Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[shawo]

Btw: given the case where Dan is really doc I think the most likely scenario is that we have no cop.

In that case it doesn't make sense for mafia to have multiple blackmailers (cuz that'd be broken.) And it doesn't really make sense for mafia to have (more than) 1 GF (just to throw mafia off the fact that there's no cop.) Meaning that mafia most likely has VM and not just a bunch of prs.

Of course the more likely situation is that there's only one doc.

 

[voltairenism]

Yeah if both doc claims then they can protect themselves for the entire game, basically making the "not the same vote in the row" rule useless

aka one of them must be lying then

 

[Damniel]

are we lying though? im not sure

 

[Dinosaurz]

I am shooketh

 

[shawo]

NTM the blackmailers can just go on docs. There's actually probably any easy way to confirm daniel.

Daniel claiming as PR means that mafia would've had to blackmail them if they weren't going to kill him, so if there's a way that we can test if Daniel's vote is really blackmailed it could work. I think this is likely super stupid though.

Anyways, I have a bunch of reads from d1 I'm going to get to, since I didn't get to post them yesterday.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Can’t both docs alternate heals on both of them for the whole game lol

 

[Antonio]

aka one of them must be lying then

Yes but check the op, Dino said there could be duplicates.

 

[Damniel]

Can’t both docs alternate heals on both of them for the whole game lol

yes but we love WIFOM kills

 

[epona]

i just refuse to believe that 2 docs is balanced

Post automatically merged: Sep 23, 2020

this just got S P I C Y though

 

[Damniel]

i just refuse to believe that 2 docs is balanced

its not really something to worry about for today

 

[shawo]

Sorting in docs is kinda useless rn, you can just treat us as a 1 mafia/1 doc cc. The only downside is that if (daniel) gets confirmed, they can lead a kill and waste our riddle.

Either way, in the worst case we can just use it to keep a pr alive for the rest of the game.

 

[Antonio]

@Damniel was your protection successful or not?

@shawo same for you?

In a 14+ player game, mafia only having 1KP seems unbalanced aswell.

 

[voltairenism]

Yes but check the op, Dino said there could be duplicates.

yeah but headcanon is that shawo stumbled upon this information in mafia chat and claimed to his advantage, or daniel is lying
for now it's better to consider it true and see it being proven, but it's so broken lol

 

[Damniel]

@Damniel was your protection successful or not?

@shawo same for you?

In a 14+ player game, mafia only having 1KP seems unbalanced aswell.

i did not protect glow so no

 

[epona]

@Damniel was your protection successful or not?

@shawo same for you?

In a 14+ player game, mafia only having 1KP seems unbalanced aswell.

especially if there's multiple town power roles
i feel like we are possibly dealing with a 4-person team

 

[Dinosaurz]

I am confused

 

[Antonio]

i did not protect glow so no

That's the point, I'm thinking mafia may have 2kp and one of their attempts failed and either your guys hit was successful or they hit the bodyguard role.

 

[voltairenism]

btw dinotown said "there could be multiples of a role" hence we can be dealing with an all pr mafia (if there more than 3 i mean). with clues and two doctors it's too townsided

 

[Damniel]

i still have a protect on me so im willing to WIFOM whether i protect shawo or myself or someone else

 

[Dinosaurz]

i thought dinotown said mafiia had 1kp before