh. I say if your game is really important to you, it's worth looking for and if you're like me and hate buying things that are still around but just stuck somewhere i'd try to get it.