Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

Interested in seeing what kind of game is going on, I might be able to be present for a little while
voltairenism said:
this would be true if you were proved town
Click to expand...
But how would people responding really hurt even if Alek ended up being mafia? It seems pretty harmless to respond as town, like it seems like mafia would have more incentive generally to not respond, in case they said something that reflected back on them about their own behavior as mafia/following town meta

I kinda see Alek's point about Dedenne and Epona in regards to that whole Q&A thing, though Epona other than that seems fine to me
 
alright lit one more person
Post automatically merged:

FinalArcadia said:
Interested in seeing what kind of game is going on, I might be able to be present for a little while

But how would people responding really hurt even if Alek ended up being mafia? It seems pretty harmless to respond as town, like it seems like mafia would have more incentive generally to not respond, in case they said something that reflected back on them about their own behavior as mafia/following town meta

I kinda see Alek's point about Dedenne and Epona in regards to that whole Q&A thing, though Epona other than that seems fine to me
Click to expand...
if everyone else is responding i think mafia would feel pressured to respond anyway. im sure at least one of the people asked are maf
 
FinalArcadia said:
Interested in seeing what kind of game is going on, I might be able to be present for a little while

But how would people responding really hurt even if Alek ended up being mafia? It seems pretty harmless to respond as town, like it seems like mafia would have more incentive generally to not respond, in case they said something that reflected back on them about their own behavior as mafia/following town meta

I kinda see Alek's point about Dedenne and Epona in regards to that whole Q&A thing, though Epona other than that seems fine to me
Click to expand...
he said that "if we are all town, why not answer it" hence assuming everyone believes he is town. that's just the failure with the argument, I'm not saying it is bad to answer if he was maf. also if it's a harmless question why mafia would not answer it? and wouldnt mafia answer for towny points? thats why it's not AI, because you can reason anything with the fact that someone answered it or not.
 
voltairenism said:
he said that "if we are all town, why not answer it" hence assuming everyone believes he is town. that's just the failure with the argument, I'm not saying it is bad to answer if he was maf. also if it's a harmless question why mafia would not answer it? and wouldnt mafia answer for towny points? thats why it's not AI, because you can reason anything with the fact that someone answered it or not.
Click to expand...
The point of the sus read is that I'm more inclined to believe that town wouldn't be against intentional pressure compared to others but town would be more for the pressure. It's also important that Dedenne and Epona were against the pressure on Damniel compared to Glow unless i am missing something
Post automatically merged:

Hikari said:
just to confirm, i was using the "singular" they to refer to dino. also im a guy haha
Click to expand...
i'm terribly sorry.
 
Alek said:
The point of the sus read is that I'm more inclined to believe that town wouldn't be against intentional pressure compared to others but town would be more for the pressure. It's also important that Dedenne and Epona were against the pressure on Damniel compared to Glow unless i am missing something
Post automatically merged:


i'm terribly sorry.
Click to expand...
you're good, i can understand why you made that mistake lol
 
shawo wanna play a game with us we can begin right away
Post automatically merged:

the epona vote is pretty spicy im interested in it
 
ok I read up to page 11 and got bored but here's some opening thoughts.

Hikari was the person who I was upset about outting fast reads, but I also don't inherently think it means they're mafia.

Second. I think that up to page 11, the person who's been making reads the quickest was epona. I've been less than impressed with just like, how fast she'd out a read. less than a page of interaction and she would say town x town etc. I'm gonna hold my vote here since this is (only an observation up to page 11).

Also no, I don't think it's a good idea to only solve the game with riddles. But you bet your a I'm gonna solve the riddle on d2.
 
Alek said:
The point of the sus read is that I'm more inclined to believe that town wouldn't be against intentional pressure compared to others but town would be more for the pressure. It's also important that Dedenne and Epona were against the pressure on Damniel compared to Glow unless i am missing something
Post automatically merged:


i'm terribly sorry.
Click to expand...
i think the reactions for pushing or not questions can indeed be analyzed somewhat
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

voltairenism
Mafia Zelda Mountainous Mafia
Replies
4
Views
876
Wiisp
Wiisp
Fridaynightcatlady
My pitch for Animal Crossing for the Switch 2 - Animal Crossing: Let's Go Exploring!
Replies
0
Views
285
Fridaynightcatlady
Fridaynightcatlady
Awesome Gamer 2009
Funny game challenges you made up?
Replies
0
Views
91
Awesome Gamer 2009
Awesome Gamer 2009
iocatio
Hello!
Replies
2
Views
275
Mimi Cheems
Mimi Cheems
M
Giveaway ✨How It's Done The Island Watch Party✨
Replies
1
Views
1K
Phoenix45
P
Back
Top