Mafia June 2020 Mafia Game Thread [DAY 2 ENDS AT 6/20 5PM PST]

[toadsworthy]

@Aerious role claiming is never a good idea until late game... role claiming early gets us nothing because mafia will just claim townie and outs the power roles.... so no one is role claiming anything

even saying yourself is a townie can narrow down the pool for mafia, so i wouldn't even bring up role-claiming

 

[Ace Marvel]

Ignoring game making board pupupupu @ please if you need something from me.

 

[Damniel]

Sorry folks I'm very distracted with my MU champs results (i got 2nd place for those curious). Need to look into the convo more when I can but 2 things:

did rqs get posted yet

No, why don't you post one yourself if you really want one? You say you wanna solve, do you have any insight on what's been going on? MU doesn't usually do a RQS so im interested on to why you're reliant on it rn

It’s kind a fun to see yall argue bout the amount of mafia

What do you think is fun about it? What do you think the setup can be?

Personally I think it's 4 if it's 1 KP. The goon isn't listed but all power maf doesn't sound right

 

[toadsworthy]

typically protective roles have a limit and can't protect same for consecutive nights and mafia may have a roleblocker

Post automatically merged: Jun 15, 2020

@shawo thoughts on the game outside set up and why you voted for Ace Marvel

 

[Damniel]

wait my bad goon is listed. I think 2 goons makes sense

 

[g u a v a]

lol teddy has hardly posted and already has a vote against him. (low key protecting teddy/ace at all costs only for his photoshop contributions)

question for the room: would maf really do something so bold so early on?

 

[Damniel]

lol teddy has hardly posted and already has a vote against him. (low key protecting teddy/ace at all costs only for his photoshop contributions)

question for the room: would maf really do something so bold so early on?

shawo as maf was very bold and claimed blue D1 so I wouldn't put it pass him

 

[Ace Marvel]

@shawo you barked at the wrong tree pupupupupuu. lol

question for the room: would maf really do something so bold so early on?

I think not.

 

[Aerious]

@Aerious role claiming is never a good idea until late game... role claiming early gets us nothing because mafia will just claim townie and outs the power roles.... so no one is role claiming anything

even saying yourself is a townie can narrow down the pool for mafia, so i wouldn't even bring up role-claiming

that makes a lot of sense, thanks so much for the clarification.

which leads me to my next point, and why i'm asking about when to rc:

someone do rqs or something i wanna solve

what are you trying to solve? asking someone to potentially sacrifice themselves doesn't align with what people are warning against. pls don't think i'm being accusatory, but i'm curious now.

 

[g u a v a]

part of me thought it was their way of making sure their vote got in because of timezones but... days are 48 hrs so like.. why the rush bby?

 

[shawo]

I work

also I already apologized for my vote what else do u want from me.

I will do exactly what I want and you can decide whether or not that is sus.

 

[epona]

I don't think it is redundant, and I don't think I made a false assumption at all actually. I find it odd you're deflecting on something that you claim is redundant (why care at all, then?), when all I asked was what made you think there was 4 mafia specifically.

How am I suddenly "worse" when I'm trying to question what made you think 4 mafia as opposed to there only being 3 roles in the semi-open setup? If your assumption is rational, how is mind not?

It's not a case in that I could see the value in hypothetical scum!Epona purposefully revealing there is 4 mafia, but it just seemed a bit jarring to state so confidently there's 4 mafia, I was under the assumption that it was a 3 man team with 2 KP, but I concede that since it's only 1 KP for whatever reason it makes more sense that there would be 4.

how did you not make a false assumption? you literally said you assumed it was 2 KP, which is factually false bc we were directly told otherwise in the OP. i'm saying you look worse bc you clearly didn't pay attention to the OP, so your assumption was baseless, whereas my assumption of a 4-man scumteam was directly related to the information we were given in the OP.

fmpov this conversation is redundant bc i'm townreading you for all of this anyway so i don't see the point in this back and forth if we're town/town

 

[shawo]

I guess to clarify, I shouldn't be playing forum mafia at work, but I saw you guys talking about mechanics so I came in, said my two pieces, and came back.

I opened it and now I feel obligated to reply. I won't be able 2 participate so if you think that's sus that's that.

 

[g u a v a]

I work

also I already apologized for my vote what else do u want from me.

I will do exactly what I want and you can decide whether or not that is sus.

nobody's saying you can't do that, but if you're town it'd make sense to try to work together and maybe give us your insight.

 

[radical6]

Actually, sorry everyone, I know its only been 2 hours but after discussing with Geoni I've decided its best to resume with the KP formula for this game.

Kills = mafia remaining/2 rounded up.

 

[shawo]

4 mafia final answer.

 

[N e s s]

Actually, sorry everyone, I know its only been 2 hours but after discussing with Geoni I've decided its best to resume with the KP formula for this game.

Kills = mafia remaining/2 rounded up.

pog

 

[Damniel]

Actually, sorry everyone, I know its only been 2 hours but after discussing with Geoni I've decided its best to resume with the KP formula for this game.

Kills = mafia remaining/2 rounded up.

oh it's 3 maf then

 

[epona]

that makes a lot of sense, thanks so much for the clarification.

which leads me to my next point, and why i'm asking about when to rc:

what are you trying to solve? asking someone to potentially sacrifice themselves doesn't align with what people are warning against. pls don't think i'm being accusatory, but i'm curious now.

rqs = random question stage not roleqlaiming

Actually, sorry everyone, I know its only been 2 hours but after discussing with Geoni I've decided its best to resume with the KP formula for this game.

Kills = mafia remaining/2 rounded up.

ok then

 

[Aerious]

rqs = random question stage not roleqlaiming

***** i am so dumb LMAOOOOOOOOO. i've been curious about that for the longest, pls someone link me to a mafia dictionary