Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Damniel]

@DinoTown can the same clue apply to more than one member of mafia. Like if more then one had pointed ears could you reuse that clue.

i think youre asking about this clue thing too much. the clue here is very vague so better to ask later if anything. i suggest focusing more on looking back at EoD or something

 

[Dinosaurz]

yeah it can be misleading to clue 1 is leading if two mafia members have pointed ears. thats what alek brought attention basically
i dont think this really matters though unless we really want to get a pr mafia

I think it matters a lot. It can suggest not all mafia members have pointed ears

 

[DinoTown]

@DinoTown can the same clue apply to more than one member of mafia. Like if more then one had pointed ears could you reuse that clue.

One individual clue can hint at a trait that multiple members have. However, I would only ever re-use a clue if I was really struggling to come up with another clue. So 99% chance you won't see repeat clues.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Lol maybe I’m being big conspiracy theorist lol

 

[Ace Marvel]

You're interpretation of me making my vote worthwhile is to vote for somebody I didn't sus?

I won't continue this further, there is no point.

 

[epona]

actually i will to an extent

i didn't protect myself. who i protected didn't die like i thought, but im not gonna think to hard about that rn

wait what
obviously they didn't die if you protected them

 

[Geoni]

fwiw, looking at the worlds I'm considering, there's two pointy ears in each world and potentially more (only if Arcadia/epona are in deep)?

guava x dedenne feel like they could work
Ace x shawo feel like they could work

But again the only thing that can be made certain from the clue is that the mafia team isn't a combination of players that has 0 pointed ears among them.

 

[dedenne]

I still didn't like the post though, which felt really pointed. Is guava posting only one post of substance how she normally acts as town for you?

yeah im just used to the memes and s posting. it didnt really stick out as maf motivated

 

[Antonio]

I think it matters a lot. It can suggest not all mafia members have pointed ears

This clue does matter and we should gather a list of all players with gathered ears. My point was that for the next clue, we shouldn't assume it's about the same person but only consider.

 

[voltairenism]

so abt dedenne

actually didnt dedenne just went "haha i did went 360 on my read on cake right nevermind im going no chop for consistency"

i said this while trying to find a new wagon besides all the current ones and but funny enough it didnt get much attention. I still find the behaviour weird but i thought dedenne was an easy d1 wagon so i didnt want to push her too much

 

[Damniel]

wait what
obviously they didn't die if you protected them

i thought they wouldve been the target, but wolves went onto glow is what i meant

 

[Antonio]

"gathered ears" .-.

 

[voltairenism]

I think it matters a lot. It can suggest not all mafia members have pointed ears

yeah obvs

 

[Dinosaurz]

This clue does matter and we should gather a list of all players with gathered ears. My point was that for the next clue, we shouldn't assume it's about the same person but only consider.

Yeah I didn’t think that either...

it was because dinotown said there is a list of clues and I was wondering if the list of clues for each member could have a repeating clue for more than one. Not seeing same clue twice.

 

[epona]

i thought they wouldve been the target, but wolves went onto glow is what i meant

oh okay i was like .. sir

 

[voltairenism]

chat is moving so fast no one will see this dan is ugly

 

[Antonio]

I won't continue this further, there is no point.

No no no because this is important. You wanted me to make my vote, worthwhile. Why did you think i would assume that making my vote worthwhile involves Geoni, someone who was barely online last phase.

 

[Ace Marvel]

FinalArcadia (Lolly)
Dedenne (Anhka)
Ace Marvel (Colton)
guav@ (Monique)
Geoni (Dobie)
Epona (Whitney)
shawo (Raymond)

One of those 3

 

[Damniel]

chat is moving so fast no one will see this dan is ugly

my M.D. is my greatest feature

 

[Antonio]

Yeah I didn’t think that either...

it was because dinotown said there is a list of clues and I was wondering if the list of clues for each member could have a repeating clue for more than one. Not seeing same clue twice.

Wait, where's the list of clues? Does that mean there are more then one in the story?