Interesting super mario galaxy 2 rumour

[Tyeforce]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

So...? There's no reason why a canon Mario/Sonic crossover can't be good.

If they do something which mixes BOTH games then it will be killed.
Mario collecting Rings? Sonic eating mushrooms?!
but if they balence it right i tihnk it could be ok

It worked in SSBB and M&SatOWG. Why can't it work in another game, canon or not?

It never worked in Brawl. He wasn't even in 99% of the story. "Hurr, I coem saev everone from Tabu"
More like, "I was added in late in the development so that's the only scene I get."

Not the story, but the gameplay. You could replay any stage as Sonic after you beat Tabuu, you know...

 

[Neko Yuki Pyrozanryu]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

If they do something which mixes BOTH games then it will be killed.
Mario collecting Rings? Sonic eating mushrooms?!
but if they balence it right i tihnk it could be ok

It worked in SSBB and M&SatOWG. Why can't it work in another game, canon or not?

It never worked in Brawl. He wasn't even in 99% of the story. "Hurr, I coem saev everone from Tabu"
More like, "I was added in late in the development so that's the only scene I get."

Not the story, but the gameplay. You could replay any stage as Sonic after you beat Tabuu, you know...

Actually Tye you have a good point About sonics Tabuu scene.

 

[-Aaron]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

If they do something which mixes BOTH games then it will be killed.
Mario collecting Rings? Sonic eating mushrooms?!
but if they balence it right i tihnk it could be ok

It worked in SSBB and M&SatOWG. Why can't it work in another game, canon or not?

It never worked in Brawl. He wasn't even in 99% of the story. "Hurr, I coem saev everone from Tabu"
More like, "I was added in late in the development so that's the only scene I get."

Not the story, but the gameplay. You could replay any stage as Sonic after you beat Tabuu, you know...

So what if you can play as him after the game? It doesn't change the story that he looks tacked on.

 

[Tyeforce]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

It worked in SSBB and M&SatOWG. Why can't it work in another game, canon or not?

It never worked in Brawl. He wasn't even in 99% of the story. "Hurr, I coem saev everone from Tabu"
More like, "I was added in late in the development so that's the only scene I get."

Not the story, but the gameplay. You could replay any stage as Sonic after you beat Tabuu, you know...

So what if you can play as him after the game? It doesn't change the story that he looks tacked on.

I know, but I was talking about gameplay, not story. If you want a good example of a Mario/Sonic story, look at M&SatOWG for DS.

 

[Ciaran]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

 

[-Aaron]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

If it does, I'm going to boycott Nintendo games for a while.

 

[Ciaran]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

If it does, I'm going to boycott Nintendo games for a while.

Nintendo knows not to do that to us...

What did we ever do to deserve it?

 

[Tyeforce]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

If it does, I'm going to boycott Nintendo games for a while.

Why? Nintendo can make a better Sonic game than Sega can, anyway. I don't see why having Sonic in Super Mario Galaxy 2 would be such a terrible thing. It would be awesome.

 

[-Aaron]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

If it does, I'm going to boycott Nintendo games for a while.

Nintendo knows not to do that to us...

What did we ever do to deserve it?

We bought their products and they want more.

EDIT: Tye, that's coming from the person that lives and breathes Sonic and Nintendo. I'm coming from the side that thinks good games don't need to be crapped upon.

 

[Ciaran]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

If it does, I'm going to boycott Nintendo games for a while.

Nintendo knows not to do that to us...

What did we ever do to deserve it?

We bought their products and they want more.

SMG got universal acclaim...

Sonic... yeah...

They arent so stupid as to put him in there, and they owe us for their lackluster performance for a while...

And how would all the suits etc. work with sonic??

Sonic is suppposed to feel all fast and stuff....

 

[Tyeforce]

Back on topic: Its obviously not gonna happen

If it does, I'm going to boycott Nintendo games for a while.

Nintendo knows not to do that to us...

What did we ever do to deserve it?

We bought their products and they want more.

SMG got universal acclaim...

Sonic... yeah...

They arent so stupid as to put him in there, and they owe us for their lackluster performance for a while...

And how would all the suits etc. work with sonic??

Sonic is suppposed to feel all fast and stuff....

Putting Sonic in the game wouldn't make it automatically bad. >_> But you are right when you say that Super Mario Galaxy is liked by more people than the recent Sonic games (that's not saying that they're bad, just that they just don't appeal to everyone and a lot of people aren't even giving them a chance). Why is that? Because Miyamoto is awesome. He knows what he's doing. If Sonic is in SMG2, it will be by Nintendo's ways, not Sega's.

 

[Ciaran]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

Nintendo knows not to do that to us...

