Honestly though the only villager I don't like is Benedict. I don't particularly hate Bunnie or Roald, and I don't even really hate Benedict. I just like them the least out of all my villagers.
I don't hate any of my babies, but there are some I like least!
(Most loved to eh) Julian, Beau, Lobo, Freya, Bam, Fuchsia, Renee, Flora, Goldie, Maple
1. Jacques (best friend)
2. Ribbot
3. Robin
4. Elvis
5. Ruby
6. Derwin
7. Hopper
8. Nan
Last 3 are the ones I dont like because I dont have 10 yet. Cant say why exactly I dont like Nan or Hopper other than they are boring and the character designs are awful imho.
1. Tammy
2. Gabi
3. Nana
4. Amelia
5. Grizzly
6. Phil
7. Penelope
8. Pecan
9. Peggy
10. Hamlet
I've always considered Nana and Amelia my favorites (they've been in my town since the beginning), but right now I find myself more interested in talking to Tammy (my only uchi) and Gabi (newcomer whose appearance I really like).
I actually really like all of mine but here is my order:
1. Rosie
2. Tom
3. Margie
4. Tangy
5. Whitney
6. Lobo
7. Rudy
8. Phoebe
9. Filbert
10. O'Hare
This order is purely based on my current new leaf town and who i am most attached to based on my experiences in new leaf. If I was to rate them in order of how much I like them outside the game or on other games the list would be quite different.
Actually my favourite villagers of all time are tangy, Rosie and Whitney and Rosie has only joined the list since new leaf.