Is this town map ok

[mw2016]

I restarted my town and can't choose a town map

 

[Tri-Cell]

I like it especially the long beach front, mine is split up and it's annoying plus retail, the town hall and train station are quite close which is handy.

 

[ZebraQueen]

Honestly from me
It's a hate and love map
I can't decide

 

[mw2016]

Same, I like where retail, plaza and town hall are but I don't like the river

 

[Heyden]

The river makes everything have too narrow spaces.

 

[Charcolor]

i think it looks good, unless you like to make bells by catching beetles on the island. then you have to make several long trips to retail without any villagers pinging you asking you to trade a moldy shirt for your golden stag. (i mean, you could always say no, but the ping just wastes time)

plus, there's a couple narrow spaces. i'm okay with it, but you might not be.

 

[mw2016]

i think it looks good, unless you like to make bells by catching beetles on the island. then you have to make several long trips to retail without any villagers pinging you asking you to trade a moldy shirt for your golden stag. (i mean, you could always say no, but the ping just wastes time)

plus, there's a couple narrow spaces. i'm okay with it, but you might not be.

yeah I know what you mean. do you think this one is any better?

 

[Chris01]

I restarted my town and can't choose a town map
View attachment 170119

Hey, if you want my opinion, this is a crap town map, I personally hate when it looks so cramped, plus the location of the bridge sucks becuase you have to run all the way back on yourself just to get to a villagers house. Keep looking at maps, you'll find one ventually, if you want some advice, try to get a town with a diagonal bridge they are the best I reckon!

 

[mw2016]

Hey, if you want my opinion, this is a crap town map, I personally hate when it looks so cramped, plus the location of the bridge sucks becuase you have to run all the way back on yourself just to get to a villagers house. Keep looking at maps, you'll find one ventually, if you want some advice, try to get a town with a diagonal bridge they are the best I reckon!

Thanks, just posted another picture of a different one. What do you think of that one?

 

[Chris01]

yeah I know what you mean. do you think this one is any better?
View attachment 170121

Its slightly better as everything shops wise and town hall is right near the town gate But again all the villager houses are on the second half of the town which can be a hassle BUT the bridge is alot lower in this map so, it looks good, but again I wouldn't go with this town map, try to find a town map where the startr villagr homs are sort of spread around the town rather than all grouped in one part of the town

 

[kazaf]

I restarted my town and can't choose a town map
View attachment 170119

I personally think there is too much bends and corners, I would prefer a plain and open field. It will be hard for me to landscape on this map. But if you like corners and bends, then it's ok.

ReTail is a bit far from the pier as well. Bug catching off the island and then selling would be a long walk and hassle.

That's just my personal opinion.

 

[k.k.lucario]

honestly you should get the one i have
where the river is in a "U" shape

but hey thats my opinion