Julian or Octavian

[Ami Mercury]

While resetting to get Merengue into a good spot, I have gotten these guys 5 times each in the campsite, and will eventually switch out Cherry for one of them. Who should I add to Anur Transyl?

My other choices for the town are Stitches, Tucker, Lionel, Shari, Nana, Merengue, Amelia, Rocco, and Snake.

I might not necessarily go with the winner. Please leave a comment as to why I should that one over the other.

 

[Coolio15]

Octavian is in my second town and he is da bomb! I luv him so much! Julian is vile and stupid. Plus unicorns suck kthxbai XP

 

[FireNinja1]

Octavian. Julian is just a unicorn. So what?

 

[Ami Mercury]

Julian is vile and stupid. Plus unicorns suck kthxbai XP

Unicorns are awesome. (Especially ones name "The Great and Powerful Trixie!!!!") Not as good as pegasi, but I still LOVE unicorns. It is one reason I am considering him. I LOVE MLP:FiM!

 

[Capella]

I don't like Julian but I really hate Octavian

 

[PopteenPrincess]

julian's the best
like he's so freaking wild and free how could you not love him
his little horn looks like its glowing and all too
octavian scares me to be honest. i dont find anything redeeming or better about him compared to all the other crankies they have in game.

 

[charyse]

I'd take Octavian I think he's cool the only reason I'd ever take Julian is because he sells for a lot he's not interesting to me

 

[Shirohibiki]

julian is hot unicorn boyfriendo
i dont like octavian in the least urghh marina is the only octowaifu
but julian is rly gr8 i just dont like the fact that his eyes dont open...? but otherwise hes really rad

 

[Emily]

who doesnt love a blue unicorn!?!?!?! ❤❤
i think julian is one of the best new characters introduced in new leaf as he is creative and cool and cute and glitter loving ❤❤❤

 

[nammie]

Who else is in your town? I love Octavian but Julian might be a better fit depending on who you have

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Octavian because I hate Julian and unicorns.
Plus Octavian's really cool.

 

[Ami Mercury]

Who else is in your town? I love Octavian but Julian might be a better fit depending on who you have

As I stated in the first post, my planned villagers for Anur Transyl are; Stitches, Tucker, Lionel, Shari, Nana, Merengue, Amelia, Rocco, and Snake.

 

[nammie]

oh oop I thought by other choices you meant other people you might want instead of octavian and julian or something lol my bad
but you have a lot of variety so I'll just vote for Octavian because I love his cranky eyebrows and the bandage on the back of his head!!!

 

[Mini Mario]

Octavian is in my second town and he is da bomb! I luv him so much! Julian is vile and stupid. Plus unicorns suck kthxbai XP

This

 

[effluo]

Out of these two I'd say Julian. I am not too fond of Octavian.. He looks too angry for me. Suits him though considering he is cranky.

But unicorn over octopus for me..

We need some Pegasus in this game though..

 

[Ami Mercury]

Wow, I just remembered something. I have Marina, another Octopus, in my main town. I might just go with Julian after all. (I know I have a lion in both, and plans for a bunny in both but I might want one that uses the horse model). Not sure yet though.

Now that I think about it he is the only one other the 3 mythical creature villages I don't have, so I am most likely going to go with him.

Also, for the people saying to not take him because he's a unicorn.....shut up. That is one of the reasons I want him.

I might even switch out Snake and take both! Honestly Jocks and Peppys are my least favorites, so I wouldn't be to upset not having either of those personalities.

 

[Leopardfire]

Julian because he's an unicorn, has awesome eyes, and MLP.

 

[itzafennecfox]

Octavian. I've never really liked Julian, I think he's was overrated (and I dislike smugs)

 

[aimeekitty]

I think both are great. I have both in my town, you can visit the dream address and talk to them if you want of course.

They are totally different though. Julian is kind of a flamboyant flirty feeling? and Octavian is cranky but very sincere. I think the Octopus animation is very amusing so if you like Octopi and don't have one? I"d go with Octavian! Some of my best letters I've gotten from Octavian being a cranky with a soft heart. He does have a space house, which I don't prefer? Julians lovely star interior is prettier in my opinion?

anyway, they are totally different and both great. Goodluck!

 

[Zanessa]

Having a town with too many populars is just a nightmare. Julian's okay. The only Julian I had was given to AndrewArcade. I was happy when he left because Julian is just.. no, thank you!

Octavian's pretty cool. I have a small fear of octopi, but he's alright.