INSANE LUCK! SHOULD I KEEP IT?

[Allure]

So, I've spent weeks before when trying for a perfect map. This was the 7th map I came across when map resetting. I've never seen anything this perfect! Look at the houses! I named it PixiIsle.... IDK if I like the name or not...I don't like ANY of the villagers, and I don't plan on TTing or buying villagers... What do you think of the name, villagers, and layout? Should I keep it?

 

[Pancake225]

Personally every time I reset my map I find this layout VERY common.
I'm not a fan at all in my honest opinion. The pond in front of the train station is very uncomfortable , I also don't like the cracky grass outlines.
The villages are OK. If you like it then keep it. If you don't then you can cycle through more maps.
Keep in mind that this is my opinion. It's not meant to let you down. If you believe this is the perfect map for you then go with it and have fun.

 

[Allure]

Personally every time I reset my map I find this layout VERY common.
I'm not a fan at all in my honest opinion. The pond in front of the train station is very uncomfortable , I also don't like the cracky grass outlines.
The villages are OK. If you like it then keep it. If you don't then you can cycle through more maps.
Keep in mind that this is my opinion. It's not meant to let you down. If you believe this is the perfect map for you then go with it and have fun.

I hate the villagers, but my main thing was they way the houses were alligned. Not a fan of the rest of the layout. I perfer having all my houses on one side of the river, and they were all like this so... IDK I HATE the villagers.... Leaning towards looking for better map.

 

[HappyTails]

If you like this map that's all that matters. And villagers houses can be aligned like that on any map if you place patterns down and plot reset them into a line like that.

 

[Allure]

If you like this map that's all that matters. And villagers houses can be aligned like that on any map if you place patterns down and plot reset them into a line like that.

Thanks, Happy, I am looking for a better map! If you guys are interested, I'll show you the map I choose!

 

[luna-melody]

thats the town map I have. I put my house right by bump thing and the villagers houses underneath.

 

[Mu~]

I love Gayle. And not sure if that's the diagonal waterfall, but I don't like that the closest spot to the waterfall is taken by a villager house.

 

[Selky]

Not personally a fan of the name. Just not my cup of tea but all that matters is that it is yours. So, if you love it, that's all that matters. I don't really pay much attention to town names anyhow. The map isn't really my tastes either. It's not really an issue with the map but rather the placements of the retail, plaza, and hall. I just love all the buildings being aligned at the top and I prefer maps in most cases that has the event plaza under the town hall. But that's me. Even for maps that I wouldn't personally choose, I've seen people cleverly landscaped and develop them in ways that are really enjoyable to explore. So, just goes to show that it's what you do with it ultimately and anything can be worked with. Villagers don't really matter as usually you don't end up keeping them. Good luck!