Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Geoni]

who exactly then?

Namely Dedenne.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Where tf is hikaris replacement anyway

 

[Ace Marvel]

@epona tell your mom, that a random person from the internet that you play forum games with, wishes her a happy birthday.

 

[epona]

Namely Dedenne.

i think dedenne was a straight bus here

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

@epona tell your mom, that a random person from the internet that you play forum games with, wishes her a happy birthday.

will do boss

 

[voltairenism]

I actually get what you guys are saying about more that I comment than directly question, which I... can't really fight that since it is mostly true and is something I need to work on more here. Not as much an issue on my home site where I'm used to the same group of people I've been playing with for literal years for the most part and have significantly less anxiety about questioning any of them lol. though I did directly ask guava something at least once and dedenne. not many examples admittedly, but attempts were made

and this is going to look bad and I know it if shawo is actually mafia and maybe I'm just suuuuper gullible, but the entire cop claim feels so unnecessary for the current state of the game for maf!shawo and I don't know what it accomplished other than an Ace save when the doc situation was very likely to not get resolved this phase anyway and would've let him coast along at least to D3. hope that he actually IS mafia for town's sake, but this wagon feels off to me

my commentary was more in regarding of choosing dedenne. I think it's fair u think he could be town

Important Island Announcement
@Alek is being replaced by @Vrisnem
They are still Stitches.​

poggggg

Feels like everyone is just accepting the chop of an unCC'd cop. Not that I'm a fan of the claim myself so I understand, but the air surrounding it is really stagnant?

maybe the real cop doesnt want to cc since shawo is being so sussed. maybe there isnt a cop at all

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

It's just that there's people I don't trust that I would expect to act differently in reaction to this if they were town? If this is a wolf!Shawo plan, t's shaking up the worlds and I'm wondering if that was intentional.

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

I'm more than happy to vote him regardless.

not sure I understand

 

[Geoni]

I'm not sure I understand Shawo as a player to begin with.

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

This play as either alignment, really.

 

[voltairenism]

i think dedenne was a straight bus here

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

will do boss

shawo did say that dedenne was the most town along guava/dino/dedenne. wonder if he would be this on the nose tho. when I was maf with guava, when i was going down i said everyone should vote guava instead of me

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

although these kind of thoughts should be explored after the flip

 

[Geoni]

But the reality of it is is that he felt like he wanted to survive without giving analysis on actual posts and suspicious behavior (outside of the whack case on me D1) and kept his content stuck within role-claim-play and that just didn't feel like someone trying to solve to me.

Post automatically merged: Sep 25, 2020

SDLFJDSL:FKSJ:L WHY IS IT SO DEAD

 

[Damniel]

what do we do

 

[Chris]

Still not fully caught up, but I think FinalArcadia is mafia.

and this is going to look bad and I know it if shawo is actually mafia and maybe I'm just suuuuper gullible, but the entire cop claim feels so unnecessary for the current state of the game for maf!shawo and I don't know what it accomplished other than an Ace save when the doc situation was very likely to not get resolved this phase anyway and would've let him coast along at least to D3. hope that he actually IS mafia for town's sake, but this wagon feels off to me

On first read, your attention is likely drawn to the middle of the quote where FinalArcadia is giving their opinion. I think the text around it is more telling. Specifically the lines:

• "and this is going to look bad and I know it if shawo is actually mafia and maybe I'm just suuuuper gullible"
• "hope that he actually IS mafia for town's sake, but this wagon feels off to me"

Both of these lines imply to me that FinalArcadia knows shawo's alignment already. Unfortunately both of these lines could give opposite meanings. The first makes me think this is one last ditch attempt at defending a teammate (look back through FinalArcadia's posts and you will see they have been softly defending/siding with shawo throughout, including trying to push attention away from discussing shawo/Damniel situation); the latter reads as mafia knowing that a town player is on the line. Either way I think FinalArcadia knows shawo's alignment already because this uncertainty does not ring true IMO.

My initial thought was that shawo and FinalArcadia are teamed - especially as both have avoided making strong reads on each other. That last line in FinalArcadia's post is throwing me. This might sound a little rambly but IIRC thread is locked at night so I wanted to get this in now rather than tomorrow.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I voted Shawo, we have more room for error, since Vrisnem joined the game.

 

[Geoni]

You would think if people are feeling that Shawo is a wolf they'd be exploring who his partners could be and whatnot at EoD.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Hmmm gives us something to think about once shawo flips whatever

 

[Damniel]

omg a spicy arcadia read reading now

 

[Dinosaurz]

You would think if people are feeling that Shawo is a wolf they'd be exploring who his partners could be and whatnot at EoD.

I’ll be honest I’m lazy

 

[Damniel]

You would think if people are feeling that Shawo is a wolf they'd be exploring who his partners could be and whatnot at EoD.

i think it’s along the lines of hikari/finalarcadia/dedenne maybeeeee guava

 

[Ace Marvel]

You would think if people are feeling that Shawo is a wolf they'd be exploring who his partners could be and whatnot at EoD.

Yes, you and FA/Dedenne

 

[Dinosaurz]

Sorry for saying dan was more likely to be wolf before 👁👁

 

[Geoni]

Still not fully caught up, but I think FinalArcadia is mafia.



On first read, your attention is likely drawn to the middle of the quote where FinalArcadia is giving their opinion. I think the text around it is more telling. Specifically the lines:

• "and this is going to look bad and I know it if shawo is actually mafia and maybe I'm just suuuuper gullible"
• "hope that he actually IS mafia for town's sake, but this wagon feels off to me"

Both of these lines imply to me that FinalArcadia knows shawo's alignment already. Unfortunately both of these lines could give opposite meanings. The first makes me think this is one last ditch attempt at defending a teammate (look back through FinalArcadia's posts and you will see they have been softly defending/siding with shawo throughout, including trying to push attention away from discussing shawo/Damniel situation); the latter reads as mafia knowing that a town player is on the line. Either way I think FinalArcadia knows shawo's alignment already because this uncertainty does not ring true IMO.

My initial thought was that shawo and FinalArcadia are teamed - especially as both have avoided making strong reads on each other. That last line in FinalArcadia's post is throwing me. This might sound a little rambly but IIRC thread is locked at night so I wanted to get this in now rather than tomorrow.

I'm in agreement with FinalArcadia that the wagon feels off however. Do you think everyone on it is just pure Vris?

 

[Damniel]

Yes, you and FA/Dedenne

i don’t reallyyyy think geo and shawo are teamed together. their interactions make it pretty clear