Mafia Murder Mystery Mafia-Mafia Win

Dolby, is there something else other than the Panda that makes me a suspect to you? As Seroja done the same and you don't have her listed as a suspect?

I guess I'll explain the whole Panda voting fiasco anyway. Basically I wasn't risking lynching the doc, no way, I just wasn't, not again. There was little information to pin-point anyone at that point, but obviously I felt like I had to vote someone. At that time, on Discord, Panda was being lightly questioned but yet, was coming across angry and defensive, I don't know, but it just set off red flags for me (I'll go back and try to find the messages). Anyway, after seeing how Panda was acting on Discord, I had to vote for her. Before I went on the thread I didn't know Mog and Seroja had also voted her, when I seen that they had (they clearly read what she was saying on Discord and also thought it was weird also) I felt better, knowing that I wasn't the only one that'd read what Panda was saying as scummy, or weird at the least.

so apparently 4 people knew she was vig. god knows how many more knew as well. she chooses to confide in panda of all ppl. who i bet, convinced her to shoot kirby instead of scumbuddy chrys. it's telling, that despite panda and chrys being at each other's throats, panda puts her vote on me. because i was one of 4+ ppl who knew mog's role.

Did Mog tell you who she told? As far as I know, it wasn't 4+ people, it was three. You, Panda, and I. I know it's hypocritical of me to say as I knew also, but I know that it wasn't me, last night's events puts the two of you high in my suspect list. I do agree that Panda's actions are so off for so many reasons, including the chrys thing. Also, how did she imply she was going to kill you? (I don't think Tom knew she was vig, I think that maybe just came from the fact he mentioned lynching chrys on Discord, (unless he did know, but, uh))
 
Did Mog tell you who she told? As far as I know, it wasn't 4+ people, it was three. You, Panda, and I. I know it's hypocritical of me to say as I knew also, but I know that it wasn't me, last night's events puts the two of you high in my suspect list. I do agree that Panda's actions are so off for so many reasons, including the chrys thing. Also, how did she imply she was going to kill you? (I don't think Tom knew she was vig, I think that maybe just came from the fact he mentioned lynching chrys on Discord, (unless he did know, but, uh))

so when i woke up this morning, she had deleted everything on her side of our private discord chat. im hoping it was because she wanted to remove anything that i could read back on, rather than because shes angry at me. she gave me the impression last night that she was discussing who to shoot with tom. however, it's also possible she was talking about tom publicly discussing it in the discord mafia chat. i didnt know that she told u and panda but i assumed she would tell someone because she definitely didnt trust me. i was fine with that because i was certain she would shoot chrys or hold her shot (that was my advice to her) and her shooting chrys would exonerate me. instead, you, panda or someone else convinced her to shoot kirby and now that makes me look very bad.

i still dont know why she roleclaimed vig to me in the first place tbh, maybe it was to cause this exact situation to occur and bait me out, except she trusted the wrong people with her "will"
 
so when i woke up this morning, she had deleted everything on her side of our private discord chat. im hoping it was because she wanted to remove anything that i could read back on, rather than because shes angry at me. she gave me the impression last night that she was discussing who to shoot with tom. however, it's also possible she was talking about tom publicly discussing it in the discord mafia chat. i didnt know that she told u and panda but i assumed she would tell someone because she definitely didnt trust me. i was fine with that because i was certain she would shoot chrys or hold her shot (that was my advice to her) and her shooting chrys would exonerate me. instead, you, panda or someone else convinced her to shoot kirby and now that makes me look very bad.

i still dont know why she roleclaimed vig to me in the first place tbh, maybe it was to cause this exact situation to occur and bait me out, except she trusted the wrong people with her "will"

So Mog deleted her messages after she was killed? I don't understand why she'd do that, remove everything she said just so you couldn't read back on it, she's not in the game anymore, so why would you reading back on her matter to her all all? Being angry makes more sense to me, being angry that she trusted you, and look where that got her?

Did Mog actually say to you that she was going to shoot Chrys, or were you just 'advising' her to do so? I mean, when she was speaking to me, she was never set on killing Chrys, not at all. She was always (based on what she said to me) leaning towards Kirby, based on things he'd said to her and his messed up, confusing, jester claim. I can't speak on behalf of Panda or anyone else (as I don't know what they said) but I for one didn't convince her to shoot Kirby. She said she was going to, and I said that's what I would have done if I were vig (as I also would have shot him then, I mean, what was that all about, purposefully messing with town?).

