Lucky or Sherb

[Santana]

Im ready to let Tucker go, unfortunately I am not set on which lazy I want to replace him. My favorite lazy is Sherb, he’s a cutie and goes well with my town theme. However, It gets complicated with Lucky, who I adore, tho not as much as Sherb. The catch is, I have Ankha living in my island, and Lucky would compliment her PERFECTLY. So yea, feel free to give advice. Thanks!

 

[Bk1234]

Go with Sherb. I don't think you should just go with a villager because they fit with another villager. Plus, if you don't end up liking Sherb, you could probably trade him for Lucky.

 

[Dewasa]

I went with Sherb as my lazy simply because I found him on an island and fell in love with the baby blue fur.

 

[absol]

Sherb
I wouldn't choose a villager just based on whom he fits well. Definitely go with Sherb if you adore him and he fits your theme!
Lucky is my absolute favorite though so it's always great to see him in towns.

 

[Bk1234]

How are you acquiring Lucky/Sherb?

 

[Santana]

How are you acquiring Lucky/Sherb?

I plan on doing the campsite method for the first time

 

[shayminskyforme88]

Personally I’d go with Sherb since I got creeped out by Lucky back in Wild World. Saw how his house looks in this game and didn’t help with my impression. Aside from that, you seem to really like him and he does go with your town’s theme.

 

[Luella]

Every time I pass by Sherb I fondly call him, "Sherb-a-derp". <3

Gonna go with Sherb obv.

 

[Iris_T]

I have both and I adore them, but if you have to choose maybe get Sherb since Lucky no longer have egyptian decoration inside his home so it won't fit Ankha as much as in New Leaf.

 

[Blueskyy]

Sherb no question. I really just don’t like Lucky.

 

[Bk1234]

I plan on doing the campsite method for the first time

Well then I would just go with whoever you find first. Good luck!

 

[Rosewater]

Since you're more drawn to Sherb, I'll say go with him.