Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Geoni]

Multiple blackmailers doesn't counteract the issue I brought up one bit because blackmailing is a DAY action and what I'm talking about has to do with a soloing wolf being locked out of ever being able to kill, which you understood completely in your 'NO U' post I quoted. It's such a reach and idk why you're taking it just for the sake of making it to day 4.

Idk if mafia can realistically win at day 4 but if Hikari and Alek both get modkilled and they're both town then they probably could.

 

[epona]

my GOD i wish this was a PM game

Post automatically merged: Sep 24, 2020

i really really think it's shawo/ace

 

[Geoni]

So either you believe I went super deep on trying to convince everyone there was no rolecop. Or!!! I didn't know!!!

Nobody is thinking that. What I'm thinking is you're acting like you didn't read what roles were on the table to play with as someone who lives and breathes playing with claims regardless of alignment.

 

[shawo]

Because of your theory?

 

[g u a v a]

i’ve been sussing ace since the get go and self votes are never a good town sign so... his time has come.

 

[epona]

Because of your theory?

among other things

 

[shawo]

So you're trying to say that I'm mafia because I didn't know about a mafia role in the game?

I mean isn't that even more of a reach than anything else. If I was mafia why would I PRETEND not to know about a mafia role? To dumbtell? Do I seem like the kind of person to dumbtell?

 

[epona]

Btw: given the case where Dan is really doc I think the most likely scenario is that we have no cop.

In that case it doesn't make sense for mafia to have multiple blackmailers (cuz that'd be broken.) And it doesn't really make sense for mafia to have (more than) 1 GF (just to throw mafia off the fact that there's no cop.) Meaning that mafia most likely has VM and not just a bunch of prs.

Of course the more likely situation is that there's only one doc.

this postttttttttttttttttt

 

[voltairenism]

So either you believe I went super deep on trying to convince everyone there was no rolecop. Or!!! I didn't know!!!

my theory was that you know there isnt a rolecop so you forgot.

that breaks epona's ace/shawo team theory btw

 

[shawo]

Epona your theory is FLAWED. It's just mechanically impossible. Not to mention you didn't even continue that thought. You're just, THROWING things out?

Do you want to elaborate.

You're the second person who's made that teamread, and I don't think either one has been justified.

 

[Damniel]

 

[epona]

Do you want to elaborate.

no i do not < 3

 

[shawo]

my theory was that you know there isnt a rolecop so you forgot.

that breaks epona's ace/shawo team theory btw

That's more realistic. But if there's no rolecop then there's no reason to sort in docs.

Post automatically merged: Sep 24, 2020

I think I'm gonna vote Epona.

She's either softing alignment cop, which she should hardclaim because there are docs in the game. Or she's mafia. Softing alignment cop.

 

[Damniel]

this is not how i expected the doc CC to end up like

 

[g u a v a]

View attachment 322161

i’m on my way!!

 

[voltairenism]

That's more realistic. But if there's no rolecop then there's no reason to sort in docs.

hence why you were brave to claim 2nd doc. we are going in circles lol

 

[Geoni]

So you're trying to say that I'm mafia because I didn't know about a mafia role in the game?

I mean isn't that even more of a reach than anything else. If I was mafia why would I PRETEND not to know about a mafia role? To dumbtell? Do I seem like the kind of person to dumbtell?

You seem like you didn't think about the optics of your plan moreso than forgetting a role existed to begin with. If you can get people to suspend their disbelief that's all you really need to do to last long in this game.

 

[shawo]

Given the fact that you believe I'm mafia. The most realistic test in the game is to just have me and Daniel alternate saving on alignment cop. In the best case the game just ends, in the worst case mafia sacks and daniel gets confirmed.

Either way we get mafia without using an ML + we get riddles.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Just kill me, then Geoni.

 

[Geoni]

You have to be a doctor to save.