Are you saying that Mog done all this on purpose, just to make you look bad? Honestly I don't get that, I think she genuinely trusted you, if you look bad, that's not Mog's doing.
 
Yes, she must think I'm mafia for sure and is removing everything in case she gave away information that hurts town. Or she's angry with me.
No she never said she would shoot chrys. I advised her that chrys is the best shot cuz they're an almost guaranteed lynch today, so why not kill her at give us something else to discuss on day 2. She wasn't convinced so I told her holding the shot is fine too since its only night 1.

I don't for one moment believe she intentionally tried to make me look bad. Even if she did suspect me, shooting someone innocent to make me look bad is an awful play. I think she was played by someone whom she also confided in, who saw the opportunity to have her shoot an innocent and pin it on me. I think that person is panda.
 
After Mog being killed last night, I believe that there's scum between Panda and Karla, I'm adamant that there is. and I'm definitely leaning towards Panda. I'm pretty set on voting Panda today, but I'll lay off and wait until a little later before deciding. There's likely 3 mafia and 1(or two?) third party? we need to work hard today, we can't really risk lynching town again.

*Panda* - I want to start off by mentioning this:
Panda offered herself as a lynch to save Crys, which I don't think that scum would do.
The way Panda brought up the whole "I would have died for crys!" thing (on more than one occasion, may I add) when she was being questioned seems very weird to me, it just seems like she wants people to think exactly what Dolby thinks. I mean, people were already being suspicious of her a little, she had to do something to advert the negative attention, and make her undoubtedly town, and "sacrificing" herself for crys is the best way to do that. I'd been thinking it, but Liam pointed out the fact that Panda said what she said to crys before she'd had many votes, so even if crys had changed her vote to Panda, she knew she'd be safe.

**There's something else about this whole thing that's off to me, Panda said this on Discord last night:
"Panda - Today at 3:06 AM
She had two and I had two so I told her to change"

However, after going back and looking at the votes, Panda and crys never each had two votes at one time? Just before Mog, Seroja and I voted Panda the votes were as follows; Crys-5, Panda-2, so Panda, when exactly did you tell/ask crys to change her vote, and when were you two each on two votes? I mean, I may have miscounted, but i doubt it. Panda knew that telling crys to vote her wouldn't make and difference to the lynch at all, all she knew it would do is make her look good, which it does, clearly, based on the fact Dolby thinks that makes Panda town.

I'd like to ask you something again, Panda. I mentioned this to you in the Discord, but your answer made no sense at all. If you were so willing to die to save crys, then why did you get so angry/defensive when you thought you were going to be lynched at the end? I'd like to bring this up again and ask for further explanation, I don't by the whole "being lynched over chrys" thing, chrys wasn't really in it at this point, it was you and crys. If you were town willing to save the doc, why on earth were you so angry? surely that's what you wanted? (personally I don't think it was, you wanted to look good/town but stay safe, that's all). Just saying I don't buy it, any of it, at all.

I've only properly addressed the crys lynch thing, but that's not it all, I mean, just what on earth is going on between Panda and Chrys? and telling Liam to basically keep his mouth shut instead of answering his questions? Honestly what on earth. It's weird. I'll just leave it here for the time being though.

Karla - The main reason why Karla is so high on my list is the Mog thing. Like I said, either Karla or Panda is scum. Right now my main suspicions lie with Panda, but I'm still not letting go of the fact that there is a chance I might be being suspicious of the wrong one of the two. Likely the only reason I'd be any less sus of Karla is if Panda is lynched and flips red. I doubt they're both scum, I think there's one between them. The last few posts on the thread (by Karla) lead me to believe that he's telling the truth and is innocent, but maybe that's what he wants, to fool me or to make me trust him? I don't know, I agree with what he's said regarding Panda, but at the same time, it's really 50/50 between him and Panda, and I don't want to be making a mistake.

Chrystina - What Dolby posted about Chrys basically sums up my suspicions of her. I need to read over everything and make a big read here, that'll likely come later in the day.

