Ankha, I had her in my village and I really didn't care for her. I was surprised she's a tier 1, but I guess her character design is pretty unique and cool. I prefer cutsie characters.
For me it would have to be ankha. I thought her design was pretty nice but when I got her I didn'd really connect with her as I did with other villagers.
Julian. I never liked his design much. Not to mention that he's a horse...none of the horse villagers are cute, so he's just not what I like by default. I also find it hard to understand why Lolly is so high up on Tier 1. As a person whose favorite animal is the cat, I find her a bit boring. Cute, but boring. Chief too. He's not my favorite of the wolves.