Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[voltairenism]

i actually yelled “WOW” out loud when i read this

hey queen

 

[glow]

If we mischop today and rest of game:

5 v 3 on D4

If we dont chop today and mischop rest of game:

4 v 3 on D5

ok so n4 would be a loss if blackmailer is in play and we don't kill today

i don't think we gain much then

 

[Antonio]

play the same way***

 

[Damniel]

i actually yelled “WOW” out loud when i read this

i actually do agree with this. this is basically a policy vote. you should be voting for who you think is a wolf

 

[dedenne]

Those should be irrelevant because those games consist of different individuals with different playstyles. Plus, people stated that they don't tend to play way every game so having a solid opinion regarding towns behavior is hard to come up with unless you are an informed minority.

after playing a certain amount of games wouldnt u know how town tend to act and have a good idea of town motivations and maf motivations? idk im not dan

 

[Damniel]

ok so n4 would be a loss if blackmailer is in play and we don't kill today

i don't think we gain much then

this is assuming there is a blackmailer yes. i guess this is a fair point

 

[Antonio]

after playing a certain amount of games wouldnt u know how town tend to act and have a good idea of town motivations and maf motivations? idk im not dan

I have played a bunch of games and I can say their is no unify way for town to act.

 

[voltairenism]

i actually do agree with this. this is basically a policy vote. you should be voting for who you think is a wolf

it's not a new thing that i advocate for policy chop but I dont think we should do it
yet I have no clue on who to vote

 

[Damniel]

town can be weird for no reason. unravel was killed in kingmaker largely for writing in white texts. did it mean anything? no. why did she do it? who knows that's just how she wanted to play but there wasn't an explicit wolf motivation for writing in white which i think alot of people didn't consider. like just because you dont understand what something is doing doesnt mean they're a wolf

 

[g u a v a]

hi i’m awake i see everyone still wants me to be here more and i feel loved <3 *teary eyed*

ok yes i will grant glows wish and post a read list in a bit. i just finished reading so give me a sec. :> ngl doe the reason i don’t want to say much d1 is bc every1 always wants to chop me!!!

anyway brb i’m cOnTrIbUtInG!!!

 

[glow]

this is assuming there is a blackmailer yes. i guess this is a fair point

there are a LOT of variables that could potentially change everything too, like lucky, doctor -> at least one is very likely to be in the game and also vig potential which could change the phase counts.

imo there's not a strong case to no kill today.

 

[dedenne]

I have played a bunch of games and I can say their is no unify way for town to act.

of course theres not. but u should eventually gain a typical idea, idk anymore. u just have to think ab whether their actions are town or maf motivated i guess

 

[glow]

voting u @MyLifeIsCake

thoughts? who would u rather die instead of u

 

[voltairenism]

policy chop is more suited for something like what ness did
guava is just being herself

yes im arguing with myself

 

[Damniel]

glow when you said that something about epona seems off and she's tired, im a little unclear on what you mean by this

 

[voltairenism]

what is dedenne dan and alek even talking about omg we have two hours

 

[Ace Marvel]

Go Alek! <3 Thanks for seeing the light!

 

[Damniel]

what is dedenne dan and alek even talking about omg we have two hours

personally i dont even understand alek's point on me despite reading it

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

voting u @MyLifeIsCake
No u

thoughts? who would u rather die instead of u

 

[Antonio]

town can be weird for no reason. unravel was killed in kingmaker largely for writing in white texts. did it mean anything? no. why did she do it? who knows that's just how she wanted to play but there wasn't an explicit wolf motivation for writing in white which i think alot of people didn't consider. like just because you dont understand what something is doing doesnt mean they're a wolf

There is no certain way for Town to act due to that game having different people then here. Basicing your opinions around a majority based on past behavior from a different majority not only hurts your reads but hurts your perspective when interpreting the game.

We should be basicing our opinions on people motivations and determining if the motivation is coming from a town or mafia perspective of gameplay.

Post automatically merged: Sep 22, 2020

of course theres not. but u should eventually gain a typical idea, idk anymore. u just have to think ab whether their actions are town or maf motivated i guess

Exactly, hence the question. Wouldn't mafia most likely have a more solid idea on how town should be playing rather than the actual town?