Tom - I'm still not completely sure that I buy his claim, but I'm going to say I do for the most part. Anyway, he said he's more than willing to turn to scum if they had approached him, so basically he could turn to mafia and work for them at any point.
"TrentTom - Today at 2:15 AM
Mafia doesn't trust me enough to reach out directly so I'm sidin with town until I get that pretty letter"
I guess he's pretty easy to ignore (I'm not trusting him anyway, who knows when scum has reached out to him?) but slightly dangerous alive at the same time. Then again, thinking of it, what he's doing really is taking the spotlight away from him, which is what mafia would want. He's said he's working in the best interest of town, and I just don't see it or buy it, nope. However, at the same time, I don't really see him as a massive threat to town at the moment.

Dolby - Again, I don't really feel like I have massive reason or information to be suspicious, but I am still a little suspicious regardless. Dolby has been really rather quiet, both on the form and Discord (only really appearing when saod quietness is mentioned), just enough to advert suspicion and and the same time not enough to draw attention to themselves. Also, is there a reason you didn't vote D1?

Cory / Byngo / Ness - Null on these three, there isn't enough information on them to sway me either way and I haven't been able to form a strong opinion on any of them yet.

Seroja - Town, she hasn't said anything to make me think otherwise, a little null as there isn't that much information to sway me one way or the other, but definitely town for the most part.

Liam - I do find a few things odd, not going to bring up the PM thing at the start again, because that's been addressed and forgotten about. Liam does seem to be playing very differently to how he was in the last game where we played together (where i was paying a lot of attention to him) i'm sure he said somewhere (Discord?) that he's just trying to change his meta, and I buy that since he wasn't really taken lightly in the last game. I like how he's being so bold about the Panda thing, and I agree completely.
 
Maybe mog wasn't even shot because of her being vig?
Is it possible?
Also did anyone pm with toads?
Who was he sus of?
 
Maybe mog wasn't even shot because of her being vig?
Is it possible?
Also did anyone pm with toads?
Who was he sus of?

I guess it is possible, but I don't see any benefits of thinking that way. It's way more likely that she was killed because she was vig, and I don't think we should let that go.
 
Also if panda wanted to sacrafice herself for crys, wouldn't she have voted for herself?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Will have explainations when I get home but for now
Least to most:
Fleshy
Byngo
Sejora
Liam
Ness
Dolby
Tom
Karla
Chrystina
Panda

- - - Post Merge - - -

The first half I trust way more than second half
So I trust ness a lot more than I trust Dolby
 
fleshy makes some great points. when exactly did panda claim that she was willing to die instead of improper? cuz saying it after the lynch is totally meaningless. even if she said it before the lynch, it shouldnt be taken as a sign of innocence. she can easily coordinate with her scum teammates to keep enough votes on improper to ensure they still get lynched (for example, chrystina).

i am certain that one of chrystina and panda are scum, and strongly believe that they both are and are putting on a show for us. between them and on the balance of all the evidence, i think chrystina has a slightly higher chance of being mafia so i still want to see her lynched today. if mafia does have 3 members, then a successful lynch should drop their KP to 1 which will give us a lot more breathing room so we should vote based on that. conversely, lynching panda should clear me and i certainly won't say no to that. if anyone has arguments for why panda is scummier than chrys, then they should put them forward
 
fleshy makes some great points. when exactly did panda claim that she was willing to die instead of improper? cuz saying it after the lynch is totally meaningless. even if she said it before the lynch, it shouldnt be taken as a sign of innocence. she can easily coordinate with her scum teammates to keep enough votes on improper to ensure they still get lynched (for example, chrystina).

i am certain that one of chrystina and panda are scum, and strongly believe that they both are and are putting on a show for us. between them and on the balance of all the evidence, i think chrystina has a slightly higher chance of being mafia so i still want to see her lynched today. if mafia does have 3 members, then a successful lynch should drop their KP to 1 which will give us a lot more breathing room so we should vote based on that. conversely, lynching panda should clear me and i certainly won't say no to that. if anyone has arguments for why panda is scummier than chrys, then they should put them forward

She said she was willing to die for her about 5ish minutes after she flipped doc
 
^Yeah, in Discord, I'll post all the times she mentioned that, which just so happen to usually be the times she was being questioned (times are in gmt)
Panda - Yesterday at 2:58 AM (when Seroja was questioning her scummy actions)
"i wish i would have got lynched instead of Crys
seriously i told Crys so vote for me so she wouldnt die...."