What did we ever do to deserve it?

We bought their products and they want more.

SMG got universal acclaim...

Sonic... yeah...

They arent so stupid as to put him in there, and they owe us for their lackluster performance for a while...

And how would all the suits etc. work with sonic??

Sonic is suppposed to feel all fast and stuff....

Putting Sonic in the game wouldn't make it automatically bad. >_> But you are right when you say that Super Mario Galaxy is liked by more people than the recent Sonic games (that's not saying that they're bad, just that they just don't appeal to everyone and a lot of people aren't even giving them a chance). Why is that? Because Miyamoto is awesome. He knows what he's doing. If Sonic is in SMG2, it will be by Nintendo's ways, not Sega's.

Sonic wouldnt fit in.

Full Stop.

 

[Tyeforce]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

We bought their products and they want more.

SMG got universal acclaim...

Sonic... yeah...

They arent so stupid as to put him in there, and they owe us for their lackluster performance for a while...

And how would all the suits etc. work with sonic??

Sonic is suppposed to feel all fast and stuff....

Putting Sonic in the game wouldn't make it automatically bad. >_> But you are right when you say that Super Mario Galaxy is liked by more people than the recent Sonic games (that's not saying that they're bad, just that they just don't appeal to everyone and a lot of people aren't even giving them a chance). Why is that? Because Miyamoto is awesome. He knows what he's doing. If Sonic is in SMG2, it will be by Nintendo's ways, not Sega's.

Sonic wouldnt fit in.

Full Stop.

Sonic characters and elements fit perfectly with Mario characters and elements in M&SatOWG. IT CAN WORK.

 

[Ciaran]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

SMG got universal acclaim...

Sonic... yeah...

They arent so stupid as to put him in there, and they owe us for their lackluster performance for a while...

And how would all the suits etc. work with sonic??

Sonic is suppposed to feel all fast and stuff....

Putting Sonic in the game wouldn't make it automatically bad. >_> But you are right when you say that Super Mario Galaxy is liked by more people than the recent Sonic games (that's not saying that they're bad, just that they just don't appeal to everyone and a lot of people aren't even giving them a chance). Why is that? Because Miyamoto is awesome. He knows what he's doing. If Sonic is in SMG2, it will be by Nintendo's ways, not Sega's.

Sonic wouldnt fit in.

Full Stop.

Sonic characters and elements fit perfectly with Mario characters and elements in M&SatOWG. IT CAN WORK.

3D platformer =/= a collection of sports based mini games.

 

[Tyeforce]

Quoting limited to 5 levels deep

Putting Sonic in the game wouldn't make it automatically bad. >_> But you are right when you say that Super Mario Galaxy is liked by more people than the recent Sonic games (that's not saying that they're bad, just that they just don't appeal to everyone and a lot of people aren't even giving them a chance). Why is that? Because Miyamoto is awesome. He knows what he's doing. If Sonic is in SMG2, it will be by Nintendo's ways, not Sega's.

Sonic wouldnt fit in.

Full Stop.

Sonic characters and elements fit perfectly with Mario characters and elements in M&SatOWG. IT CAN WORK.

3D platformer =/= a collection of sports based mini games.

You haven't played it, so really can't compare it to anything. You could take away the sports in the DS adventure mode and it wouldn't affect anything at all. The Olympic sports games were just tacked on to make it fit the game. The sport gameplay and the adventure/role playing gameplay are completely independent of each other. Like I said, you could remove the sports and it would be a normal adventure game. The actually story and adventure was very interesting and worked out very well, even if it was just a small dose of what could happen.

 

[Bacon Boy]

Tye: there really was no dragonball z in it, just the effects

 

[Tyeforce]

Tye: there really was no dragonball z in it, just the effects

The music is from DBZ, too, isn't it? And the whole theme of the story is very DBZ-ish.

 

[Micah]

Ew...if this is true I won't be buying SMG2. >_<

 

[Tyeforce]

Ew...if this is true I won't be buying SMG2. >_<

...WHY?! >_>

 

[Megamannt125]

Tye: there really was no dragonball z in it, just the effects

The music is from DBZ, too, isn't it? And the whole theme of the story is very DBZ-ish.

Some of it was. Most was Mario and Sonic music.
<object type='application/x-shockwave-flash' width="250" height="250" data='http://www.youtube.com/v/zQ0sHYiwpCM'>
<param name='AllowScriptAccess' value='never' />
<param name='wmode' value='transparent' />
<param name='movie' value='http://www.youtube.com/v/zQ0sHYiwpCM' /><param name='play' value='true' />
<param name='loop' value='true' /><param name='quality' value='high' /></object>