I've been visiting the island now forever but always have the same old stuff, is everyone's island like this or do you get exciting things like the mermaid statue?
I always get the same old stuff when I visit my personal island, whereas if I visit the international one, I get uncommon items such as the treasure chest and beach table.
Usually what happens to me is I'll have one of the same items two days in a row, but everything else will be different. Earlier in the week I had the same black wetsuit for two days in a row, but in a different area. Other times I'll have a wetsuit for a bunch of days in a row in the same spot(usually on the far left), but it'll be a different colour.