Panda - Yesterday at 2:59 AM (quoting a conversation between her and crys)
Crys - Today at 3:00 PM
"im dead
dont trust chrys ty"
Panda - Today at 3:00 PM
"What's going on ?
If you need to you can vote for me so that you don't die???"


Panda - Yesterday at 3:00 AM
"if i was mafia would i tell her to vote for me so i die in her place ?"

Panda - Today at 2:48 AM (when Liam mentioned said he thought she was unhelpful)
"no ?
i didnt do one useful thing like try to save doctor"

Panda - Today at 3:03 AM
"Liam I don't know where you been but I literally was gonna die for the Doctor I told her to vote me to sway the votes but for some reason she didn't"


Chrys defending (or whatever you'd call it) Panda in discord, I think this is also relevant and can be further reason to believe they could be scum buddies, the whole thing between those two is flip-floppy and confusing;
Chrystina - Yesterday at 3:36 AM
"whoever the vig is dont shoot panda
like brought up before, terrible idea"


Chrystina - Yesterday at 3:37 AM
"someone who is willing to be lynched is a waste of a vig shot. i.e panda is probs town"

Chrystina - Yesterday at 3:41 AM
"i mean panda and I have been mafia team before and she bussed the hell out of me but liam reeally, if we both were mafia, we wouldnt be bussing each other THIS hard"
 
Chrystina - Yesterday at 3:41 AM
"i mean panda and I have been mafia team before and she bussed the hell out of me but liam reeally, if we both were mafia, we wouldnt be bussing each other THIS hard"
i mean isnt panda bussing the hell out of chrys this game??
 
Mog didn't share her roles with me, so I'm assuming that she was referring to my thoughts on who the vig should shoot based off the public Discord conversation and the thread.
 
oh lord

//snip//
Toadsworthy's death is the one that makes the least amount of sense to me, when these are their only posts of substance, and he hammered Crys


My list
Ness
Panda

Seroja
Cory
Liam

Byngo
Fleshy
Tom
Karla
Chrys


Chrys and Karlaare around even in suspicion to me. Chrys continuously grasps at straws, while Karla has the smoking gun of Mogyay telling him her role. Both I feel reasonably certain are mafia (before Panda revealed Karla had Mogyay's role, I had him as null). Strictly speaking it's possible that Mogyay's death was a coincidence(though a good mafia player doesn't believe in coincidence's

Now where is Chrys grasping at straws? Well here she accuses me and Ness of being scum, because I mentioned that we share a quicktopic
Chrystina - Today at 12:37 PM
because she thought day was over.
if she thought day was over, might as well claim what shes about to flip as? in mere minutes?
i thought she ****ed up tbh
but go ahead and grasp for straws @Ness
Wait wtf
[2:27 PM] Dolby: Oh yeah, I shared that with you in our qt. The mental gymnastics comment was from me
@Dolby @Ness you guys have a qt?
did you just slip....

Dolby - Today at 12:40 PM
Yes
We have a qt rather
mogyay - Today at 12:41 PM
why lol
Chrystina - Today at 12:41 PM
only reason you need a qt is if youre mafia..
theres another possibility but
Dolby - Today at 12:41 PM
Because he kept leaving discord
Chrystina - Today at 12:41 PM
PM through forums?
Dolby - Today at 12:41 PM
Chrys
https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/trr6ysjDkHZyv
Chrystina - Today at 12:42 PM
ah, okay. ty
Ness - Today at 12:42 PM
If you really want to see it
oh well he beat me
mogyay - Today at 12:43 PM
thatd be so much effort if u were both mafia lol
Chrystina - Today at 12:43 PM
yeah theyre in the clear. but i was already town lean on them both anyways
before I thought they slipped that is lol.


