Need new smug: Shep or Colton?

[Dorian]

They are BOTH so great!!! I am trying to be more open-minded and try out new villagers. Both these guys seem pretty great. Any thoughts?

 

[Melchoir]

Shep because his design is cooler than Colton's. Colton is pretty plain, whereas Shep looks like he has personality.

 

[gem83]

I'm biased toward Colton because he lived in my town for a while. He was my first camper ever. But Shep is okay too. I think his design makes him look kinda...Idk...trashy? I guess? But to each their own.

 

[Dorian]

Both really varied opinions and I like them both for those reasons: I love Colton's kind of princely demeanor and Shep's southern laid-back charm.Like he would call you 'sugar' Okay, I think I just made up my mind. Shep

 

[roseflower]

Get Shep, he`s awesome, I like his interior theme, and the song he`s playing in his house is K.K. Reggae! What?s not to love

 

[Nunnafinga]

I like Shep but Colton is my favorite smug.I didn't even like the horse villagers until he moved to my town.

 

[Blue-Ninja]

I've never had either.. Colton looks more like the princely type for some reason. x'D
Shep strikes me as a lazy type more than smug. Hehe. I think I prefer Shep though.

 

[KoalaKitty]

I'd say Shep, but that's only because he amuses me in HHD and because I have an intense dislike for Colton, who decided to plot on top of my perfect orange tree before it had even fully grown. He's right next to my house, I want him out XD

 

[hulaburger]

shep. he looks like a stoner to me. in a cute way.

 

[HHoney]

Shep all the way dude!!!

 

[santoyo.bay]

Shep! He's awesome!

 

[Chere.]

I personally prefer Colton, he's a cutie. She's is also cool though haha xD

 

[kawaii_princess]

Colton is cute! He's got the total boy band look haha. Shep is ok, but I guess design-wise, I'd prefer Colton.

 

[Dorian]

Went for Shep! Moved him in and he is WONDERFUL!

 

[RainCrossing]

i love both ahhh. it depends, colton is great for a girly themed town, but shep is good for other themed towns like forest, japanese

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

I don't like either of them very much, but I think Shep is better. Colton looks weird with that blond hair. LOL