Qvaric_Storyteller
Senior Member
~Dreaming of Freeland~
All those paths with the emblems, the sense of Harry Potter is really strong. I just walked around your town for a little while to get a feel for it. Your PWPs don't seem to give a sense of the books/ films very well, but I understand it can be difficult to do that when the game sets the limits, not you.
Hermoine's house: That main room was kind of weird. I haven't read the books or seen the films, so there are a lot of things I'm not going to understand when I see them. Maybe that's why that room makes no sense to me. I don't know. In terms of layout, though, it's fairly good. It is a little difficult to navigate around the tables, but I made my way through okay.
The room on the left. I'm getting a classroom sort of feel, which does remind me of Harry Potter. There wasn't anything bad about it. It lacked interest, but it was original, which is good. I like how you haven't just thrown random sets together. Each room obviously has a set idea of what it is meant to be, and I like that. The room out the back sort of breaks that flow. It just doesn't seem finished. Upstairs feels pretty good, but I was just thinking maybe you could move the sort of sci-fi/ observatory room from the right on the bottom floor up to the second floor, since you'd want to be up high if you were doing that sort of thing. Just a suggestion.
Josh's house: That main room was quite eerie. In fact, the whole house is like that. I think you've definitely lost the plot with the Harry Potter theme in this house. That hospital... and then the cemetery in the opposite room... Oh God *shudder*. That's just so creepy. Your chess room; you're missing your rooks and bishops. Also, it's very dark in there.
Hagrid's house: It was small but comfy. There's not really much else to say. It was rather dark in there.
Jasa's house: NOW I'm feeling the Harry Potter theme. It's very prominent in this room. The pumpkins and floating candles just ARE Harry Potter to me. As for the library, well the layout is pretty good. I mean, it's a library. It's interesting in that paradoxically dry sort of way that libraries are. Ah yes, the bathroom. It has that real public bathroom feel that you'd expect a school to have. The basement was really good, too. I think this is the house that resonates with that idea of what Harry Potter is the most.
As I was wandering around, I was going to suggest to you that you have something near your station with nine and three quarters on it, but of course you've already thought of that. I thought that was really cool.
Overall, not a bad town. There is a feeling of Harry Potter here. I know it's hard to carry a theme through a town, and you've done it really well in places. Other places, not so much. My favourite place was the station with the 9/3/4 signs, and I'll upload that soon.
All those paths with the emblems, the sense of Harry Potter is really strong. I just walked around your town for a little while to get a feel for it. Your PWPs don't seem to give a sense of the books/ films very well, but I understand it can be difficult to do that when the game sets the limits, not you.
Hermoine's house: That main room was kind of weird. I haven't read the books or seen the films, so there are a lot of things I'm not going to understand when I see them. Maybe that's why that room makes no sense to me. I don't know. In terms of layout, though, it's fairly good. It is a little difficult to navigate around the tables, but I made my way through okay.
The room on the left. I'm getting a classroom sort of feel, which does remind me of Harry Potter. There wasn't anything bad about it. It lacked interest, but it was original, which is good. I like how you haven't just thrown random sets together. Each room obviously has a set idea of what it is meant to be, and I like that. The room out the back sort of breaks that flow. It just doesn't seem finished. Upstairs feels pretty good, but I was just thinking maybe you could move the sort of sci-fi/ observatory room from the right on the bottom floor up to the second floor, since you'd want to be up high if you were doing that sort of thing. Just a suggestion.
Josh's house: That main room was quite eerie. In fact, the whole house is like that. I think you've definitely lost the plot with the Harry Potter theme in this house. That hospital... and then the cemetery in the opposite room... Oh God *shudder*. That's just so creepy. Your chess room; you're missing your rooks and bishops. Also, it's very dark in there.
Hagrid's house: It was small but comfy. There's not really much else to say. It was rather dark in there.
Jasa's house: NOW I'm feeling the Harry Potter theme. It's very prominent in this room. The pumpkins and floating candles just ARE Harry Potter to me. As for the library, well the layout is pretty good. I mean, it's a library. It's interesting in that paradoxically dry sort of way that libraries are. Ah yes, the bathroom. It has that real public bathroom feel that you'd expect a school to have. The basement was really good, too. I think this is the house that resonates with that idea of what Harry Potter is the most.
As I was wandering around, I was going to suggest to you that you have something near your station with nine and three quarters on it, but of course you've already thought of that. I thought that was really cool.
Overall, not a bad town. There is a feeling of Harry Potter here. I know it's hard to carry a theme through a town, and you've done it really well in places. Other places, not so much. My favourite place was the station with the 9/3/4 signs, and I'll upload that soon.