And then proceeds to tell us that we're town leans to her, immediently after assuming that we're scum because I mentioned a shared quicktopic. I find this flip-flopping behavior indicative of her being mafia.
How is this at all grasping for straws? You and ness were discussing how I "twisted" Crys's words, (this I would call grasping for straws), but what you bolded - no. I stand by what I said. I was always trusting of you and ness both, but just because I trust you both in the beginning of the game - doesn't mean I'm gonna read "oh ya we discussed this in our qt ness" and let it go. Lmao. Remember, this is my first PM game - and I didn't know QT's were used that commonly for "PMing". So you're calling me out for questioning something I saw as a slip? It's not like I was the only one who saw it as a slip, & it's not like I tried to keep going with it after you linked me the qt, I dropped the whole matter.

As for the flip flopping thing, aren't you doing that with this very case? You said day 1 I was a town lean for you, and now I'm a scum read, with little to go off of.

As for here post reacting to the death's, what stood out to me was her insistence that Panda was behind Toad's death

The purpose of the first half of this post is mainly to generate sympathy for Chrys. The second half, and particullarly the bold, attempt to paint Toads death as a conspiracy to lynch her, which is 1. Just plain dumb. 2. If Karla knowing Mog's role hadn't been revealed, your lynch probably would happen despite Toad. 3. Goes against Occam's razor. 4. You have presented yourself throughout post of the game as being suspicious of Panda, why were you even sharing PMs with here. 5. It's taken a full phase for you to even explain your sus on Panda

//snip//
generate sympathy? no.... I was annoyed. Coming back to people DMing me and accusing me of "not wanting to post" is gonna annoy me, yeah. Do I want sympathy, was I trying to get any? hell no. It was a way to let everyone know I was back and I'd respond eventually instead of getting more prodding while doing so.

1. okay
2. okay
3. explain?
4. I literally put "i was an idiot" in caps. thats why.
5. It's taken a whole phase and more for people to even present a case on other people ??? I was gone most of yesterday, and it was during night, why/HOW would I make a case then?

at this point I'm leaning heavily towards chrys but I'll wait to see her defense
bless. you. for waiting.

//snip//

Cory / Byngo / Ness - Null on these three, there isn't enough information on them to sway me either way and I haven't been able to form a strong opinion on any of them yet.

Seroja - Town, she hasn't said anything to make me think otherwise, a little null as there isn't that much information to sway me one way or the other, but definitely town for the most part.

//snip//
I read your case on me, but I think I addressed all of it already in reply to Dolby, but what struck me as odd was your reads on Cory, Byngo, and Ness and then Seroja. The explanation for them all is basically the same, but you're a little more town lean on Seroja .. ?



Anyways, which brings me to Seroja. I know she's been in the discord chat here and there, but... in the thread? she's a ghost.

Generally, most mafia don't try to make themselves so noticeable, but not lurking too much where it becomes obvious, and this mostly happens day 1. Going back and reading day 1, the two people that fit this perfectly were Karla and Seroja. Not letting my suspicions of Panda go, I'm just putting it out there that we're missing something, and this is most likely it.
 
I read your case on me, but I think I addressed all of it already in reply to Dolby, but what struck me as odd was your reads on Cory, Byngo, and Ness and then Seroja. The explanation for them all is basically the same, but you're a little more town lean on Seroja .. ?

I have played with Seroja in a previous game, I haven't with the others. Plus I tend to agree with what she's been saying on Discord more, but Ness seems a little more "stand-offish" (maybe that's not the best way to word it, I'm not sure) on Discord, and I just wasn't sure at all about Cory and Byngo. I'm not completely townreading her or anything at the moment. I see where you're coming from with your reads on Seroja though.
 
If anyone had pmed toadsworthy please release these convos.
 
If anyone had pmed toadsworthy please release these convos.

he pmed me this about halfway? through day 1. (already brought this up but never pasted it) so
Murder Mystery Mafia
With what i just said about you in the game, I honestly don't think you're mafia.... but people who start to go along with what I say are the ones I will be more suspect of because they are trying to bandwagon against you.

You are too smart of a player to go that hard on people this early in the game. You wouldn't have done that if you actually were mafia.

don't let me down on this....

- - - Post Merge - - -

welp I actually might've pasted this already.
disregard me wow.


tbh toads didn't seem that very trustworthy of anyone soooo I don't see him as one to pm with anyone like back and forth about the game. of cours could be completely wrong but I wouldn't be surprised.
 
RIP panda's defense

- - - Post Merge - - -

oops just saw her message on the discord
my bad
 
Back
Top