I’ve only gotten Audie and I’ve kept her. I’m even thinking of rehunting for her on my new island (she’s the only peppy that fits my intended theme from what I remember).
I had Reneigh and let her go. She is a nice uchi but I can't stand the zoomies and she didn't play the stick game with the other villagers in the plaza that much.
I have Raymond and I'm keeping him. He popped out of the void ungifted which was shocking.
I currently have Raymond, Dom, and Judy on my island. Dom and Judy I hunted for on mystery islands (collectively used around 160+ nook mile tickets to find both!) and Raymond I was lucky enough to find on my campsite when I wasn’t even actively looking for him. For now and for the foreseeable future I think I’ll be keeping them!
I currently have Raymond and Sherb and I'm in the process of getting Dom today. I think Raymond will stay for a bit more but not forever. I'm undecided about Sherb. I'm intending Dom to be permanent!
The only new villagers I'm actively looking for are Dom and Judy. Raymond was a total surprise on a mystery island, as was Sherb. I grabbed them because I figured if I didn't jive with them that I could help someone else out with them eventually!
I had Audie but let her go, kind of miss her honestly...
I actually have Cyd and Raymond on my island, Cyd is never leaving, I adore him. Raymond I don't know : I grew attached to him but I think he will leave one day.
I met Judy and Dom on mystery islands but didn't invite them.
I have Audie,Raymond,Sherb,Dom,Reneigh,Cyd and Judy and I'm keeping all of 'em.I've been lucky in that I didn't have to pay for any of them and they're all good villagers that I would keep whether they're new or not.