Marshal vs. Julian for a smug villager (or other suggestions)

[Kittyinpink87]

I think Julian looks kind of creepy. For Smugs i prefer Rodney or Marshall.

 

[Blueskyy]

Thanks I chose to keep Marshal because he pinged today to tell me about how much of a friend he considers me. I love him now.

 

[RainCrossing]

Marshal is not too cute but he is overused. So I will vote for Julian (●?ω｀●).
There could be better though: Colton, Lopez and Zell.
If I had to choose one, I'll chose Colton!

 

[TamaMushroom]

I personally don't like either of them. I like Marshal slightly more than Julian, but I really like O'Hare, Henry, Graham, Hans, and Ken. I like the themes and appearance of the characters better. It's just a personal preference

 

[PastelPrincess]

I prefer Julian over Marshal (yes I've had both). Even within personality types the NPC's are a little bit different. Marshal has always been more timid while Julian is very outgoing. Be warned however because Julian will try to date snooty's and normal's and will admit to crushes all the time. Julian just the other day was talking his heart out to Whitney (they were in a conversation for 20 minutes) and then pinged me asking if I could deliver a present to Whitney. WHY MUST HE DO THIS IS HE NOT SATISFIED WITH COLTON

 

[Blueskyy]

I prefer Julian over Marshal (yes I've had both). Even within personality types the NPC's are a little bit different. Marshal has always been more timid while Julian is very outgoing. Be warned however because Julian will try to date snooty's and normal's and will admit to crushes all the time. Julian just the other day was talking his heart out to Whitney (they were in a conversation for 20 minutes) and then pinged me asking if I could deliver a present to Whitney. WHY MUST HE DO THIS IS HE NOT SATISFIED WITH COLTON

Thank you for this post. I wanted Julian with the hopes that he'd be a LGBT little unicorn. I dunno why lol. Marshal doesn't talk about crushes and has a bromance with me so I'm keeping him. Thanks!